I see this as an exercise in technology and history, and a celebration of what was certainly an innovative idea in da Vinci's time. Really, it makes more sense to think of the viola organista as a synthesizer or a sampler, invented centuries before the modern electric and electronic incarnations.
On the more practical side, before synthesizers and samplers, this would probably have been a ground-breaking tool for composers. To be able to play and hear rough arrangements of string pieces (again, not to replace string musicians, but rather to easily hear a much closer approximation than any contemporary keyboard instrument could produce) would no doubt have been amazing for composers in that period.
There are plenty of possible variables in how you play it - the sharpness, speed and strength of hitting keys... the rate at which you spin the bow... and damping. It might be considered more complex than a piano.
note: Actually interesting to read the Youtube comments on this.
Definitely. Or even as a kind of crude sequencer, as demonstrated (I believe unintentionally) by this test clip of a similar instrument: [1]
The instrument is called a geigenwerk, which I gather is approximately just a smaller viola organista. The builder's page [2] has excellent documentation of the inner mechanism, which sadly was absent from the video of the OP.
[1]http://obuchi.music.coocan.jp/Geigenwerk/Geigenwerk3/Image/M...
This critique is using a 1820+ vocabulary for what I would call a "Baroque" instrument. "The right way to evoke feeling is by using expressive articulation on an expressive, lyrical melody line (among other differences)." It perfectly befits a Baroque keyboard instrument to work better with ornamentation and polyphony.
As a side note, I think the tone could gain a lot from gut strings. I don't think period strings work as well with steel.
The hurdy-gurdy also allows some variation by using more or less force when pressing the keys. This may also be the case with the viola organista, although I suspect less so.
Sure string instruments give you more control but at the end of the day, it's only timbre, harmonics and timing (plus the mysterious immeasurable Q factor which I dub musicality). If this gives you the ability to generate more harmonic components through multiple chords and changes the timbre, then it's a valuable device. I mean a cheap analogue monosynth for example has many good qualities and is not short of utility in music.
I'm sure the harp players were just as pissed as you are when they knocked it on its side and added hammers and keys.
It's still a neat instrument, but it falls into the uncanny valley a bit - it kind of sounds a bit like a bunch of strings, with very mechanical phrasing.
Of course, you could say the same about organs being mutant cyborg flutes, so I guess there's a place for it.
As a mechanical engineer, I have to respond to your terminology. The tension in a bow is the same all along the length of the bow. It has to be; it's the force the bow hair applies to the connection points at both ends, and if it wasn't the same along the whole length parts of the hair would be pulling harder than other parts which isn't physically possible.
I think the effect you're describing has to do with pressure perpendicular to the bow: how hard the performer is pressing the bow against the string. That deflects the bow hair, and for a given pressure there's greater deflection in the middle of the bow than at the ends. Also, the deflection changes the tension all along the bow, which changes the sound.
I can definitely see how you'd think the tension is different at the ends of the bow, because your feedback is the sound that is made and you can only measure the tension at one point of the bow at a time. Assuming you're applying equal pressure, when you measure the tension at the ends you're getting a different result than when you measure in the middle, because the deflection is different. If instead you reduce the pressure to near zero you should hear the same sound all along the length of the bow, because you have constant (zero) deflection and constant tension.
And viola is a shitty bass violin by the same logic.
You have to appreciate it for what it is, not for how it compares with another DIFFERENT instrument.
the reason this machine sounds so bad to me is that its design removes a lot of the variables that are important for nuanced tone quality. bowed instruments simply have a lot more variables involved than struck instruments such as pianos or harpsichords. in a violin, viola, or cello, the bow has uneven tension along its length, allowing for many different articulations - it also means that when you start the bowstroke at the top or bottom of the bow, the hair tension is higher at those points. so, given an even downward bow pressure, the start of the stroke at either end of the bow has less friction and therefore less volume than the higher-friction middle, creating a naturally smooth attack as you draw the bow. this says nothing of the ability of the musician to change the bow pressure along the bowstroke, another variable.
the viola organista, on the other hand, presses a metal string to a rotating bow of even tension with constant force. since the string and bow are both evenly tense along their length in this design, there is no possibility of controlling the attack and release of a note, giving a binary, on/off, jerky sound with less continuity between notes.
but theres even more to this. a traditional bowed instrument not only has uneven tension in the X-axis (the bow axis), but also has uneven tension in the string axis. violins, violas, and cellos all have a bridge. the bridge not only transmits the vibration to the soundboard, it creates a tension differential just like the bow. but the resonant property of the bridge means that the string tension corresponds to resonance. the closer you bow to the bridge, the louder, fuller, and more resonant the tone. but also, the closer you bow to the bridge, the less the tension of the string is affected by the downward bow pressure (since the string is higher tension). so, bowing closer to the bridge, the resonance is large and doesn't change very much with differing bow pressure, while bowing further away from the bridge, the resonance is relatively less but is also affected more by bow pressure (since the string is less tense, so increased downward pressure by the bow pushes the string down and raises its tension).
the point of all this shit is to say that traditional bowed string instruments are incredibly complex dynamic systems and a lot of their dynamism has been thrown away in this design, yielding something that offers less tonal control with no tangible benefits beyond being able to bow more strings at once. sorry da vinci.