News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Can anyone tell me what these services do? by teddyh on Wednesday November 20, 2013 @09:22AM (#6768078)
> Intel refuses to say what the software they installed does

Is this not the very definition of software in binary-only form?

Re:Can anyone tell me what these services do? by buren on Wednesday November 20, 2013 @09:29AM (#6768122)
There is a difference between knowing what the software does and _how_ it actually achieves it.
Re:Can anyone tell me what these services do? by jcromartie on Wednesday November 20, 2013 @10:05AM (#6768376)
Unless you are talking about metaphysics/teleology, the only difference is levels of description. What software does is what software does.

The difference between a binary and source code is just level of description. A binary is obviously very hard to understand, but it is just instructions to the computer, and those instructions can be interpreted by following them logically according to the hardware documentation. This is true all the way down to the OS.

Of course, you have to trust that the hardware does what it says it does... I guess you could always break out the oscilloscope...

Re:Can anyone tell me what these services do? by marcosdumay on Wednesday November 20, 2013 @09:41AM (#6768225)
Is there? Are you sure about that?
Re:Can anyone tell me what these services do? by ori_b on Wednesday November 20, 2013 @10:03AM (#6768357)
Yes. It's the difference between

"It's an 8 inch chef's knife in a stain-resistant steel"

and

"It's an 8 inch gyuto-style chef's knife, which is thinner and lighter than the German style knives, but tempered to a higher hardness. This one is hardened to RC-57 (soft for the genre), ground from a hot-forged steel with 1.03%, carbon, 13.06% chromium, 0.37% nickel, and 0.28% nicklel, heated to 1000 degrees to promote austenization, and then oil quenched to form a highly martensitic steel, with moderate levels of pearlite and low levels of cementite. The temperature is then raised to 230 degrees and held until the stress from the quench is relieved. The chromium compounds are relatively coarse, similar to A-1, with a similar effect on the edge. The edge is then wet ground.... etc, etc, etc."

A metallurgist or good blacksmith would be able to write hundreds more pages about a kitchen knife and the processes involved in it's creation.

[Note, I am not a metallurgist. The description, I think, is mostly right, although I may have some of the phase transitions and temperatures wrong. Corrections are welcome.]

Re:Can anyone tell me what these services do? by marcosdumay on Wednesday November 20, 2013 @01:41PM (#6770056)
The difference is that software is always in an environemnt where any small deviation from the "common sense" approach can lead to disastrous consequences (intentional or not).
Re:Can anyone tell me what these services do? by ori_b on Wednesday November 20, 2013 @02:29PM (#6770482)
I'm not sure how that's different from many other forms of engineering. For the example I gave, bump the temperature you hold it at after quenching by 20 degrees, and it will shatter because it hit the TME (Tempered Martensitic Embrittlement) stage. Hold it above that temperature by 80 degrees, and it won't hold an edge, although it will be ductile. Increase the amount of carbon by 0.5%, and it will be remarkably brittle and weak. Decrease it by 0.5%, and it will be extremely soft and won't hold an edge. etc, etc.

A knife is fairly unimportant, but make the wrong decisions of that sort on a plane, or on a bridge, and people will die.

Even more subtle decisions can have serious consequences. See, for example, the DeHavilland Comet, which crashed because the windows were too square.

The squareness was causing them to act as stress concentrators. With the cyclic loading from pressure changes, this caused metal fatigue, and the windows would fail after hundreds of flights. This could be fixed by rounding the corners of the windows, or by using alloys that don't fatigue as easily. And this is why modern jets have rounded portholes, instead of rectangular windows.

Re:Can anyone tell me what these services do? by huhtenberg on Wednesday November 20, 2013 @09:51AM (#6768285)
Being a smartass, aren't we?

Is there a difference between knowing what pressing a gas pedal in a car does and how it does that? Surely there's none.

Re:Can anyone tell me what these services do? by user24 on Wednesday November 20, 2013 @10:05AM (#6768374)
But you can test what the gas pedal does pretty easily. I think parent's point was that without peer review source code audit, we just have to take it on trust.
Re:Can anyone tell me what these services do? by Touche on Wednesday November 20, 2013 @10:31AM (#6768548)
The analogy doesn't hold because gas pedal's tend to do only one thing. A binary blob can do anything. A better analogy would be what some random wire in your car does... but even then if you know where the wire is located you can reason what it probably does. In this case a binary blob can't as easily be inferred.
Re:Can anyone tell me what these services do? by reidrac on Wednesday November 20, 2013 @09:32AM (#6768140)
I think it goes one step beyond that: you're asked to accept an EULA for a software that you don't know what it does or why it needs to be installed and run... because the vendor refuses to tell you! Amazing.
Re:Can anyone tell me what these services do? by pbhjpbhj on Wednesday November 20, 2013 @10:47AM (#6768677)
Well, you accept [probably non-legally binding, at least I always assume that] condition for a driver for your hardware.

Anything else they don't get specific permission for is a breech of the law here (UK, Computer Misuse Act) ... would love to see that prosecuted.

The government should lead such a prosecution really given how important unauthorised computer use/access is to them - extraditing people for it and all.

Re:Can anyone tell me what these services do? by PeterisP on Wednesday November 20, 2013 @11:31AM (#6768970)
This is a good point - if it happens to transfer private data and it didn't explicitly say in the EULA that it's going to do so, then they are violating a bunch of laws.

On the other hand, if an EULA for video card drivers starts including language about transmitting your data, then you already know what it means.