News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Undo by jd007 on Tuesday November 19, 2013 @11:46PM (#6766354)
That may or may not be legal. IANAL but telling a user that his/her data has been deleted when in fact it still sits on the server could be regulation violating or downright illegal depending on where you are. Of course it would probably also depend on what your product ToS says and the nature of the data being deleted.
Re:Undo by mcphage on Wednesday November 20, 2013 @12:27AM (#6766475)
> IANAL but telling a user that his/her data has been deleted when in fact it still sits on the server could be regulation violating or downright illegal depending on where you are

Where on Earth do you think labeling a button "Delete" is a legally binding specification with an incredibly specific required implementation?!

Re:Undo by dandelany on Wednesday November 20, 2013 @01:20AM (#6766608)
EU member states are subject to the (soon to be rewritten) Data Protection Directive: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Directive_95/46/EC_on_the_prote...

In the UK, for example, this is implemented by the Data Protection Act 1998: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Data_Protection_Act_1998

The guidelines for complying with the DPA talk a bit about deletion here: http://www.ico.org.uk/for_organisations/data_protection/the_...

"If you offer users the option to delete personally identifiable information uploaded by them, the deletion must be real i.e. the content should not be recoverable in any way, for example, by accessing a URL from that site."

In fact the DPA takes it even further by requiring that personal data "shall not be kept for longer than is necessary" ie. you are supposed to delete any personally identifying data once you're done using it for it's original purpose (or another legal use). Granted, I imagine it would be pretty hard to bring a case against a company for either of these things, and I can't tell if the former is legally binding or just a "guideline," but it's not outside the realm of possibility...

Re:Undo by mcphage on Thursday November 21, 2013 @02:13PM (#6776708)
> the DPA takes it even further by requiring that personal data "shall not be kept for longer than is necessary" ie. you are supposed to delete any personally identifying data once you're done using it for it's original purpose (or another legal use)

I think you could easily argue that "needing it for an undo feature" is still a legal use for that data. But, thanks for pointing out that "delete" is a lot more legally loaded a term than I had assumed. It makes a pretty convincing case to call things "remove" instead of "delete".

Re:Undo by dandelany on Thursday November 21, 2013 @07:53PM (#6778604)
Maybe so, I'd be really curious to talk to a UK lawyer who has some experience in these matters to get a sense for how they're enforced. Thanks for asking the question and inspiring me to do the research - like you I assumed there was no way "delete" was regulated, but decided to look it up before replying and was very surprised.
Re:Undo by nitrogen on Wednesday November 20, 2013 @01:05AM (#6766563)
Probably a place on Earth that legally frowns upon deceptive business practices, false advertising, and the like.
Re:Undo by elithrar on Wednesday November 20, 2013 @01:15AM (#6766589)
> Where on Earth do you think labeling a button "Delete" is a legally binding specification with an incredibly specific required implementation?!

It may not be "legally binding", but it certainly is a big risk: look at all the hoo-ha when (e.g.) Facebook/Adobe/etc. don't really delete your profile.

Note that I'm not saying they should/shouldn't: I'm arguing that there's many cases where indicating something is deleted (and not deleting it) can cause user outrage.

Re:Undo by mcphage on Thursday November 21, 2013 @02:07PM (#6776654)
> I'm arguing that there's many cases where indicating something is deleted (and not deleting it) can cause user outrage.

Oh, definitely; that's a great way to piss people off. But jd007 specifically mentioned that it might be "downright illegal", and that's what I was criticizing.

Re:Undo by smooj on Wednesday November 20, 2013 @12:10AM (#6766421)
I'm not sure about the legal implications either, but it would be interesting to know. From a totally different angle it might cause backlash from users if they felt betrayed by an action not actually doing what they thought it would do. You'd have to balance the conflicting desires to be able to undo things and have actions do what they say they will do. Maybe a 'trash can' or 'archive' system is the way to go.
Re:Undo by sgdesign on Tuesday November 19, 2013 @11:52PM (#6766368)
Isn't that exactly what Facebook and every other social network does though?
Re:Undo by kamakazizuru on Wednesday November 20, 2013 @12:05AM (#6766406)
Yes, and they keep getting flack from various regulatory authorities for things like that. Facebook or anyone doing something that isn't legal doesn't make it legal.
Re:Undo by xerophtye on Wednesday November 20, 2013 @12:23AM (#6766461)
They don't even do a good job of hiding it :/ the URL of the image stays the same and it is still accessible through the URL. All they do is remove its link from their interfaces...