News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The first Bitcoin post on HN by Houshalter on Tuesday November 19, 2013 @03:35PM (#6764258)
Some people getting rich of bitcoin doesn't make everyone else worse off. And a "new aristocracy" is a huge stretch. A few people will get rich off it but not like that.

And the value of bitcoin won't deflate forever. Eventually the price will stabilize.

Re:The first Bitcoin post on HN by Jtsummers on Tuesday November 19, 2013 @04:25PM (#6764606)
When will the price stabilize? Serious question, I can't figure it out. What conditions would need to be present for the bitcoin economy to be stable so that prices of goods/services are consistent over extended periods of time? Do you mean that deflation will actually end or that the rate of deflation will be reduced from its current excessive rate (from a currency standpoint, as a commodity/investment it's great)?
Re:The first Bitcoin post on HN by Nursie on Tuesday November 19, 2013 @05:06PM (#6764844)
If you view a change in currency as fundamentally pretty useless, then yes, giving massive amounts of financial control of resources and labour(which is what money represents) to people with BTC hoarded does indeed take away from others.

And if BTC were to become (for instance) a primary currency for a country, and that country were to experience economic growth, then deflation must necessarily continue.

Re:The first Bitcoin post on HN by Houshalter on Tuesday November 19, 2013 @07:04PM (#6765481)
>If you view a change in currency as fundamentally pretty useless, then yes, giving massive amounts of financial control of resources and labour(which is what money represents) to people with BTC hoarded does indeed take away from others.

People are voluntarily paying them for their coins because they, for whatever reason, value them. You can say that's silly but it's not like you are being forced to buy bitcoins or anything.

>And if BTC were to become (for instance) a primary currency for a country, and that country were to experience economic growth, then deflation must necessarily continue.

Isn't the same true for any other finite resource? Everything will deflate/increase in value relative to rest of the economy.

Re:The first Bitcoin post on HN by Nursie on Tuesday November 19, 2013 @07:08PM (#6765505)
>> People are voluntarily paying them for their coins because they, for whatever reason, value them. You can say that's silly but it's not like you are being forced to buy bitcoins or anything.

I'm saying it would be a bad idea to adopt as a de-facto currency, that's all.

>> Isn't the same true for any other finite resource? Everything will deflate/increase in value relative to rest of the economy.

Currency isn't and shouldn't be a resource, it's a medium of exchange. If BTC is a resource then cool, but lets stop pushing it as a currency.

Re:The first Bitcoin post on HN by Houshalter on Tuesday November 19, 2013 @07:19PM (#6765563)
>Currency isn't and shouldn't be a resource, it's a medium of exchange.

Well why not? A medium of exchange is a resource. There are exchanges and markets for currencies, people speculate on them, etc. They are definitely a resource.

Re:The first Bitcoin post on HN by yen223 on Wednesday November 20, 2013 @01:20AM (#6766607)
Resource in the sense that the item in question has some inherent value. If I can't exchange Bitcoin for anything, then Bitcoins have zero value. If I can't exchange rice for anything, that rice will still have some value to me.

It's important to realize that all currencies, including Bitcoin and the USD, are only as valuable as the stuff I can buy with them. There's no point in having a million dollars, if I can't buy anything with it. That makes currencies distinctly different from "resources".

Re:The first Bitcoin post on HN by Nursie on Wednesday November 20, 2013 @03:25AM (#6766919)
Because we have history to show us it doesn't work very well, screws up the economy, concentrates wealth etc etc.
Re:The first Bitcoin post on HN by nazgulnarsil on Tuesday November 19, 2013 @05:51PM (#6765074)
circumventing capital controls allowing people to vote with their feet and impoverish corrupt governments is not useless.
Re:The first Bitcoin post on HN by Nursie on Tuesday November 19, 2013 @06:07PM (#6765147)
In many cases impoverishing various governments, corrupt or otherwise, would be worse than useless. Many, many people rely on government for food, fuel and shelter.

Secondly there are many of us who consider a currency that can be centrally adjusted as part of economic stabilisation to be a very good thing.

Third, in an expanding economy, a deflating currency steals wealth from the productive and hands it to hoarders.

So yeah, it's pretty useless as far as I can tell.