Yes it is. And it is up to the people to decide not wanting to go to US ever again, as stated in this post.
Seems like you got offended by something the writer said. All he stated that he doesn't ever want to go there and I think he is allowed to state that without anyone getting upset about it.
I, for one, would rather live in a world where individuals are free to travel at will (protected by international agreements) than in one where only goods and money benefit from this kind of protection.
As someone who lives in a Schengen area country, I experience both, so maybe that influences my opinions : it seems quite retrograde and unbearable to forbid people to just travel as they wish.
(I happen to subscribe to the theory that, since the world is highly unlikely to do the reverse, borders should be relaxed to the point where people can move as freely as capital, but we're not anywhere close to that, either.)
This article is essentially about a 'false positive' by the border agents, nothing more.
If you follow the rules then there is a good chance they will close the door on you, let alone make sure you don't sneak in.
I was denied entry once for an entirely frivolous reason (before anyone asks, no, no criminal record or DUI or anything) and it made subsequent entries extremely difficult/stressful but I was not turned away.
Edit: That second link. Trust me on this: the worst innocent thing you can ever tell a CBSA agent is that you're dating a Canadian. Especially if the agent decides that they don't like you.
I'm also never going back to Canada, because there's nothing up there worth it for me to be treated that way.
http://www.metalinsider.net/touring/warbeast-denied-entry-to...
http://www.thetelegram.com/News/Local/2013-06-21/article-328...
http://news-briefs.ew.com/2013/11/16/russell-brand-south-afr...
(well, almost) http://correresmidestino.com/almost-denied-entry-to-canada/