The concerning issue here is someone hacking this vehicle's OTA software update and causing accidents. Or even tapping into the vehicle control system(s) and causing havoc.
Unlikely, but possible vs. current vehicle technology requiring a trip to a dealer by an authorized and authenticated trained tech to make these changes.
I imagine every critical system on the Model S is accessible wirelessly.
This actually bring me back to Michael Hastings accident where theories are floating around that steering, breaking and acceleration systems might have been compromised wirelessly causing the accident.
The bottom line is that there's simply way too much convenience technology in cars today and that might not be such great thing. It's a tough call as safety technology is important and the more the better. However, certain things such as OTA suspension and other critical system updates need to pushed and completed intelligently. I want to assume that any updates to these vehicles are done when they are off (overnight) and redundantly checked for integrity to ensure the update was successful.
So the protocol the car uses to receive commands and firmware is likely different.
What may be unique about Tesla is the explicit provision for over-the-air software updates. But anyone with sufficient technical knowledge and physical access to a conventional car can do very nasty things to the electronics (i.e., deadly to the occupants).
Don't know when Wikipedia became the bearer of all truths ...
BTW, there is no evidence, at least none you have cited or even referred to, that the Tesla computer is "becoming increasingly complex". All we see in this article is that they are changing one variable in their existing system. That's not increased complexity.
All of the cars I've driven have been accessible by ODB2 or something similar, which is a physical connection under the hood and/or steering column.
http://telematicsnews.info/2010/08/31/onstar-supports-over-t...
Since 2010, OnStar has offered OTA updates.
There's just starting to be real external research into the current state of the automotive world: http://www.autosec.org/pubs/cars-usenixsec2011.pdf
Even the proposed new standards are busted: http://publications.lib.chalmers.se/records/fulltext/143639....
I for one, am going to have a hard time buying any car made after 2006.
Note I wrote most. I am aware that some organizations like Toyota engage in poor practices, but there's more the exception than the rule.
Obviously that doesn't mean it's inherently secure or anything but maybe hint that it might be using some more standard security practices than a crazy custom Tesla invented magic box.
You don't need anything approaching realtime for controlling an air-based suspension. If we were talking about the magneto-hydraulic suspensions that adjust constantly to road conditions like potholes and corners, then I would agree 100%. But the response rate of the pneumatic system will be far slower than the computer.
Yet more movement of freedom and power from individuals to corporations.
Something that happens once in a million will happen on an iPhone, not on a Tesla.
If / When they produce a mainstream car that will be another story.
All cars in Tesla premium category have quirks that require trip to the dealer. I have had colleague with bricked Series 5 BMW that requires full rewiring, ... Except for Tesla being overhyped with people that will not buy it, the actual clients of that kind of car seems generally happy to go through the "pain". (see, not an opinion I share, but then I don't buy 85K car either)
With OTA updates you can at least fix it with a rollback, quickly, before more people die.
I fail to see this as a move of power from individuals to corporations.
Needs high resolution radars with good range (very expensive on its own) and good software in order to detect something and then find an evasive action.
As these events are already unlikely (i assume), doing something about it seem unnecessary. Even this OTA update seem like it is more for the press rather than protecting the driver.
All I remember while trying to do this is that high sensitivity is expensive..
A few sentences later, though -- "Another software update expected in January will give the driver direct control of the air suspension ride height transitions." -- concerns me. Tesla's car computer is becoming increasingly complex, and the fact that the infotainment system will have such complete control over the car -- and will still accept data from outside sources -- is very concerning. I hope that at some point soon Tesla will begin talking about the security methodology that they use for the firmware running on the car, and how they prevent unauthorized code from running.