If Canada said "fuck it" on dollars today and decided they were going to start a brand new currency (let's call it the Ford, after Toronto Mayor Rob Ford), what would it be worth initially? It would be worth $0. Any increase in value after that up until the money supply and the price stabilized enough for it to be used as actual currency would be in the thousands of percent, which would make it seem quite volatile indeed. However, the huge increase in the beginning would attract a ton of investment because of the profit incentive and soon the Ford would be worth something. It would grow until it reached a saturation point where all the people who wanted a Ford had one. At that point the price would level off to the point where investors would stop seeing it as a profit opportunity. At this point it finally starts to look attractive as a currency.
In short, today's investors are tomorrow's spenders.
BitCoin had to start somewhere, and it was never going to be useful as a currency until it is widespread enough for its value to stabilize. Until then all mediums of exchange are speculative instruments.
That's not true at all. The Euro was launched as a completely new currency in 1995, across a huge and diverse group of economies and backed only by trust in the ECB. The value of the Euro has remained remarkably stable, launching at 1EUR=1.12USD, peaking in 2008 at 1.59USD and currently trading at 1.35USD. The biggest increase in the value of the Euro happened as a result of the declining value of other currencies during the US financial crisis.
BTC is in the midst of a vast speculative bubble. It isn't a currency in any real sense, as the vast majority of the trading volume is purely speculative. A currency is defined by liquidity and there just aren't many things you can currently exchange for a bitcoin. BTC might eventually become justifiably very valuable, but it might just as easily become worthless due to a run on MtGox.
The reason the Euro started off there is because, like an IPO, they thought that because an entire federation of countries was backing it, they could offer it initially for a price higher than $0, just like Facebook thought that because millions of people knew what Facebook was they could offer their shares for a higher price than $0. In all likelihood Canada would offer it for a price higher than $0, and the market would probably bear that price.
BitCoin couldn't do that because it wasn't introduced by a federation or a nation. Satoshi couldn't just go to an exchange and offer BitCoins for $600 because nobody had heard of BitCoin and people were skeptical. So it had to make the journey from $0 to $600 on its own.
But now that it has earned the faith of the people who use it, what makes it different from a national currency being offered that price? Not much.
" A currency is defined by liquidity and there just aren't many things you can currently exchange for a bitcoin. "
There are more and more things you can exchange a BitCoin for every single day. And if you're a vendor, don't you want to accept BitCoins? If someone wanted to give me a BitCoin in exchange for something worth say, $550, I would accept it because a BitCoin is worth about that much on the exchange and there's a high chance that it will be worth more tomorrow. It might not make a whole lot of sense to spend BitCoins right now but for the very same reason it makes all the sense in the world to accept them. Vendors have every incentive to accept BitCoins at the moment, which means there will be more and more of them, which means BitCoin's utility as a currency will only go up. Network effects.
Due to the in-built deflation of the currency, the main incentive is to hold the coins until some value is reached and then sell them. But because the distribution of coin ownership is quite asymmetrical, there are people out there that could cause massive drops in coin value by accidentally flodding the market when their 'Sell!' price is reached.
So the price will go up, sometimes faster, sometimes slower, with massive drops every now and then and a continuous value increase over the very long run.
And even if there were (which there isn't), the fact that the currency has doubled in the last 2 weeks suggests that there is massive hoarding going on now, and people would rather own the currency rather than exchange them for goods or services. Why would you spend 1 BTC when the price of the good or service could halve in BTC in a week? It's better to just dig out your old fiat currency and pay for it with that, since the price is much more stable.
You are probably right about the median case, but I say there is a small chance of a >$10M value for this reason alone.
If millions of people start believing BitCoin will eventually be a world currency, then it will be.
I agree that it is price speculation. Is speculation always based on a delusion?
And remember, I have no problems with speculation and people making money off of this. And this speculation can go on for years. But in the end BTC will be worthless, because there is no inherent value to a BTC. Even the fundamental promise of Bitcoin being anonymous is inherently flawed! Sure, you can money launder it, but the US government will make quick work of that in due time.
At least with tulip bulbs, you can grown them into flowers, and gold can be turned into jewelery and has industrial uses.
BTC has literally zero inherent or fundamental uses for it.
My guess is that it will keep rising until the US government starts cracking down hard on it, like they did with poker sites, etc. They've already put it on their radar screen, and a lot of these companies that deal with BTC don't understand the ramifications of money transmission. Once the US government starts shutting down in earnest, people will dump their BTC and it will be over.
Think of the BitCoin network as a financial superconductor - the resistance to movement is so small that its negligible. Is that not inherently valuable to our economy as a whole?
As well, since those transactions can be tracked, I don't think it will take very long for governments to start cracking down on them, and taxing them. They might force you to register your wallet, they will try to break up people who allow for anonymization/laundering of transactions, etc. It doesn't take a lot for real-life friction to make this pretty hard to use unless you just want to meet face-to-face and transfer BTC offline.
I have no doubt that governments will find ways of taxing it that are at least as effective as those used to tax cash businesses presently.
edited to add footnote: [1] ... as a relatively small player. My understanding is that payments between huge, well established institutions can approximate bitcoin in lack-of-friction.
To accept credit cards I need to fill out a bunch of paperwork, wait for blessing (which might be withheld), and then pay transaction fees on every exchange that are way higher than bitcoin transaction fees. They are likely to stay way higher since bitcoin allows direct competition on the basis of transaction fee. Then I'm faced with the possibility that the charges will be disputed!
To use credit cards, I need to fill out a bunch of paperwork, wait for blessing (which may be withheld), and only then can I easily make these payments - with the acknowledged advantages you cite. I may also have to pay an annual fee, but that's often waived because - analogous to web advertising - VISA wants larger numbers to better convince businesses they need to accept VISA.
Bitcoin is also substantially more resistant to fraud in one particular dimension: I am not constantly handing out my secret to every waiter and website I interact with.
Early adopters.
With the BTC/USD run-up to $550+, many early adopters who bought bitcoin when it was trading for a few dollars now have very high purchasing power; this will lead to spending, regardless of volatility.
As an example, imagine you purchased 1,000BTC when they were trading at a dollar. Your purchasing power was $1,000 back then. Today, your purchasing power is around $500K. Spending a bitcoin or two on Christmas gifts would make perfect sense to you.
Yes, bitcoin could be our tulip bulbs.
Or history might not be repeating this time and we might actually be looking at something new that is here to stay.
Nobody knows, I wonder why so many people have that reflex to pretend they do.
Whenever people say "This time it's different", it never is. BTC is a bubble. But I don't admonish anyone for trying to make money off of it. I don't have the balls to, but that doesn't mean people shouldn't be allowed to speculate. The ones who will lose, however, are the ones that think this is for real, and have rationalized away their common sense into thinking this is a long-term investment and sustainable.
When there is no inherent use of something other than pure speculation, then it will end badly. This is 21st century tulip bulbs, but I cheer on anyone who has the balls to jump in and make money on BTC while there's money to be made.
But holding on long term is seriously a fool's game, this is a trading instrument, not something with any long term value.