Re:
by TheHydroImpulse on Saturday November 16, 2013 @10:45PM
(#6747474)
While not the same concept (or scale), this comment seems awfully similar to the ones originally posted about Dropbox. People resorted on using older UNIX programs to handle what Dropbox did better and much much easier.
While some people don't exactly value aesthetic, I do, so even if it's a prettier IRC client, I'd take it. I'll also point out that "team chat" may include a whole company. From sales to support to engineering and design. It's highly unlikely that everyone would like or know how to use IRC.
Native campfire sucks. It works, but it sucks.
Re:
by lennykhazan on Saturday November 16, 2013 @09:57PM
(#6747340)
I believe you got this from gitter.im - that is a very similar idea (likely a ripoff of ours) which is nothing more than a concept and design. We build a rough working prototype.
Re:
by lennykhazan on Saturday November 16, 2013 @09:38PM
(#6747290)
IRC doesn't have the same level of deep integration with GitHub and ease-of-use that Hub has.
Sure, but neither does a silicon wafer make it easy to do arithmetic.
What does your app do that a GitHub-aware IRC bot cannot?
It's prettier and it has more hype? :P
IRC?
I use IRC for all sorts of purposes and audiences, there are tens ifnot hundreds of implementations that are being actively maintained, and it's been a standard for decades. How does that suck?
Edit: Oh they mention "Like IRC, but smarter", where smarter is a link. Let's see about that.
> Know who's seen any message.
Facebook does this. It more annoys me than anything else, but I can see the point. People could also simply acknowledge having read something, but again, ok I see the point.
> Edit messages after you've sent them.
Depends on the audience... On Skype (1 on 1 chat) it rocks, StackExchange's chat is generally not for 13-year-olds either so there it works as well, but in most team chats I wouldn't want this feature. Since it's aimed at Github users, I suppose this is a nice feature.
> Automatically embeds content like YouTube, pictures of cats and other stuff.
God no.
> Did we mention our smart notifications? @mentions. Batched notifications. Won't annoy you by making your phone beep on every message.
IRC, IRC and IRC.
> Awesome emotigifs.
You mean like MSN's Winks®? [1]
> Infinite chat history stored in the cloud.
trustworthiness--;
> Searchable too, naturally.
grep
> Oh, and a unified activity feed.
Hmm, what's that for? You mean like IRC clients' "last message" feature, or a way that stalks people even when your client is not running?
[1] http://img.uptodown.net/screen/windows/bigthumb/free-msn-win...