News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:As Oracle axes support for GlassFish, MySQL users might w... by PaulHoule on Friday November 15, 2013 @10:38AM (#6739985)
I think the difference is that Glassfish is a piece of garbage. Among the few people who have heard of it it has a reputation of being the worst application server you can possibly use.
Re:As Oracle axes support for GlassFish, MySQL users might w... by strictfp on Friday November 15, 2013 @11:27AM (#6740262)
I haven't used it but there is NO WAY that it is worse than WebSphere.

In any case, my firm belief is that the whole concept of app servers is flawed. Libs are so much better than frameworks, and app servers are just horribly clunky frameworks, which take away as much control as possible from the dev.

Taking control away from devs is a really backwards way of thinking of development as grunt work, which has been proven time and time again that it isn't.

Death to all app servers, I say!

Re:As Oracle axes support for GlassFish, MySQL users might w... by kaffeinecoma on Friday November 15, 2013 @11:58AM (#6740493)
I actually passed on some repeat client work when they insisted on using WebSphere.

My initial project for them was an eternal struggle to get basic things (XML parsing, Hibernate, CDI, etc) working in their environment because specific versions of these things were already included in the app server, and always ended up conflicting with libs we needed to include for our own app. I remember it distinctly as one of those times where I just felt helpless to make anything work.

Re:As Oracle axes support for GlassFish, MySQL users might w... by hackinthebochs on Friday November 15, 2013 @01:36PM (#6741227)
I was in a similar boat. I abandoned a potentially very lucrative startup because the owner (my friend's brother) insisted on using Websphere and all the associated apps (he was a former IBMer). There came a point where some misconfiguration occurred when attempting to restore a previous version of the application after that point nothing worked. I tried for days on end to fix the problems but nothing would compile without massive errors. The piles and piles of cruft that Websphere added did nothing but obscure the real source of the issue. Eventually I gave up and said screw it and left.

The startup was already on its last legs at that point, as I was the only active developer since the other developer I worked with had already left after getting fed up for other reasons. After I left the startup limped along for a while but as far as I can tell was abandoned. If they had just used a more sane environment I could have easily developed the entire thing myself as it wasn't anything more complicated than a straightforward CMS + payments. I still kick myself for not making a better case for a more sane environment but I was wet behind the ears at the time and I didn't trust my instincts in the face of guys with masters degrees and X years at IBM and other top companies. I know better now.

Re:As Oracle axes support for GlassFish, MySQL users might w... by mathattack on Friday November 15, 2013 @01:11PM (#6741008)
Can you be more specific on your issues with WebSphere? I remember the buzz when it first came out, but haven't bumped into it in quite a while.
Re:As Oracle axes support for GlassFish, MySQL users might w... by theandrewbailey on Friday November 15, 2013 @01:05PM (#6740960)
App servers solve so many problems so you don't have to. Taking control away by solving problems to let you focus on the bigger ones is great.
Re:As Oracle axes support for GlassFish, MySQL users might w... by cbp on Friday November 15, 2013 @10:55AM (#6740079)
There are a couple applications running on top of glassfish at $DAYJOB but I can't say I've ever been involved with them. Care to elaborate a little on why it's so bad? I saw the admin console once and it seemed to run like a slug but it did seem to include a lot of features.
Re:As Oracle axes support for GlassFish, MySQL users might w... by theandrewbailey on Friday November 15, 2013 @01:10PM (#6741004)
The admin console is easily the slowest part of Glassfish, but it lets you configure everything that, if you were using Tomcat, would need you to play around with XML.
Re:As Oracle axes support for GlassFish, MySQL users might w... by sgt on Friday November 15, 2013 @12:55PM (#6740889)
Definitely not the worst. I work with it every day and most of the time it behaves quite well. Glassfish 4 (Java EE 7 support) behaves relatively well, too. I do wish they made it more light weight and faster, but clearly it is good enough to be bundled with NetBeans 7.4.
Re:As Oracle axes support for GlassFish, MySQL users might w... by theandrewbailey on Friday November 15, 2013 @01:15PM (#6741044)
I've been a fan of Glassfish and Netbeans for 5 years. It started when I was testing a few "stacks" for web services, and that combination worked amazingly well out of the box; or rather, it was the only one that did.
Re:As Oracle axes support for GlassFish, MySQL users might w... by noselasd on Friday November 15, 2013 @12:22PM (#6740673)
In all honesty, I've never heard that about glassfish before. The people I know that use it, are very happy with it, and praise it over JBoss.
Re:As Oracle axes support for GlassFish, MySQL users might w... by tieTYT on Friday November 15, 2013 @01:31PM (#6741180)
Why, specifically, is it a piece of garbage?
Re:As Oracle axes support for GlassFish, MySQL users might w... by lmm on Friday November 15, 2013 @12:56PM (#6740903)
As opposed to MySQL, which is respected and certainly not a target widespread of hatred and mockery?
Re:As Oracle axes support for GlassFish, MySQL users might w... by theandrewbailey on Friday November 15, 2013 @01:18PM (#6741065)
Have you ever worked with WebSphere or WebLogic? When I was, I wished I was using Glassfish.
Re:As Oracle axes support for GlassFish, MySQL users might w... by dangerboysteve on Friday November 15, 2013 @12:53PM (#6740872)
Would you care to explain with an example.