I've always taken pleasure in pointing out that 4chan doesn't have the worst comments, and that title belongs to YouTube.
I'm glad the world agrees.
Youtube, on the other hand, is simply plagued by stupid comments.
That's how I use YouTube, and I couldn't be happier. I was hiding comments on YouTube before anyway.
Google+ was never intended to be a product in itself. Google+ is Google's social layer. Providing social features to other Google products was always the plan for Google+.
September 2011: "Until now, every single Google property acted like a separate company. Due to the way we grew, through various acquisitions and the fierce independence of each division within Google, each product sort of veered off in its own direction. That was dizzying. But Google+ is Google itself. We’re extending it across all that we do—search, ads, Chrome, Android, Maps, YouTube—so that each of those services contributes to our understanding of who you are." http://www.wired.com/magazine/2011/09/ff_google_horowitz/2/
October 2011: "The strategy is revealed in the name," Gundotra agreed. "We chose the smallest modifier we could. Just a plus." But the shift it represents is not small. Plus is now a social layer built into all Google's Web products." http://readwrite.com/2011/10/19/sergey_brin_vic_gundotra_on_...
March 2012: “This is just the next version of Google,” Mr. Gundotra said, noting that he sees Google Plus as a social blanket that envelopes the entire Google experience. “Everything is being upgraded. We already have users. We’re now upgrading them to what we consider Google 2.0.” http://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/03/06/google-defending-go...
Doesn't get any clearer than that. People just assumed it was spin at the time so focused on the FB-aspect of it. Instead turns out they actually meant every word, and things are finally on track as far as they're concerned.
The only cure if you disagree with the vision is to stop using Google products altogether.
That said, it's obviously got a lot of warts, like promoting Plus power-users over the regular subscribers. Say what you want about Reddit, but at least the infamous karma-farmers get a lot of legitimate upvotes before they bubble to the top and don't pop in their^H^H^H^H^Hthere automatically on the strength of their reputations.
This "popping-in" reminds me of Digg somehow.
There's much made of how Apple isn't the Apple it used to be. What about Google? A guy I know through music commented that getting hired at Google was "a breeze." That contrasts with the being interviewed every which way I used to hear about.
This is a common sentiment, but doesn't simple platform pragmatism make it obvious why they want to merge disparate identities and systems? Why should YouTube have an island comment system given that it's a Google property? Of course the replacement should be ready for prime time (it sounds like some basic features are missing right now, such as channel owner moderation), but the eventual move to that is something that under virtually any situation anyone would recommend.
My Flickr account got turned into a Yahoo account. My Skype account is now a Live account or whatever. Of course these things come together, and I'm not quite sure why every narrative about things like this (not necessary your post) has to be "G+ needs to take on Facebook so this is how it's doing it", when the more obvious explanation of "Company homogenizes systems" fits so well.
Further one annoying aspect of this whole drama is that to demonstrate that there is a problem, people become the problem. It seems like the vast majority of abuse in YouTube land right now are people desperately trying to demonstrate that the Google+ migration was a mistake (e.g. copy pasting tanks an other inanities). This demonstrates that people resist change more than any fault in the new platform.
That's a very Google-centric way of looking at it. From their point of view, merging everything may be a big convenience and make them more money through more detailed profiling of users.
But my end user point of view is the opposite. The fact that one company with a product I use bought another company with an unrelated product I use, because it happens to create efficiencies on a balance sheet, doesn't magically create a desire within me to use those products together.
I don't need some stupid cat video I clicked on and watched for 10 seconds affecting my searches and ads I see. My choice of what videos to watch is by default disjoint from my other online activities. If I want to share a video, I'll do it explicitly and don't need any integration to make that happen. Having my actions tracked across unrelated sites and reported to everyone I know, and a labyrinthine scheme of privacy settings I would need to constantly monitor to stay configured the way I want, just keeps me off social networks altogether and using adblock/ghostery everywhere.
It's a very every company ever way of looking at it -- if you have multiple systems that do largely the same thing, you take the better or more encompassing of the two (or three, etc) and let it win. This is 90% of the purpose of companies acquiring systems and companies.
As to tracking, do you think Google didn't already track you with complete accuracy and knowledge? I don't think this does anything at all to improve their profiling of you. Literally nothing. They probably have some hopes about engagement, but I would wager the primary motivation is simply rationalizing systems.
And let's be clear -- YouTube's comments before this debacle were a garbage dump of noise. They represented the most notorious, least signal manifestation of comments on the tubes. Now, apparently, distaste for Google+ is enough for people to black that out of their memory?
I want a firewall that separates identities. The identity that I use to connect with my mom and in-laws should be separate from the one I use to post on tech forums. The identity where I share baby pics with my wife's friends should be separate from the identity where I comment on deathmetal videos. If Google requires them to be the same - I'd rather delete some of those identities and stay anonymous/logged-out, not merge them.
(as you say, there's no compelling reason for them not to)
Right question: Why did they release it in the current state, which is, I think it's fair to say, 1) a disaster and 2) technically rubbish for all the reasons in the OP.
You should be asking: Why, when building a cross-site system to leave comments, are their clever engineers ignoring the established discipline of spam protection, which they know how to use, and building a system optimized for social peer ranking, sharing cat videos and trolling?
But either way, it makes the Real Names Only thing more obviously false: you're making a general-purpose reusable platform and not a specific social network of your own. It's a "Social Layer", right?
In that case, forcing the users to adhere to a real-names policy instead of providing an official supported path for anonymity or pseudonymity sticks out as trying to push your users into a pattern that they might not find a natural fit for them. And by "users" I don't mean the commenters, I mean the pages to which the comments are attached - if I want to allow anonymous/pseudonymous comments attached to my channel or page or whatever I have a Plus thread associated with, why doesn't Google support this?
Even made a video explaining how to do it: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jKBGsu0TxnY
Really the underlying problem here is that "Google+, the unified platform/identity system" has the same name as "Google+, the social network which lives at plus.google.com". People just blank out anything they do/say due to the assumptions which arise from conflating the two.
Anonymity means no-one knows who you are, not "no-one except Google."
Some of us belong to minorities that are actively discriminated against, legally and illegally. If services start forcing us to use our real names for discussion, we are opening ourselves up to potentially dangerous situations, all in the name of allowing Google to monetize us better. Wow, sounds like a great deal.
They even made an easy to follow help video to walk people through it: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jKBGsu0TxnY
There's actually no problem with the system on this front. The real issue is Google's haphazard communication.
They could have merged Youtube and Google video early on but never did. They only gave an option to link your google and youtube accounts if memory serves. There's no link to youtube on the Google Search home page the way it has links to gmail and other services. It's always been an island so far so the fact that Google seems to have rushed a G+ integration into youtube says something IMO.
They did, but not early on. It caused some drama when they announced Google Video was slated for decommission and all videos migrated to YouTube.
Google is very good at sorting the web and finding the interesting content. I think in the long run they might be able to do the same thing with comments and be able to extract the insightful content and weed out all the noise. If they manage to do that it could be a revolution: imagine a website like reddit where you could automatically hide all low-content submissions and comments based on your preferences.
They're definitely not there though, so far this G+/Youtube integration is an unmitigated disaster. It even broke my Chrome plugin that removed all comments from Youtube videos. Life is suffering.