News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Economists Discover the Poor Behave Differently From the ... by dragonwriter on Thursday November 14, 2013 @01:14AM (#6730880)
> But the real point -- which is a huge one, as far as the field of economics is concerned -- is that the "rational (and by implication, homogeneously rational) actor" presumption is under fire.

Er, no, while people have been saying that this is the "real point" of various stories on internet discussion fora at least as long as I've been on internet discussion fora (which goes back to the latter half of the year 1990), its really not. The rational actor model (whose role in economics is much more limited than many people seem to think) has always -- from the day it was conceived -- been known to be a simplified model (like the "perfectly competitive market") which is a good-enough approximation for some real world interactions but fundamentally not true (it assumes, among other thing, what amounts to effective omniscience -- at least where it concerns any decision that has any impact on the actor's own experienced utility -- on the part of all actors), and also not even good enough to be useful for many important situations.

No one anywhere in the social sciences thinks the rational actor model represents the underlying reality, and in economics particularly it (along with perfectly competitive markets) is baseline that works both as a basis for a highly idealized model that is important pedagogically and often useful as a basis for describing real world situations in terms of variances from (e.g., explaining empirically derived models of real-world behavior in terms of how the empirical model differs from idealized model and connecting that to a theory of how the real underlying processes differ from those that form the basis for the idealized model.)

Re:Economists Discover the Poor Behave Differently From the ... by nhaehnle on Thursday November 14, 2013 @03:39AM (#6731300)
In fairness, though, there is a big disconnect between what economists in the media say on average when they feel free to say whatever they like, versus what economists concede in an academic context when pressed on the matter.

Part of this may be due to the fact that most economists who appear in the media are basically paid shills, but no matter the reason, it is definitely a problem for the democratic process.