News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Economists Discover the Poor Behave Differently From the ... by anigbrowl on Thursday November 14, 2013 @01:00AM (#6730845)
people have been shown, time and again, to behave economically irrationally

Likewise, choices that appear irrational may turn out to be entirely sensible but for the exclusion of relevant factors. Having been quite poor in the past I can certainly distinguish between irrational choices of the 'oh fuck it, let tomorrow take care of itself' variety and rational ones of the 'this is inefficient, but satisfies constraints' type.

As an example of the latter, consider riding the bus. In many places you can get a monthly pass at a substantial discount to paying multiple fares every day. But for someone who is un- or under-employed, the expected value of purchasing the monthly pass is quite different from that of someone with a predictable commute; if that person makes the wrong guess about how often s/he will travel over the month, it can result in a significant opportunity cost.

Then there's the even simpler case of the person who can't accumulate enough cash at a time to buy the monthly pass, but who won't be able to get paid at the end of the week without taking the bus to work each day. Absent credit facilities, paying bus far on a day-by-day basis can be perfectly rational when viewed in the individual's overall economic context. Unfortunately, economics textbooks don't devote much attention to multiple inelastic constraints.

Re:Economists Discover the Poor Behave Differently From the ... by yummyfajitas on Thursday November 14, 2013 @03:27AM (#6731273)
irrational choices of the 'oh fuck it, let tomorrow take care of itself'

Having a high discount rate is not irrational. Multiple discount rates are, but a single high discount rate is perfectly rational.

Re:Economists Discover the Poor Behave Differently From the ... by anigbrowl on Thursday November 14, 2013 @11:51AM (#6733369)
It depends. There have certainly been times where I've deferred some necessary purchase in favor of a frivolous one, eg choosing to pay a bill late so I could go out with friends and have beers. Now that's not so bad if you know you're going to be able to pay the bill next week, and arguably there's some psychological benefit in being social and and consuming some alcohol to de-stress, not to mention the signaling value of apparent economic liquidity.

But if you discount the future too liberally, then pretty much anything can be spun as a rational choice, eg drug addiction, being a hobo, taking up crime or whatever. I smoked fairly heavily for about 20 years, which I'm sur is going to have some negative impact on my future lifespan/quality of life, if the way I felt by the time I quit is anything to go by. For all that I liked smoking at times, it was basically a symptom of nictotine addiction and I can't say my life was improved by having been a smoker. This is certainly one case where I discounted the future too heavily.

Re:Economists Discover the Poor Behave Differently From the ... by xixi77 on Thursday November 14, 2013 @01:39PM (#6734397)
I think you are confusing irrationality with ex-post regret. It is to be expected that people would come to regret many choices that were rational at the time they were made.

Not everything we do is rational, but all the things you mentioned can -- and imo should, absent evidence to the contrary -- be treated as rational choice.

Re:Economists Discover the Poor Behave Differently From the ... by anigbrowl on Thursday November 14, 2013 @04:55PM (#6735923)
Oh come on, you've never done anything that you knew was a bad idea before you did it?
Re:Economists Discover the Poor Behave Differently From the ... by digitalengineer on Thursday November 14, 2013 @02:57AM (#6731187)
Up voted! Excellent explanation. I suppose Pawnshops/Lownsharks use the same 'need-money-right-now' angle.
Re:Economists Discover the Poor Behave Differently From the ... by yetanotherphd on Thursday November 14, 2013 @09:46PM (#6737374)
which textbooks are you referring to?