Re:Bill Gates: My Plan to Improve Our World, and How You Can...
by Houshalter on Thursday November 14, 2013 @01:24PM
(#6734238)
It's a club good (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Club_good).
Re:Bill Gates: My Plan to Improve Our World, and How You Can...
by teddyh on Friday November 15, 2013 @09:20AM
(#6739523)
A club good is simply an excludable non-rivalrous good. In this Internet age it is increasingly hard to maintain the illusion of the excludability of bits.
Re:Bill Gates: My Plan to Improve Our World, and How You Can...
by Houshalter on Friday November 15, 2013 @01:28PM
(#6741148)
It is relatively effective. Most people don't pirate things because it's illegal. Especially corporations are less likely to pirate software because of the serious legal consequences.
Re:Bill Gates: My Plan to Improve Our World, and How You Can...
by teddyh on Monday November 18, 2013 @02:22AM
(#6753083)
Note that I said bits, not only software. Most everyone has their music collection. Also, in regards to software, show me an average person who hasn’t had a pirated version of, say, Photoshop or MS Office. Even in business office settings it is, I am given to understand, very common.
Also, does a mere legal barrier suffice to make something an excludable good? Could you turn, for example, the observing of the Statue of Liberty into an excludable good merely by passing a law mandating that only those allowed may observe it?
I could do that, and then the ethical burden would fall on me to motivate why society would benefit more from my use of the software than it would benefit everyone I would potentially deny to receive a copy of it.
But, the way you phrase it (“claim on the fruits of the software authors labor”) presupposes that it is property, and a rivalrous one at that. However, software is a non-rivalrous good, and whether it should be considered property is the question we are debating.