News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Edward Snowden is Almost Broke by IvyMike on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @02:23AM (#6723862)
I'm actually surprised he has any access to his money at all. I assumed all of his assets would have been frozen under some sort of murky fugitive/terrorist/organized crime laws.

Or maybe he took proactive steps to keep this from happening?

Re:Edward Snowden is Almost Broke by Theodores on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @06:46AM (#6724589)
If you blow the whistle on something then all of your resources are put into getting to the whistleblowing stage. The dedication is entirely devoted to the act, not the aftermath. All that is expected of the aftermath is a bumpy ride, the possibility of being universally despised, ostracised from society and so on. Money and the means to get by is not perceived to be such a big problem when one is fully prepared to end up in Guantanamo Bay. To some extent that is the end goal, in that respect Chelsea Manning succeeded. Snowden did pretty well getting to Russia, getting some hangers on to provide support and getting a job. The fact that he is broke is mere mortal stuff, he is waiting for his pay check to come through.

As any ex-cat-1 prisoner can tell you, life on the run is the most expensive way to live. With Snowden he has had many agencies after him, all with their different approaches. Obviously the U.S. have been on his case, they tend to be good at the sigint stuff but not so good at actual spy trade craft. I would not be at all surprised if there was a British team on his case too, better able to watch him pop to the shops for a pint of milk. Then the Russians will be monitoring everything, on their home turf and able to keep watch on who is keeping watch. Not all watchers will be hostile to him, after all we are all human (Tony Blair excepted), however, none of the many folks observing him will be able to assist him. They will watch him starve rather than intervene.

Presumably he is not as on-the-run as he has had to be, however, the practical implications of being completely on-the-run are more than you might think. Imagine he wants to be able to do things like sleep without being observed. That means he has to move every day, and at extremely short notice so anyone watching him does not get a head start, e.g. to bug a hotel room before he gets in there. He also has to pay cash up front just on the off chance he has lost his tail. Then the same again the next day and the day after that.

Eventually he will realise that trying to escape his watchers is a fruitless task and decide it is better to take a disinformation approach. At this stage he could try to convince those behind the bugs that he has gone mad. Claiming to be the messiah, pretending to have narrowly avoided being poisoned, hearing voices - standard lunatic stuff. He might also want to go the extra mile on proving that he is no longer an existential threat to the American Way of Life, taking up a pastime such as computer gaming, putting in marathon Playstation sessions and completely ignoring the news. After a year or so of doing this he will be able to convince himself that he has his privacy back and live the normal life.

Snowden probably also has had the problem of living off a good pay cheque and then having to adapt to a normal pay check, or no money at all. If you are used to paying thousands a month on accommodation, buying nice food and doing things like driving a car then it can take a while to adapt to barely having enough money to afford groceries for the next day. A mental attitude has to change, from being generous with tips to actually living off what that tip would be. That change does not happen so easily, even if circumstance forces that change to be necessary.

Anyway...

This talk of sending the guy a few bitcoins is far off from the reality of his situation. Sounds to me that he actually does have everything that he needs to live, i.e. a job and a few close friends. He has sorted himself out. He does not need to be beholden to charity handouts.

Re:Edward Snowden is Almost Broke by keithpeter on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @11:57AM (#6726479)
"...pretending to have narrowly avoided being poisoned, hearing voices - standard lunatic stuff."

Not so sure fear of poisoning would be evidence of mental illness in this case, depending on the nature of the poison.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polonium#Well-known_poisoning_c...

Re:Edward Snowden is Almost Broke by todayiamme on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @01:10PM (#6727075)
Hey,

Your description of a life on the run was quite interesting and I was wondering if I could ask a few questions - would it be possible to do that? (your profile does not have an email ID)

Re:Edward Snowden is Almost Broke by Theodores on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @09:27PM (#6730145)
Sure, what's wrong with keeping the conversation here?

I have no special insight gained from first hand experience, however, if I meet someone that has a criminal record I make friends rather than run away from them. There can be many benefits in doing this, e.g. you have someone that appreciates and respects your advice, they can possibly do a better job than the police in retrieving your belongings if they get stolen, you can obtain unobtainable 'black market' items, get to the best parties, find out information not in the public domain and so on. You also get the best stories. I merely presented a composite, abbreviated version of things I have learned along the way. I am sure the same stuff could be found in films and books. I am also sure that the spies know what cycle to expect from those they take care of.

Re:Edward Snowden is Almost Broke by Theodores on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @10:07PM (#6730275)
Your profile has no email ID either - was going to write!

Anyway, couple of other things for you, since you are interested in the topic...

In the movies the guy on the run is able to get some help and support, in real life moral courage coupled with cognitive dissonance, hostile propaganda and ineptness gets in the way of that. Hence Mr Snowden, for all his many supporters is probably alone in very subtle ways, even when amongst trusted friends. None of those around him have pushed back the fear boundaries or played a tight game in a sigint-hostile 'battlespace', therefore, even if their intentions are good, or they think they have good intentions, things like basic stupidity get in the way. (Note that stupidity is the most harmful thing in the known universe.) Furthermore, anything involving actual risk is not something an honourable sort like Mr Snowden can palm off on others, so he is very much stuck doing everything himself, with no meaningful organisation to help him.

This situation was also a serious problem for Martin Luther King. He was able to get millions to turn up in support of what he had to do, yet he was also deeply alone. Part of his popularity stems from this, people who were alone could relate to what he said.

Orwell's classic 1984 is also quite interesting. We all read it at school, however, I believe the book takes on a whole new level of insight to those that are blowing the whistle in a surveillance society. Details like Winston's health problems take on a peculiar relevance. However, Orwell did not go far enough on the subtleties of betrayal and stupidity.

Re:Edward Snowden is Almost Broke by mathattack on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @09:17AM (#6725261)
He wasn't making that much money, and some of it had to be in hard to reach places. (401Ks?) So even if he had 100K, how long will it last when you're travelling internationally and staying in expensive hotels?

Being a whistleblower doesn't excuse you from having to work for a living. I hope he's able to get decent employment.

Re:Edward Snowden is Almost Broke by strickjb9 on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @10:14AM (#6725621)
And cashing out your 401k while holding a Top Secret clearance sounds like a major red flag. If he did cash it out, I wonder if he stuck around to pay the tax penalties for doing so?
Re:Edward Snowden is Almost Broke by 300bps on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @10:34AM (#6725801)
401k administrators are required to discount any 401k payout by an estimate of the amount of tax you would owe including the 10% penalty. So if you cashed out $100,000 you'd likely only received a check for about $60,000. The rest would go directly to the IRS and if that made you pay too much you could get your refund the following year.

The IRS always get paid.

Re:Edward Snowden is Almost Broke by gryz on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @10:48AM (#6725926)
he could also take a loan from his 401k
Re:Edward Snowden is Almost Broke by iribe on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @11:19AM (#6726189)
They don't allow you to loan out >50% of your 401k.
Re:Edward Snowden is Almost Broke by ekianjo on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @03:14AM (#6723988)
Well he could have withdrawn some significant amount of cash before leaving, or put it in banks not controlled by US interests.
Re:Edward Snowden is Almost Broke by alexeisadeski3 on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @03:35AM (#6724040)
> or put it in banks not controlled by US interests.

That would probably be tough for him to have done.

Re:Edward Snowden is Almost Broke by khuey on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @05:23AM (#6724319)
Indeed. As Iran has found out, essentially the entire global financial system (via SWIFT, etc) will be closed off to you if the US is after you.
Re:Edward Snowden is Almost Broke by gahahaha on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @01:31PM (#6727248)
Another example: Wikileaks.
Re:Edward Snowden is Almost Broke by ekianjo on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @03:40AM (#6724064)
Why is that? After all, he knew that he was blowing out some serious secrets, and he did take the necessary steps to protect himself from direct retaliation at the time, and was advised on how to do so as well. It would not make much sense that he would have somehow "forgot" about protecting his financial assets.
Re:Edward Snowden is Almost Broke by pyre on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @03:54AM (#6724091)
The US has even bent the Swiss banks to their will. I think that "not under US influence" isn't a synonym for "outside of the US."

Withdrawing large amounts of cash, or transferring money to (e.g.) the Bank Melli Iran would have presumably raised red flags.

Re:Edward Snowden is Almost Broke by blackoil on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @04:20AM (#6724165)
depending on the amount HSBC/Citibank can be considered not under US influence.
Re:Edward Snowden is Almost Broke by digitalengineer on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @04:28AM (#6724191)
Everything that uses the SWIFT banking system is under the US control. So that's basically everything and everybody. That's wht some of the BRIC's are setting up their own SWIFT payment system...
Re:Edward Snowden is Almost Broke by sangnoir on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @06:20AM (#6724486)
I think you are overstating the amount of control the US has. The US is spying on SWIFT transactions, that's a world of a difference from actually controlling SWIFT.
Re:Edward Snowden is Almost Broke by digitalengineer on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @06:30AM (#6724523)
Did I really?

WallStreetJournal :"Both houses of the U.S. Congress have drafted legislation threatening to penalize Swift's board and owners if they didn't ban the suspect Iranian entities from using its network."

http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/SB1000142405297020479530...

Re:Edward Snowden is Almost Broke by Shivetya on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @11:18AM (#6726173)
Denial works as well as control. Deny access through,to, or from, it pretty much sufficient.

As the quote from Dune goes, He who can destroy a thing, controls a thing.

Re:Edward Snowden is Almost Broke by tzakrajs on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @10:51AM (#6725952)
Again, this quote says nothing of the US having control over the Swift network itself.
Re:Edward Snowden is Almost Broke by rgbrenner on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @07:28AM (#6724742)
Re:Edward Snowden is Almost Broke by mseebach on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @04:53AM (#6724249)
I don't think it's unreasonable to assume that the financial dealings of Top Secret personnel is under some level of surveillance.

It's not about where to move it to, but moving it in the first place.

Re:Edward Snowden is Almost Broke by officemonkey on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @08:16AM (#6724950)
OTOH, it would not be hard to play the "paycheck-to-paycheck game" and withdraw all his cash, spend very little of it, and launder it through his trusted friends who could very well have imported it to Hong Kong (at $9,999 per flight) before he flew the coop.
Re:Edward Snowden is Almost Broke by mseebach on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @10:32AM (#6725785)
I'd say that's exactly the kind of behaviour that gets flagged. Why did you shift from spending on your credit card and saving in your account to taking out almost all your money in cash every month? The guy made $100k+, that's a lot of money. Drug problem, trying to pay a blackmailer off?

Also, I wouldn't overestimate how many of his friends he could successfully enlist in what technically (if not morally) was a conspiracy to commit treason.

For something like this to be successful, it needs to come out of the blue.

Re:Edward Snowden is Almost Broke by officemonkey on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @10:45AM (#6725901)
I think you're overestimating the capacity of the security apparatus to monitor the security apparatus.

They have so much work that they have to hire contractors to do it. They rely on the clearance process to weed out the untrustworthy. Re-investigations are typically at 5 year intervals.

It would not surprise me that any person they have watching the store is someone who is being chided for not doing "real" work.

Basically "Quis custodiet ipsos custodes?" Nobody, apparently.

Re:Edward Snowden is Almost Broke by mseebach on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @10:58AM (#6726007)
So the same NSA that we believe to monitor all private, public and encrypted communications on the internet, and expect to render the privacy features Tor ineffective, does not have the competence to keep an eye on its own employees?
Re:Edward Snowden is Almost Broke by aetherson on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @02:43PM (#6727885)
It's a different competency.

The NSA tries to monitor all communication. If it fails to monitor 10% of the communication, or 5%, or 1%, it is still problematic that it monitors the other 90-99%.

If it retains control of the information it has captured at a 90-99% efficacy rate, on the other hand, that still basically means that it leaks information like a sieve.

Re:Edward Snowden is Almost Broke by officemonkey on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @11:12AM (#6726122)
Snowden is proof of that.
Re:Edward Snowden is Almost Broke by lightbritefight on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @11:57AM (#6726483)
Snowden is proof of part of that. The part that monitored him having access to and making copies of TS data failed. It doesn't mean any other part of the apparatus is incompetent.

Put another way, I have a friend who couldn't run a mile in less than an hour. He could easily put a bullet into an apple on your head at a couple hundred yards however. If we were to consider him an adversary, dismissing him because he cant run worth a damn would be unwise.

Re:Edward Snowden is Almost Broke by pwnna on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @10:40AM (#6725857)
Reading through this comment chain and seeing all the plausible speculations about how these guys' banking info are monitored for red flags..

a) Why are we not mad about that kinda thing? b) Doesn't the law of large numbers say that even if someone does something that looks weird, it might just be for random fluctuations? Or is the financial system too.. regular?

Re:Edward Snowden is Almost Broke by Pitarou on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @07:35PM (#6729711)
If they were that good, Snowden would have never exfiltrated all that data in the first place.

Judging from this report, they seem to have a misplaced faith in the ability of the almighty polygraph to root out insiders.

I quote: If you've been cleared and especially if you've been polygraphed, you're an insider and you are presumed to be trustworthy

<http://mobile.reuters.com/article/idUSBRE9A703020131108?irpc...

In any case, if you're financially well-disciplined (that's a very big if), it's easy to hide money somewhere and pretend you're blowing it on useless junk.

Re:Edward Snowden is Almost Broke by vinceguidry on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @10:55AM (#6725977)
There's actually a lot of people with TS clearances. When I was in the military, I and everybody I worked with had one. Just as how more information gets classified than is really necessary due to CYA, more personnel than strictly necessary gets processed for TS clearances simply due to the ubiquity of TS-classified information. You're talking tens of thousands of personnel. I doubt you could monitor them all any more closely than the rest of them.
Re:Edward Snowden is Almost Broke by mpyne on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @01:52PM (#6727427)
There's a difference between eligibility for a clearance (which is the screening process you refer to) and actually having a clearance. You have a clearance when you're at a job where one is required. When you depart that job your clearance is revoked (but the eligibility screening remains). So you don't need to monitor everyone with a screening, just those with an actual in-use clearance.
Re:Edward Snowden is Almost Broke by vinceguidry on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @02:16PM (#6727621)
I just went on Wikipedia to check my rough estimates. I was off by a few orders of magnitude. A WaPo article in 2010 claims 854,000 people had an active clearance. That's a lot of potential leakers.

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/08...

Re:Edward Snowden is Almost Broke by jsight on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @01:58PM (#6727474)
True, but that is still tens of thousands of people.