You then follow this with
> But if he was on the run, why was he carrying a cell phone? Answer: because he was stupid.
Your postulation that this is sufficient proof to say that they can track you with your phone off is suspect.
Given the fact that US law enforcement and security agencies are (now) indisputably known to be in the zero-day hacking business, the burden of proof is on those of us who've always claimed these stories were exaggerated.
Personally, I no longer feel confident about calling bullshit on much of anything. With the US government's infinite budget and unaccountable influence over device manufacturers and telcos, no hack is impossible.
Can a phone be tracked while off - or can you install malware that prevents your phone from turning off while misleading the user to believe that it worked?
The latter is a lot easier to believe and what you talk about. The discussion above/the post you answered is about the former.
If all the operations are carried on by the same kind of contractors, we can sleep tight for few years.
Funny thing is, it doesn't seem to matter where healthcare systems are carried out they always run over time and over budget and end up in a big mess!
When confronted with my government's incompetence, I never know whether to be pissed off or relieved.
It's tough to say. They say their mission is vital, but then their mission is literally to lie for a living.
I don't think there's too much social harm done in pointing this out. It seems to be so well known that it's referenced (visually or even verbally) in movies and TV shows like Breaking Bad, where the criminals take the batteries out of their phones as an extra precaution against being tracked.
And I join the crowd who think that is impossible. I bet someone would notice weird patterns if the baseband kept working despite of device off. (Speakers catching 2G, battery drain, interference with other devices, etc.)
Given the types of people that would have to have access / knowledge of this though. For example people that suspect their partner of infidelity and is on the police liaison team of a carrier say...
I agree it's very unlikely, someone would have noticed it by now.
Though, not receiving any information back, draws the tracking practice significantly more difficult.
You could argue that "off" is the same thing, for instance, many Qualcomm devices boot with the BP first and and can do a lot before the AP is even taken out of halt, without initializing the LCD display, backlight, etc.
* Push the airplane mode button.
* Have the FAA place the phone in a faraday cage for testing the phone.
* Don't remotely activate the phone at this point (which you wouldn't be able to anyway, the phone is in a faraday cage )
* "Forget" to tell the FAA about the cellular equivalent of "wake on lan" we built into this phone.
Would removing the SIM be at all helpful for avoiding tracking if you couldn't ditch a phone with an integrated battery?
And there may be a legitimate reason why you may want to have a device. For instance, to run maps at a certain location. Or having data on the device you need once you arrive at a destination.
So if we were using these numbers to block messages then I'd absolutely expect government agencies to use them to monitor or track phones.
Then if in court you can try to argue that for a tin foil hat like you, the actual tin foil cell phone protection isn't an indication of anything. And much less suspicious.
:-).
Not sure how it could be fully applied if in the police interrogation room having been apprehended in a dark alleyway with two large bin bags full of steaming skunk weed, freshly purchased off a Vietnamese gentleman insistent on counting every note of that £20000 just handed to him. Maybe that is just an edge case though.
Perhaps a better idea (and market opportunity) could be a 'walkers rucksack' that has a pocket for your cellphone. This pocket could be lined specifically to act as a Faraday Cage, explicitly so that you can have easy access to your phone for maps etc., yet be fairly certain that your day strolling in the hills will not be interrupted by the office, the wife and other cold callers. Such a bag could be plausibly denied in a way that plain old tin foil could not be.
This is correct. The rule of thumb is this: If you need to avoid being tracked, do not under any circumstances carry a cell phone unless you have removed the battery. Even if it's powered off, it can still be activated to remotely track you as long as the battery is in it. This tactic was used in catching the recent serial killer Luka. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luka_Magnotta
From the article: "His cell phone signal was traced to a hotel in Bagnolet, but he had left by the time police arrived.[55]"
You can bet that, since he was on the run, his cell phone was off.
There are other examples besides Luka. Circumstantial evidence is very strong that law enforcement can track you if you've powered off your phone but haven't removed the battery.
(I feel so strange posting this comment, since those who would benefit from this advice are probably of dubious character.)
EDIT: I edited my comment before Guvante's reply. But it looks like some people aren't really convinced. So here's another comment, from tlb 113 days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6087399
"There is reason to believe phones have been remotely hacked by law enforcement using carrier credentials to leave the cellular radio running and registering with the cell network even after the off button has been pushed and the phone appears to be off. Starting point for further reading: http://www.brighthub.com/electronics/gps/articles/51103.aspx "
tlb = Trevor Blackwell, one of the best electronics hackers in the world. You may know him as the creator of the first robot that walks like a human. http://paulgraham.com/anybots.html
Now I've presented circumstantial evidence and an appeal to authority, so of course feel free to doubt me. But don't be surprised to discover you've been tracked when carrying a powered-off cellphone with a battery in it.