What that means is that they sat there with $20K in unpaid credit card bills, they got hassled by collection agencies, now the money they didn't have is unpaid taxes, which means the IRS will hunt them down, garnish their wages, take their property, and if necessary put them in jail.
The correct thing to do from a disruptive/#occupy perspective is to buy the debt and then give the debtor new terms. They could make the terms require repayment, and forgiven on death. Then it is still a 'debt' (so so tax hit) but you don't have to pay it back (so no worry and debt collectors hounding you), If you die the IRS can try to get their pound of flesh out of your presumably destitute estate.
Just send them a message like:
"Hey we're a non-profit founded by Occupy Wallstreeters that bought your debt dirt cheap for X dollars directly from the last debt collection agency to hold your debt. You don't need to do anything now, we'll hold onto it forever if need be. However, if it turns out you need to "check back into the credit economy", we'll sell it to you at cost. Be aware, that doing so will create "income" for you in the eyes of the IRS, so only choose to buy this back if you can also afford to pay them as well in the same fiscal year. You can visit this link and put in your current income to calculate approximately how much you would owe the IRS if we were to opt for us to forgive this debt. Again, you don't have to do anything and we're never going to call you and pester at work like credit collections do."
It also explains why getting a loan is not considered income, because it will be paid back. The interest you pay is income for the entity issuing the loan.
If that entity now "forgives" the debt, it now becomes income for the borrower. They could presumably file a "loss" for the interest they will now not be getting.
Did I get that right?
This would also mean this kind of open a possibility of tax fraud. Companies issuing "loans" to employees, instead of paying salaries. I am sure IRS has something against that as well.
I experienced it when I got some restricted stock (not an option but you can't sell it right way) when my company was acquired in the dot.com boom. I also got a "loan" to pay the taxes. The idea was that when the stock was available to sell, you could sell enough to pay tax on the loan forgiveness and keep the rest. (yes it was kind of convoluted but such were the times). Long story short, stock that was worth $35 in 1999 was worth $0.66 in 2001. Kinda bites big time. And yes you can take the loss, but only up to $3,000 and carry the rest forward to the next year. I believe that last year was the first year I didn't have any dot.com losses I could claim any more on my taxes :-).
Wesley Snipes - failure to pay
Nicolas Cage - threatened
Willy Nelson - threatened ( I think he got probation )
Generally the pattern is very similar, taxes don't get paid, there is some reasoning on the part of the taxpayer why they didn't pay their tax, they are charged with evasion and work from there. This is because typically people who owe taxes they don't have the money to pay, don't file a tax return, which is the minimum definition of "evasion" according to my CPA friends. I am much less familiar with people who file a tax return, indicate they owe more than has been withheld, and then just let it go at that. I don't doubt they are out there but I just haven't seen the details of any cases like that (would be interested though if they are out there, searching the web hasn't turned up much, the IRS suggests you talk to them [1], they don't go into 'you talked to us and still won't pay')
[1] http://www.irs.gov/uac/Failure-to-File-or-Pay-Penalties:-Eig...
http://edition.cnn.com/2013/10/04/showbiz/lauryn-hill-releas...
Not filing your taxes is a step beyond not paying your taxes.
Alternatively, I could agree to pay myself back the full 20k at current interest rates so as to not create a tax singularity.