News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The plot against France by jypepin on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @02:44PM (#6720391)
Disclaimer: I am French, live now in SF because the rent price and everything else, life is better here. I wish I could say this post is 100% true, but here my thoughts about some invalid points;

France is not only "experiencing economic difficulties". France has never experienced such difficulties. I'm not talking numbers, S&P ratings, or else, but as the population's feeling, buying power and general happiness.

I think that something was forgotten here, and it's the environment in which you cut spendings/raise taxes. Cutting spendings in the USA, where the policies are already ultra-capitalistic and spendings and small, it might be bad - In a country like France, with a left tendency (even when right is governing, it's way more socialist than the USA), cutting spendings sometimes doesn't hurt - and it's hard to justify more spendings.

When Sarkozy (right) was governing and the crisis started, he adopted a "cut spendings" policy, as criticized so much in this article, and well, it was obviously not welcomed by the people, but it allowed the country to get through the crises better than most other european countries. A lot of things seemed really bad and implemented, mostly because of the newspapers being biased and wanting to sell. e.g. a big scandal when he raised the age limit for retirement. It was only for one or two years on average, and a lot of "dangerous" and "hard" jobs categories were not touched. There were simply no more money in the bank, and paying was just impossible unless raising debt and printing money. No thanks. And when you compare, the retirement system in France was the more generous in Europe, with average retirement age often lower of 5+ years. This is just an example amongst others.

Now Hollande is governing (left). For the quick background, he is the complete opposite of Sarkozy. Sarkozy was the "bling bling" president, loving America and capitalism, etc. Hollande said on television he hates rich people, and does everything to be the poor class, normal, president. Robin Hood in a sense. Higher taxes (75% for one million revenue), more taxes if your net worth is high (even if no income), to the point that every rich known personality from France (actors, businessmen, etc.) are leaving and getting other nationalities, to not have to pay those taxes, because too high.

When you are in your 20s, and get out of school a Master, or 2, which is the norm now if you want to be able to hope to find a job, there is an all-time high unemployment rate. Opportunities are rare, etc.

And now, Hollande is the less-appreciated president of all time for France. His popularity was the lowest a president ever had after only a few months of presidency.

So, I am no politics analyst, or whatever, but this is a feeling as a person from France, seeing my country getting worse and worse because everything done is against entrepreneurship and lowering workers motivations. Seeing all my fellow french moving to the US, Canada, Argentina, Asia, and after only a few weeks, being so glad to call those places home, and saying they would never go back to France, because anywhere they are, it's so much better.

I'm not saying we should always cut taxes and never spend more, but this article misses a lot of point and is not really objective - "France’s remarkable health care system, which delivers high quality at low cost"- Yes it's remarkable, but it costs A LOT.

Just my 2cents :)

Re:The plot against France by grey-area on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @02:56PM (#6720507)
Completely agree with your other points, but on healthcare I would note:

Yes it's remarkable, but it costs A LOT.

It still costs far less than the equivalent expenditure per capita in the US on healthcare. [1]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_total_hea...

Re:The plot against France by jypepin on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @03:04PM (#6720545)
Oh, that's an interesting point!

Does this number includes public AND private? How is it calculated?

In France there is basic healthcare, which is really good and free for everyone (free as in taxes!) and then a lot of people have additional private healthcare -

I wonder if this number is included, because for what I remember, additional healthcare in France is about the same price as healthcare in the USA. Add to it the price of the public healthcare, which I assume is higher than USA, simply because more services, and the logic is, the overall is more expensive?

Re:The plot against France by scarmig on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @03:27PM (#6720736)
It does include both private and public. You'd have to dig into the different reports to figure out exact methodologies (which I'm too lazy to do right now), but most reports converge on the USA being the country that spends the most on healthcare, both on a per capita basis (which is less interesting, we're richer than most other countries so we should spend more) but also on a % GDP basis. And we win by a large margin on that metric, despite getting pretty mediocre bang for buck.

Various theories explain this: inefficiencies, the USA subsidizing research for the rest of the world, etc. Really they're two sides of the same coin--those inefficiencies line the pockets of various medical-related corporations, some of which ends up going into research.

Re:The plot against France by jypepin on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @03:36PM (#6720818)
Oh I see, thanks for the details!
Re:The plot against France by fleitz on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @04:28PM (#6721281)
Same thing in Canada, a lot of the US seems to envy our healthcare system and the current system is cheaper per capita than medicare in the US, even before Obama and Bush expanded coverage.
Re:The plot against France by jypepin on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @06:14PM (#6722103)
healthcare in Canada is still pretty horrible, and over flooded. Having to wait ~10h in emergency because of a minor problem... might as well not go. (lived 10 years in Canada so I know!)
Re:The plot against France by fleitz on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @06:24PM (#6722177)
I'm not a huge fan of it either, but we certainly get more for our public dollar than the US does which was my point.

Generally the emergency room works on a triage process so going there with a minor issue means everyone with serious issues gets treated first.

If you want to go to the emerg room with a minor issue and get treated in a reasonable amount of time you may want to consider whether one of your symptoms is having trouble breathing. A quick run before going to the emerg if you're out of shape quite often produces this symptom.

Re:The plot against France by toomuchtodo on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @01:16AM (#6723673)
Have you ever had an ambulance ride and 6 hours in the ER cost you ~$15K USD? This is normal in the US.
Re:The plot against France by jkn on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @03:49PM (#6720923)
Holland said on television he hates rich people

It is unfortunate to misquote someone in such a polarized debate. What Hollande really said is better translated as "I don't like rich people, I don't like rich people, I have to admit".[1] Why put more violent words in his mouth?

(As mentioned in the linked article, he also later said: "This was too short a wording. I appreciate talent, work, merit. What I don't accept is indecent wealth.")

[1] http://www.liberation.fr/politiques/2012/09/10/hollande-anti...

Re:The plot against France by sologoub on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @03:56PM (#6720988)
"Indecent wealth" is a very culturally-specific term, and I suspect every country has their own grading. Where is the line in the French society?
Re:The plot against France by atestu on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @05:05PM (#6721574)
It's okay to be rich -- just pretend you aren't. Don't have a big car, don't have flashy clothes. In France people have a tendency to be suspicious about wealth. If you're rich you probably either got it from your family or you exploited people to get it. I'm painting a caricature here but it's not far from the truth. French people don't really celebrate financial success.

(I'm French)

Re:The plot against France by sologoub on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @04:45PM (#6728808)
Thank you.

I've had very similar experience with Russian culture. It seems to have split into two really - 1) people obsessed with wealth and acquiring it, 2) people that are very suspicious of wealth and blame societal/economic problems on the first group.

Re:The plot against France by jypepin on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @06:17PM (#6722122)
sorry for misquoting. The point was not to trash talk, but to show in what culture he is governing; Even if he meant "indecent wealth", some people will have "indecent wealth" and are still a part of the people he is supposed to govern. Don't think you should say/fell like that :)
Re:The plot against France by speeder on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @03:00PM (#6720526)
I am from.Brazil, and the influx of French here ( including my associate ) is mind blowing for me... I mean, how is that possible? Usually Brazilians dreamed with France, not the other way around!!!!
Re:The plot against France by jypepin on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @03:05PM (#6720549)
I know. I was in Argentina 2 weeks ago, and was amazed at how many french were living in Buenos Aires. Either they came directly to work, or came as exchange student and never left/came back as soon as they could!
Re:The plot against France by novalis78 on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @04:38PM (#6721367)
As an expat German I feel almost the same way as you. Maybe a Western European phase...
Re:The plot against France by epsylon on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @03:04AM (#6723969)
> Seeing all my fellow french moving to the US, Canada, Argentina, Asia, and after only a few weeks, being so glad to call those places home, and saying they would never go back to France, because anywhere they are, it's so much better.

Of course, but that's probably because your friends are educated middle class / upper middle class people.

I can tell you that most of my lower working class (who are working their asses off for a minimum wage) friends and family are much better off in France than they would be in the US, Canada or Asia.

What's the lesson here? The more money you make, the more incentives you have to move to a country where that money buys you more, or where that money is less taxed. Typically countries where the inequality gap is higher.

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/3/32/Gini_Coef...

> When Sarkozy (right) was governing and the crisis started, he adopted a "cut spendings" policy

He also adopted tax cuts for the richest.

Honestly I don't like Hollande more than anyone else, but Sarkozy's tenure was catastrophic on many points, and the picture you are painting doesn't match reality - or at least, it only matches the reality of people who don't have a large view enough on the different ends of the wealth spectrum. You may be no political analyst, but your message has a strongly political bias.

> Higher taxes (75% for one million revenue), more taxes if your net worth is high (even if no income), to the point that every rich known personality from France (actors, businessmen, etc.) are leaving and getting other nationalities, to not have to pay those taxes, because too high.

FUD and bullshit. The 75% is for revenues ABOVE 1M, which is very different from 75% on all revenues - in fact, there used to be a higher taxation rate in the 1930s in France, which was set at 90%. After WWII, the USA had similarly high rates (from 91% during WWII to 70% in 1964). Bullshit because only a few high profile personalities are whining (mostly actors and overpaid footballers, cry me a river), most of them well-known friends of the French right wing parties. And also because of the large number of tax exemptions who are mostly applicable to wealthy people (because they require capital to invest into real-estate and companies), their real taxation rate is usually low, even lower than middle class workers. Liliane Bettencourt, the richest woman in France (and a friend of Sarkozy) was revealed a few years ago to have approximately a 9% tax rate. It's a very similar story to Warren Buffet who had a lower tax rate than his secretary.

[deleted]
Re:The plot against France by jypepin on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @03:37PM (#6720826)
Oh God, how could I misspell this 3 times ah! Thanks, edited!