News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google F1 vs. FoundationDB's SQL Layer by rdtsc on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @01:00PM (#6719462)
The tough sell for me is -- I don't see the source code. 10 whitepapers and 15 blog posts comparing to Google doesn't add to credibility. That works for investors and for fun recreational reading. Show me how you do write locking, let's see your cluster membership module.

Perhaps, they want to be Oracle or DB2, that's fine, and I understand that, different market perhaps. But they don't have the credibility those companies do. Even Google's F1 has more credibility because well, because of brand name recognition.

Look at these other DB products I might want to choose, all with available source code: RethinkDB, PostreSQL, Riak, CouchDB, SQLite, MariaDB, MongoDB, Couchbase, Cassandra.

At this point, databases are a bit like operating system, there is no way I am picking a closed source operating system if I have a choice. It is just too critical of a component to be closed under a sealed lid.

Yes they all have different features and maybe FoundationDB does something better, I will still put it last in whatever category, just because I want to be able to look at how it works.

Re:Google F1 vs. FoundationDB's SQL Layer by bitdiddle on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @01:13PM (#6719572)
agreed! I just downloaded and installed and can't for the life of me find the source code.

perhaps by open source they mean the collection of clients on Github

Re:Google F1 vs. FoundationDB's SQL Layer by Dave_Rosenthal on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @01:21PM (#6719652)
The SQL layer (which is compared to Google F1 in the blog post) is open-source (it is not yet released; an older version is on GitHub: https://github.com/FoundationDB/sql-layer). This means that the SQL parser, query planner, execution engine, etc. can all be audited, examined, and changed.

You are correct that the FoundationDB storage engine itself (transactional key-value store) is closed-source. (It is free for production use in smaller cluster, and available for license for larger clusters.)

Re:Google F1 vs. FoundationDB's SQL Layer by bitdiddle on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @01:34PM (#6719782)
Thanks for the clarification, my interest was academic and piqued by the use of hierarchical structures. Best of luck with it!
Re:Google F1 vs. FoundationDB's SQL Layer by jb007 on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @01:29PM (#6719731)
I don't need to see source code to use a software. Maybe I need to see source code to get some ideas to help me with my own software I'm building that I'm having problems with.