Anyway, you seem pretty [sure](http://www.idlewords.com/2005/04/dabblers_and_blowhards.htm) of your opinion so it's probably not worth further discussion.
Haskell's roots in academia often steer the discussion towards theoretical PL, which seriously hurts Haskell adoption. I actually like tikhonj's comment because it focused on practicality rather than jargon, so in response I merely pointed out that Haskell is not 100% pure gain in practical terms. That does not mean we shouldn't all adopt it, it just means that the jury is still out.
On the other hand, I don't think your 99.something are a feature of humanity, they are the result of the last decades of mainstream programming development. It took me less than a year of on-and-off Haskell hobby fiddling to find functional and non-strict less awkward to think in than imperative and strict.
How is this relevant?
> If you tell me it's less than 99.999%, then you're being dishonest. 99.999% is a "feature of humanity".
Make all && and || strict in all C, C++, Java, C# code, and chaos will reign.
||(f,g){
if (eval(f)) then return true
if (eval(g)) then return true
return false
}
A lazy language will not evaluate a function until it knows it needs it. In this implementation, there is no way of knowing that g will be needed until after computing f, so f will be computed first. Having said that, it is possible for an optimizing compiler to realize that the order doesn't matter and make a decision on which one to check first, however that is an optimization that the compiler would need to prove does not change the results.This seems like a good example of why purity seems to be really beneficial to lazy evaluation.
"Not normal", because the language is strict, and there is no way to make a lazy function on your own, even when it is so tremediously useful.
In other words, the C standard comittee decides which functions may be lazy. As a Haskell programmer, you decide.
> technically Haskell is non-strict, not lazy.
Now, see, I don't care. Neither does anyone really other than PL researchers. I mean, I can care in my spare time if I like spending it on PL research, but when I write a 2 MLOC software for a large customer, I couldn't care less whether "technically" it's "non-strict" or "lazy". As far as I, the programmer, is concerned, it's lazy. If one must be this familiar with PL jargon in order to program Haskell, then this is a problem.
> but don't pretend its a feature of humanity. All runtimes come with assumptions.
Again, I'm not trying to make a provable statement (how does that joke go? you can tell if someone is a mathematician if everything they tell you is all true and all irrelevant). We're talking software engineering, right? So what percentage of production code anywhere in the world is written in an eager (strict, whatever) language? If you tell me it's less than 99.999%, then you're being dishonest. 99.999% is a "feature of humanity". If your point is that education can change people's habit and way of thinking, I say, you're absolutely right. Go for it, and we'll talk again in 15 years.
> All runtimes come with assumptions.
Again, true but irrelevant. Some assumptions are more familiar and therefore feel more "natural",and some are less so.
I wasn't dissing Haskell. It's a very impressive and elegant language. I was only pointing out that while it has some advantages from a software engineering perspective, it also has some disadvantage.