News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Page not found by timje1 on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @07:09AM (#6717272)
This bet was attacked by feminists (rightly? or too sensitive?) : the idea of it being a humiliating punishment for a respectable businessman having to dress up like a woman and serve other men.

So it was my understanding that Virgin backed away from this bet and tried to downplay it.

I'm a bit surprised by this picture cropping up on the website. Am I being hypersensitive? No-one else seems to have picked up on this aspect in the comments yet.

edit: to clarify, here's the comment threads on a jezebel, a website with a significantly more active female membership http://jezebel.com/richard-branson-serves-juice-on-the-airli...

Some examples - It's so disrespectful to their cabin crew (particularly female cabin crew, and also women in general) that they're dressing up as them for a laugh.

But being a woman is a punchline, right? Because being female is about as low, ridiculous and debased as a person can get, riiiiight? I'm glad I'm not the only one who had that reaction; I was too afraid to say anything lest I be accused of having no sense of humour

So I don't think that I'm making this up, or alone in thinking this. There's definitely a discussion to be had.

Re:Page not found by tinco on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @07:20AM (#6717319)
1. Many men find it humiliating to dress like a woman and do make up. 2. Many men find it humiliating to serve for their competitor. 3. Richard Branson is a man.

All the logical prepositions you need to show that there is at least one interpretation for the events that does not involve misogyny.

Why bend over backwards to smear a man who has made so many women rich and powerful?

Re:Page not found by timje1 on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @07:54AM (#6717458)
It's still possible that a man "who has made so many women rich and powerful" might do something distasteful or misjudged - and it's possible to propose a discussion about this behaviour without it turning into a smear.

The fact that many men find it humiliating to dress like a woman is exactly what I find distasteful. With my apologies for escalating the rhetoric : many men find the idea of sex with another man humiliating - does this justify making fun of homosexuals?

Re:Page not found by tinco on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @08:12AM (#6717551)
No, and he is not making fun of women, he is making fun of his own masculinity.

And there's a difference between making fun of homosexuals to hurt them, and to make fun of them to be merry with them.

Thirdly, your opinion on the feelings of men in general is rather inconsequential. What do you want to do, flog every man who finds it humiliating to dress in drag?

Re:Page not found by JonnieCache on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @10:52AM (#6718460)
No. He wants to have a discussion of gender issues to try and increase mutual understanding and global human happiness.

Unfortunately that's an almost impossible discussion to have, because some people always divert the community into a pointless meta-discussion about whether it's legitimate to have the first discussion or not.

I've almost never seen HN discuss gender. I've seen it discuss discussing gender for pages and pages and pages...

Re:Page not found by tinco on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @11:11AM (#6718578)
Yes man, stop doing that.
Re:Page not found by nness on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @07:35AM (#6717378)
I would say that "punishment" is the wrong word, and with it, we can draw much stronger negative interpretations that I feel might be appropriate. To me it looks like it was a social bet, between two friends, and he is doing it for fun (and to poke fun at himself). I would imagine that would fall pretty close to the definition of a drag queen (particularly the accentuation of certain characteristics, it does look very over the top).

Given his appearance, the bet may have been explicit in saying that they would need to to dress in drag (and not "dress as a women"). Some might argue they are different, and in that, he's not saying "it is humiliating to be a women" but rather "it is funny to contrast how I normally look with something so different."

Re:Page not found by peterwwillis on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @09:57AM (#6718146)
The only reason anyone gets pissed off at stunts like this is they feel like somebody isn't taking them seriously. But the whole point of the stunt IS TO NOT BE TAKEN SERIOUSLY. The real joke is that anyone using this as an example of sexism, transphobia or offensive behavior is making their own cause seem trivial.

Give me a picture that involves sex, gender, skin color, religion, country, or any other thing that can make a person feel offended, and I will find you someone more than willing to yell about it without knowing any context whatsoever.

Re:Page not found by lucasnemeth on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @07:49AM (#6717438)
You're not being hypersensitive, this is sexist and transphobic. Let's imagine if he had lost a bet and had to paint his face black, and them serve his competitors, everybody would agree that's racist. I don't even think there is much to discuss here.
Re:Page not found by bmelton on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @10:55AM (#6718482)
Not everyone would agree that was racist.
Re:Page not found by bruceboughton on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @07:15AM (#6717293)
>> Am I being hypersensitive?

Yes, you are.

Re:Page not found by spuz on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @07:38AM (#6717394)
I think you should say "some feminists". The great 99% of the rest of us really don't see the problem with it.
Re:Page not found by ksrm on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @09:45AM (#6718078)
"Don't speak for everyone! That's my job!"
Re:Page not found by circuiter on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @07:26AM (#6717344)
> This bet was attacked by feminists (rightly? or too sensitive?)

Everything you do gets attacked by someone. If you ate meat for dinner; if you drove a car; if you use Microsoft Windows; if you didn't pray to Zeus, you offended someone's sensitivities. So if feminists attacked this bet, just ignore them.

Re:Page not found by sp332 on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @10:34AM (#6718348)
As a (male) feminist, I think Jezebel is full of people who just like piling on. Maybe it's a community bonding thing, or maybe it's cathartic, but the comments sections are always overblown.
Re:Page not found by girvo on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @10:48AM (#6718439)
The understatement of the year...
Re:Page not found by mattwritescode on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @07:22AM (#6717324)
Being too sensitive, all it is, is a man who likes to dress up in ladies clothes (or are men not allowed to do this any more ;-P)
Re:Page not found by 001sky on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @07:17AM (#6717307)
Re:Page not found by timje1 on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @07:20AM (#6717317)
There's a big difference between wearing drag for theatre, personal empowerment, kicks / w/e, and being forced to dress like a woman as a punishment or forfeit.
Re:Page not found by nness on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @07:35AM (#6717382)
Is it punishment? He's not under any kind of duress.
Re:Page not found by timje1 on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @09:41AM (#6718049)
Perhaps punishment was too strong. But it was a forfeit on a bet, and the implication of having to dress up as one of the female cabin crew as a forfeit is distasteful at best, however innocent the intention.
Re:Page not found by 001sky on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @10:15AM (#6718230)
Dressing up in drag is a time honoured tradition for comedy sketches. In places like London or New York city (that have strong arts and theatre traditions) this is a completely normal thing. Nobody would beat an eyelash at a transestite or a drag queen. The Mayor of New York used to do it all the time.[1] By turning this bet into a comedy sketch, branson is just displaying some wit, and he pulls it off.

> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mayoralty_of_Rudy_Giuliani#Dra...

That being said, you have every right to be offended.

However, It seems a bit rich tho that you need to justify your offense by quoting some 3rd party "explanation" and then trying to sell other people on it. You're not selling your own view, in that case IMHO.

Re:Page not found by timje1 on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @10:30AM (#6718320)
That's very true, it was just simply that I had multiple friends (feminists and LBGT+ individuals) that were offended when the original pictures came out - this was the first thing that came to mind when visiting the 404 page. "Oh, I remember this, it offended lots of people".

Then I come to this thread on HN and absolutely no-one had commented on the controversy (at the time of my original comment) - I figured this was down to the skewed demographics of the site. So I raised it as a point of discussion, to see what the community thought, and to try to provoke a bit of discussion of the apparently overlooked aspects of this piece.

I agree that he pulled it off with great humour, but I can't help but wince at the insensitivity of a rich straight guy losing a bet and having to dress up as a parody of his own female flight staff (who earn 1000x less than him) ...

Re:Page not found by 001sky on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @10:42AM (#6718391)
I think folks should keep an open mind as to why this works. It works because a 404 page is normally a f@_kup, and here its a gag. Frankly, it still works if you don't know its branson. Trying to "put lipstick on a pig" is the underlying subtext (ie, they are trying to cover-up their fuckup). If you think about pulling that off with...a real person Its not gonna work now is it? Hence...drag.
Re:Page not found by drone on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @12:17PM (#6719127)
So, by that same token, is not being forced to give cash as a result of losing a bet distasteful and disrespectful of the poor?

Shall we all go through a committee to get pre-approval before taking any action to ensure that it offends no one? At what point does the lone last misogynist become our Harrison Bergeron?

Re:Page not found by sp332 on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @10:31AM (#6718330)
Being British, he could have done a much better job of the drag outfit :) The "punishment" is doing a bad job of looking like a woman!
Re:Page not found by hmottestad on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @07:25AM (#6717341)
I agree with you, however I was wondering why showing cross dressing as a 404 page was funny. I much prefer the github 404 page or the one from hw.no http://www.hardware.no/abc