Re:Rate/review Newsbrane.com - personalized news recommendation
by ynniv on Tuesday June 23, 2009 @11:30AM
(#670540)
Yes - suggesting that your product might "replace" HN creates preconceptions in my mind before I get there. I see the link, I imagine startup relevant topics, I see dinosaur comics. WTF? Fail.
Re:Rate/review Newsbrane.com - personalized news recommendation
by lincolnq on Tuesday June 23, 2009 @12:01PM
(#670603)
Whoops, sorry to give you the wrong preconceptions. If you train it by voting a bunch, you can make it give you whatever topics you like, startup news definitely included. If you don't have the patience to train it, I've heard that feedback before, and that's an axis along which we don't have a good answer yet -- though hopefully we will soon!
Re:Rate/review Newsbrane.com - personalized news recommendation
by ynniv on Tuesday June 23, 2009 @01:29PM
(#670770)
Thats okay, marketing is a learned skill.
You might try making some profile templates that I can start with. The landing page could say, if you like Hacker News, click here, if you like XKCD, click here, etc. Clicking would copy the profile of a user that you have pre-trained with items that are like that site.
I know you are thinking about how to unseat the competition, but asking people to try out your tool with an eye toward abandoning something that we like is not the best approach, in my opinion.
I don't want to "replace" Hacker News. I assume that I am not alone -- many people are very loyal to HN, and like the community and the information found here. We're not looking to dump it in favor of something else, although if it's a compelling product I might use it in addition to HN.