So is beating up your weak neighbour to take his food for your dinner. We're supposed to be more civilised than that by now.
Look at any of the half dozen recent "whoops, you weren't a founder after all" legal kurfuffles removing millions of dollars from people ("ex-friends, now enemies").
People are forgetful, but less forgiving. If you "fix" forgetfulness, and make memory of your actions eternal and immortal, you destroy second chances.
I can't help but think that we've crossed that bridge, and that in the near future everything about anyone will forever be obtainable. Avoiding this situation will require collaboration around safeguarding individual privacy on a scale we haven't accomplished up to now.
Well, Google certainly retains things for longer than NSA or GCHQ does, and in any event you're describing a problem that is not new or peculiar to the Internet.
Anon is already quite fond of reminding us that "The Internet Does Not Forget". They mean this in regard to the actions of states or corporations, but the shoe does apply to the other foot.
Likewise the government already maintains permanent private and public records on many people as a matter of course.
The Germans have a very insightful legal structure on data privacy which basically forbids both collection of needless data and retention past relatively short timeframes, but I suspect that it will eventually become yet another way of trying to wash away reality via the law, as we see so often in the U.S. The Internet has popped the data genie well and truly out of its bottle, and it's high time we came to grips with that.
> If you "fix" forgetfulness, and make memory of your actions eternal and immortal, you destroy second chances.
Not at all. The correct action is in any event to allow for second chances fully appreciating that the person has previous faults. For starters it's only fair; none of us are perfect. But also, we already live in a world where people end up with scarlet letters and so it is already necessary (not simply a good idea, but required) the the law and society both are able to give people second chances.
If we can't already give second chances then we have much bigger problems to solve as a society. If we can give second chances already then the idea of our mistakes being captured can simply become a new normal, just like cell phones replaced landlines and automobiles replaced the horse and buggy.
Mass surveillance is a terrible idea not because of the potential for personal embarrassment but rather for the countless ways it can go very wrong.
People instinctively dislike spying because they want to be in control of their own PR (social status), and secrecy gives them advantage even while it hurts society as a whole due to information asymmetries. Gossip networks tend to distort the true picture as well. This, humans evolved to protect their own secrets while simultaneously snooping and gossiping on their neighbors.
However, living in an organized society involves compromise for the greater good, and community surveillance is one of those compromises. One might as well ask why the Brits accept paying taxes. Instinctively, you hate to part with your money, but you must do it.