News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Row over US mobile phone 'cockroach backpack' app by thaumasiotes on Saturday November 09, 2013 @08:00AM (#6701513)
You've got a strange idea of what science is.

> It's just a toy. There's no science taught here. It's just idle noodling.

This doesn't remind you of, say, a C64? The kit is a tool. You can do different things with it. If, at any point, someone using the kit thinks to themselves "what would happen if I did X?" and then does X to see what happens, that is citizen science.

> The other problem is really bad toys being sold as "science" with nothing sciency about them.

This is a problem, although in my experience it's not a large one. It definitely doesn't apply here, though; witness yourself the people saying they've worked on similar projects.

I've already mentioned several questions about the product that implicate "science" generally:

- can you mount a camera on the roach? If you can, and it acts naturally afterwards (or even naturally with the caveat that it's stopped fitting into cockroach-sized cracks), you'll pick up extremely valuable footage that a biologist studying cockroaches would love to have.

- Will other cockroaches accept one that's had this kit installed? If not, why not?

- Can I use my RC cockroach to influence the behavior of a swarm? Choose for them where they'll sleep? Dictate what left-out food they choose to eat and what they pass by? Cockroaches are social. Using one to manipulate a colony would be huge.

Re:Row over US mobile phone 'cockroach backpack' app by DanBC on Saturday November 09, 2013 @08:28AM (#6701563)
> This doesn't remind you of, say, a C64?

No, it doesn't. The C64 and other early home computers came with extensive instruction manuals detailing the memory map and all the language instruction. People would enter a program. They'd debug it. They'd modify it. They'd create their own programs.

Compare that to the toy - find bug, attach device, SCIENCE.

It's really shitty marketing.

> I've already mentioned several questions about the product that implicate "science" generally:

If they had any of those in any of the marketing or the instructions they might just be able to scrape by calling this a science toy. They don't. By your definition any toy becomes a science toy. Look! Drop it off a building! That's gravity!

Re:Row over US mobile phone 'cockroach backpack' app by thaumasiotes on Saturday November 09, 2013 @08:46AM (#6701599)
> By your definition any toy becomes a science toy. Look! Drop it off a building! That's gravity!

Well, first I'll note that my high school physics class involved labs demonstrating various well-known properties of gravity. I found them a waste of time, but that seems to be a minority opinion.

But let me repeat myself:

"If, at any point, someone using the kit thinks to themselves "what would happen if I did X?" and then does X to see what happens, that is citizen science."

I'm happy to stand by that statement as to any toy. But it's especially likely with a toy like this.