> It's just a toy. There's no science taught here. It's just idle noodling.
This doesn't remind you of, say, a C64? The kit is a tool. You can do different things with it. If, at any point, someone using the kit thinks to themselves "what would happen if I did X?" and then does X to see what happens, that is citizen science.
> The other problem is really bad toys being sold as "science" with nothing sciency about them.
This is a problem, although in my experience it's not a large one. It definitely doesn't apply here, though; witness yourself the people saying they've worked on similar projects.
I've already mentioned several questions about the product that implicate "science" generally:
- can you mount a camera on the roach? If you can, and it acts naturally afterwards (or even naturally with the caveat that it's stopped fitting into cockroach-sized cracks), you'll pick up extremely valuable footage that a biologist studying cockroaches would love to have.
- Will other cockroaches accept one that's had this kit installed? If not, why not?
- Can I use my RC cockroach to influence the behavior of a swarm? Choose for them where they'll sleep? Dictate what left-out food they choose to eat and what they pass by? Cockroaches are social. Using one to manipulate a colony would be huge.
No, it doesn't. The C64 and other early home computers came with extensive instruction manuals detailing the memory map and all the language instruction. People would enter a program. They'd debug it. They'd modify it. They'd create their own programs.
Compare that to the toy - find bug, attach device, SCIENCE.
It's really shitty marketing.
> I've already mentioned several questions about the product that implicate "science" generally:
If they had any of those in any of the marketing or the instructions they might just be able to scrape by calling this a science toy. They don't. By your definition any toy becomes a science toy. Look! Drop it off a building! That's gravity!
Well, first I'll note that my high school physics class involved labs demonstrating various well-known properties of gravity. I found them a waste of time, but that seems to be a minority opinion.
But let me repeat myself:
"If, at any point, someone using the kit thinks to themselves "what would happen if I did X?" and then does X to see what happens, that is citizen science."
I'm happy to stand by that statement as to any toy. But it's especially likely with a toy like this.
You mention the fear that has caused chemistry sets to be reduced, but that's only part of the problem. The other problem is really bad toys being sold as "science" with nothing sciency about them.