Once you show a normal Windows user where and how to get to the new start menu... they get it, and move on. The bloggers and writers for tech review sites however did not. They might have "got it" but they didn't move on, and MS had to buckle or suffer review after review that complained about the "missing" start button.
Once you get over the newness, Windows 8 is just like 7 but that doesn't make for a very exciting or controversial review.
People hate change. My mom is a prime example - she found Chrome to be unusable because it wasn't 100% exactly the same as IE...
However like always, users get over the change and their uproar and continue to use the product, eventually unaware that it was ever any different.
In Windows 8, there was no button unless you scrolled the mouse to the lower-left of the screen. When you did that, a button that even was labeled "Start" showed up. When you clicked it, you were brought to what people commonly call the "metro" screen.
In Windows 8.1, there is a permanent recognizable button with the picture of a Window on it in the lower-left of the screen. When you click it, you are brought to the "metro" screen.
No functionality difference in the start button. The only people appeased are those that were looking for something to complain about.