Re:Apple hides a Patriot-Act-busting "warrant canary" in its...
by simonh on Wednesday November 06, 2013 @02:56AM
(#6681455)
My understanding of this is that the last thing the NSA wants is to actually have to defend these notices in court, in public. Can you imagine Obama, or any president, having to defend forcing people to flat out lie to the public by retaining "No 215 here" notices when one has been received? That's not going to happen. By best guess is that Apple would be able to challenge being put in that situation by the 215 notice's terms effectively forcing them to self-incriminate.
Also Apple's statement that if they get a 215 they will fight it means they are significantly less likely to be served one. 215s work mainly through fear and doubt and picking on people without the resources to defend themselves.
All this skullduggery is very effective when it's in the shadows or off stage, it's still actually a fairly marginal issue, but the more it gets pushed into the faces of ordinary voting Joes, the worse it gets for the spooks.
Also Apple's statement that if they get a 215 they will fight it means they are significantly less likely to be served one. 215s work mainly through fear and doubt and picking on people without the resources to defend themselves.
All this skullduggery is very effective when it's in the shadows or off stage, it's still actually a fairly marginal issue, but the more it gets pushed into the faces of ordinary voting Joes, the worse it gets for the spooks.