News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple hides a Patriot-Act-busting "warrant canary" in its... by haberman on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @08:14PM (#6679847)
> My not-a-lawyer read on the whole warrant canary thing is that it would never fly in front of a judge. [...] So warrant canaries, while seemingly clever, are actually pretty much worthless.

"Worthless" is a pretty strong statement: do you have anything at all to corroborate your speculation in an area which you admit you have no expertise?

Re:Apple hides a Patriot-Act-busting "warrant canary" in its... by defen on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @09:27PM (#6680147)
> do you have anything at all to corroborate your speculation in an area which you admit you have no expertise?

No. I've talked to lawyers in a non-client capacity and they all agreed that taking down a warrant canary after receiving a NSL would probably be viewed as equivalent to a straightforward disclosure, since you deliberately put yourself in that situation. There is no relevant case law that I am aware of.

Re:Apple hides a Patriot-Act-busting "warrant canary" in its... by jlgreco on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @11:57PM (#6680780)
I can think of a example of canaries working in practice (I am not sure if they were ever challenged, but they weren't successfully challenged at least). Also, the example is from the UK:

In the early part of the 20th century, the Automobile Association (the "AA") would send 'scouts' out to find speedtraps and warn motorists to slow down before arriving at them. Within a few years cops got fed up of not catching speeders, it was decided in the courts that warning people about speedtraps was an obstruction of justice, and therefore illegal.

So that put an end to that game, right? Nope. The AA developed a new technique. Their scouts would salute all passing cars at all times... unless something was wrong.

If the AA scout didn't salute you, you knew there was a speedtrap.

The theory here was that the law could not compel an AA scout to salute motorists. This worked for about 50 years, until the practice of warning motorists of speed traps (or perhaps rather, not signaling to them an absence of speed traps...) was discontinued for road safety reasons (basically they decided that speeding wasn't a brilliant idea).

http://www.theaa.com/aboutaa/history.html

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Automobile_Association#Hist...

So basically, while "Judges don't take kindly to tricks" does make a certain amount of intuitive cynical sense, if we remove computers from the equation (our intuition on morality/ethics seems inconsistent when computers are involved for some reason), does it seem reasonable that a judge might compel a free civilian in a free society to salute? Of course not.

Re:Apple hides a Patriot-Act-busting "warrant canary" in its... by Dylan16807 on Wednesday November 06, 2013 @09:05AM (#6682687)
>The theory here was that the law could not compel an AA scout to salute motorists. This worked for about 50 years, until the practice of warning motorists of speed traps (or perhaps rather, not signaling to them an absence of speed traps...) was discontinued for road safety reasons (basically they decided that speeding wasn't a brilliant idea).

I wonder why they decided that. Speed traps have nothing to do with improving road safety. In fact they often make roads more dangerous if they expect you to slam on the brakes.

Re:Apple hides a Patriot-Act-busting "warrant canary" in its... by jlgreco on Wednesday November 06, 2013 @11:27AM (#6683491)
I'm not really sure, I agree with you though.

For whatever it is worth, it seems they still provide some speed trap related services: http://www.theaa.com/apps/safety-cam-iphone-app.html

Re:Apple hides a Patriot-Act-busting "warrant canary" in its... by goatforce5 on Wednesday November 06, 2013 @09:54AM (#6682942)
They don't expect you to slam on the brakes... They expect you to already be driving at the speed limit.
Re:Apple hides a Patriot-Act-busting "warrant canary" in its... by Dylan16807 on Wednesday November 06, 2013 @10:24AM (#6683126)
Speed traps are generally either set up by having a sudden drop in the speed limit, or by having unreasonably low speed limits. Both of these lead to higher variance in speed and make the road less safe.
Re:Apple hides a Patriot-Act-busting "warrant canary" in its... by arrrg on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @09:46PM (#6680230)
But Apple has nothing to take down, no webpage or PDF document to take offline. This canary would work by not including the current language in the next report, not altering the current one. To me (also not a lawyer) that seems quite different from taking down an existing notice.

It’s not as clear as an explicit sign (in whatever form) being taken down. The interpretation is much more difficult and vague (also to observers like us who would be the target audience for such a canary): Did they just forget to include this language this year or did they actually receive a request? It also requires actively doing something (including the language in the new report) instead of doing nothing (not taking down the sign).

This is very vague as you can see by the many people here doubting that this is a canary at all. If it is indeed one this might afford it legality.

Re:Apple hides a Patriot-Act-busting "warrant canary" in its... by amirmc on Wednesday November 06, 2013 @04:03AM (#6681692)
> "...since you deliberately put yourself in that situation."

This is the crux of the problem. If we assume Apple is being truthful in its statement, they should be completely free to make such statements. No-one should be punished retrospectively for statements that were true at the time of utterance.

Compelling someone to lie after the facts have changed seems to me a far murkier legal area (and perhaps easier to fight in court).

Re:Apple hides a Patriot-Act-busting "warrant canary" in its... by comrade_ogilvy on Wednesday November 06, 2013 @07:53PM (#6686738)
>Compelling someone to lie after the facts have changed seems to me a far murkier legal area (and perhaps easier to fight in court).

And IIRC C-level executives are required to certify they believe their quarterly reports are, to the best of their knowledge, accurate, under Sarbanes-Oxley. There is a ticking clock here, once Apple asserts that the nebulous statement is relevant to the value of the company, because some customers are tetchy about their data.

Re:Apple hides a Patriot-Act-busting "warrant canary" in its... by CapitalistCartr on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @08:46PM (#6679993)
While he has no expertise, neither does anyone else. NSLs are a Brave New World.
Re:Apple hides a Patriot-Act-busting "warrant canary" in its... by haberman on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @09:09PM (#6680061)
That's exactly why it seems a bit premature to preemptively dismiss them as "worthless." There's a pretty interesting question here (IMO) of whether the court can compel a false statement, or whether they can exercise prior restraint on companies saying they haven't received a warrant.
Re:Apple hides a Patriot-Act-busting "warrant canary" in its... by jasallen on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @09:28PM (#6680149)
All the same defen admitted it was speculation and that he's not a lawyer, so, it's opinion. Perhaps his opinion is "worthless" too, but since he gave you his (lack of) credentials you can judge for yourself.

I get so tired of the "you need to quote sources" in simple commentary.

Re:Apple hides a Patriot-Act-busting "warrant canary" in its... by haberman on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @10:17PM (#6680386)
The latter part of what I quoted wasn't phrased as speculation, which was what irked me. But the fact that OP has heard this opinion expressed by lawyers certainly makes the comment more interesting.
Re:Apple hides a Patriot-Act-busting "warrant canary" in its... by Spooky23 on Wednesday November 06, 2013 @09:21AM (#6682760)
There's another, more practical question. Does the canary-wielding party have the resources to fight the matter to conclusion.

If there's no known caselaw, you're going to have to litigate with the US government over this issue. That's an uphill battle that is exhausting, outrageously expensive and fraught with risks to both the company and the principals.

And guess what? Lets say you win this epic battle after spending lots of money and many months of your time. Everything that you've done was done in a secret court and will be unknown to the world. Your attorneys get a big check, and you get a pyrrhic victory that you cannot tell anyone about.

Re:Apple hides a Patriot-Act-busting "warrant canary" in its... by gabrielrotbart on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @09:43PM (#6680218)
Very clever.

To respond to above. An approach would be to conduct an ROI analysis for Apple to lie.

For example: Goodwill for seeming to 'fight for the little guy' vs. cost of exposure.

Re:Apple hides a Patriot-Act-busting "warrant canary" in its... by javert on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @09:02PM (#6680042)
" In other words, anyone with two brain cells can see that, if there has in fact been a 215 order by the time the next report rolls around, then deliberately removing the warrant canary language is tantamount to revealing the order's existence, which is illegal."
Re:Apple hides a Patriot-Act-busting "warrant canary" in its... by masklinn on Wednesday November 06, 2013 @07:32AM (#6682329)
Assume each report is created from scratch, not adding the canary language is different from removing them.
Re:Apple hides a Patriot-Act-busting "warrant canary" in its... by spiritplumber on Wednesday November 06, 2013 @02:08AM (#6681279)
I'm pretty sure that a government can compel you to be silent, but not to outright lie.
Re:Apple hides a Patriot-Act-busting "warrant canary" in its... by Intermernet on Wednesday November 06, 2013 @02:47AM (#6681423)
“I responded in what I thought was the most truthful, or least untruthful manner, by saying no,”
Re:Apple hides a Patriot-Act-busting "warrant canary" in its... by emn13 on Wednesday November 06, 2013 @11:26AM (#6683484)
But how much of that was due to the speaker, and how much actually coerced?
Re:Apple hides a Patriot-Act-busting "warrant canary" in its... by jeremyjh on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @09:19PM (#6680106)
Confirmed.

Source: I have two brain cells.