News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:MacKenzie Bezos Writes Amazon Review for Jeff Bezos Biogr... by rmk2 on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @11:44AM (#6676068)
Something bothers me about the conclusion of the review...

"In this theory I treat the historical work as what it most manifestly is: a verbal structure in the form of a narrative prose discourse. Histories (and philosophies of history as well) combine a certain amount of 'data,' theoretical concepts for 'explaining' these data, and a narrative structure for their presentation as an icon of sets of events presumed to have occurred in times past. In addition, I maintain, they contain a deep structural content which is generally poetic, and specifically linguistic, in nature, and which serves as the precritically accepted paradigm of what a distinctively 'historical' explanation should be." (Hayden White, Metahistory, p. IX)

What MacKenzie Bezos points out, albeit in a localised fashion, is what the Humanities have come to regard as the "linguistic turn" during the course of the 20th century. As Hayden White states above (in his concern with historical writing), historical writing takes a certain set of data that is then fitted into a wider narrative, alongside some underlying meta-narrative, which marks a certain interpretive paradigm (e.g. a progress-narrative). This, in turn, means that no account can desribe "historical truth". It also means that every account is fundamentally literary (or, as he formulates it, at least linguistic). It is no surprise, then, that the Bezos biography does not describe "historical fact". However, it also means that a biography written by Bezos's wive or even his autobiography cannot describe "historical truth" either. Every account remains a narrative, and thus fictional, even if based "on real events", as Hollywood so neatly calls it.

Hayden White continues: The chosen (or, in this case, criticised) writers' "status as possible models of historical representation or conceptualization does not depend upon the nature of the 'data' they used to support their generalizations or the theories they invoked to explain them; it depends rather upon the consistency, coherence, and illuminative power of their respective visions of the historical field." (Hayden White, Metahistory, p. 4)

So her final claim is dubious, at best: "Ideally, authors are careful to ensure people know whether what they are reading is history or an entertaining fictionalization. Hollywood often uses a more honest label: 'a story based on true events.' If authors won’t admit they’ve crossed this important line, their characters can do it for them."

While the "character" may certainly give you their version of the story, what they present is far from being "historical truth". They also choose examples, omit others, pick and make decisions, depending on their very own narrative. This is less a clash of "fiction" versus "historical truth", but instead a clash of two narratives. The character's narrative (in this case, Bezos's) might carry more authority (he is the character in question, after all), but the account remains nevertheless a narrative, which can also be criticised.

This is the same reflex as can be observed sometimes with old guest listeners at universities who torpedo (especially) historical lectures with a simple claim: "But I was there in 19xx, and I didn't know about or notice any of that." And while that might be a true data point, it doesn't mean that it somehow invalidates the wider narrative.

Edit: The author can thus certainly criticise the overall narrative or narrative thrust in the biography, but pointing out singular data points that simply oppose a given data point do not serve the same function.

Re:MacKenzie Bezos Writes Amazon Review for Jeff Bezos Biogr... by unclesaamm on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @08:54PM (#6680016)
This is a bunch of pretentious hock. The linguistic turn has nothing to do with this. In fact, I hate how you bring up an external source and quote extensively from it as if it proves anything. Okay, armchair liberal arts student, here's the smack:

When you purport to be writing a factual account, there are certain standards that you can be held accountable to.

Take, for instance, "A Million Little Pieces". It was a memoir written by James Frey in 2003 that absolutely imploded when people found out that he made up large chunks of the material (wikipedia now lists it as "semi-fictional"). There's a difference between the two categories, and the difference is in exactly the type of anecdotal evidence that you don't think is important.

Edited to add: I agree that maybe the overall narrative of the book--the feeling and reportage of Amazon's culture--may still be accurate. I'd like to see more examples of inaccuracies before drawing any conclusions. It's also important to bear in mind just how much of a vested interest MacKenzie Bezos has in debunking this, because presumably the book makes Jeff Bezos and Amazon look bad (haven't read it yet though).

Re:MacKenzie Bezos Writes Amazon Review for Jeff Bezos Biogr... by rmk2 on Wednesday November 06, 2013 @08:08AM (#6682472)
Ad hominem aisde, your edit seems to actively counter your other point.

My whole point is that both sites spin a narrative a certain way because they both would like history to look a certain way. The reason why I "extensively quote" an external source is to show that there are other elements involved in the perception of truth than just the given data points.

There is nothing fundamentally wrong with pointing out inaccurate data. However, there seems to be a general propensity to then discount a whole narrative in favour of the seemingly corrected narrative of the person doing the corrections. The whole point of bringing up the underlying bias of any historical account, however, is to just keep in mind that all correction is capable of doing is to erect another narrative. Which one you find more convincing is entirely yours to decide. I merely (or, perhaps, "merely") contest that what happens in the review is an opposition of (semi-)fiction on one hand and "historical truth" on the other.

Re:MacKenzie Bezos Writes Amazon Review for Jeff Bezos Biogr... by jdlshore on Wednesday November 06, 2013 @12:39PM (#6683954)
There was no ad hominem here, just insults. You've fallen into the "ad hominem fallacy fallacy." :-) http://plover.net/~bonds/adhominem.html
Re:MacKenzie Bezos Writes Amazon Review for Jeff Bezos Biogr... by rmk2 on Wednesday November 06, 2013 @01:57PM (#6684617)
Mhm, indeed! The more you know! :)
Re:MacKenzie Bezos Writes Amazon Review for Jeff Bezos Biogr... by RockyMcNuts on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @01:17PM (#6676847)
Well, either the Remains of the Day anecdote is true or false... it's one thing to pick and choose the facts you think are important in the context of the narrative you think is important, another if the facts are incorrect, which is what Mrs. Bezos is alleging.
Re:MacKenzie Bezos Writes Amazon Review for Jeff Bezos Biogr... by rmk2 on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @05:55PM (#6679092)
Certainly, a given anecdote might be right or wrong. The thing that seems to follow here, however, is an implied claim that because of the falsity of a given (singular?) data point, somehow the overall narrative becomes unsustainable. However, this means that the claimed truthfulness of the counterpoint is used to support a completely opposing narrative without any further backing. This is, in a round-about way, an appeal to authority that then seemingly provides a complete alternative to a given narrative, seemingly without the need to substantiate the wider claims in their entirety.
Re:MacKenzie Bezos Writes Amazon Review for Jeff Bezos Biogr... by middus on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @06:18PM (#6679214)
The falsity of a given (prominent!) data point just puts the care and diligence of the author into question and plants doubt in the reader's mind. It doesn't imply the validity of an opposing narrative.
Re:MacKenzie Bezos Writes Amazon Review for Jeff Bezos Biogr... by RockyMcNuts on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @06:47PM (#6679393)
Not the way I read it. She said there were a lot of errors, and gave one example.

No one who was there is necessarily reliable. Absent a time machine, no narrative is going to be right on all facts.

Perhaps the critic is is self-serving. But perhaps if the author gave competing versions instead of using the device of an nonexistent omniscient narrator, that would be more defensible.

Maybe, as you say, all narratives are fictional, but some are more fictional than others. Serious historians and journalists don't go out of their way to make the narrative more dramatic at the expense of accuracy.

Re:MacKenzie Bezos Writes Amazon Review for Jeff Bezos Biogr... by josefresco on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @02:50PM (#6677691)
Interestingly, one of the "characters" did come forward, with their own "historical truth" review (4/5 stars) that doesn't exactly fall in line with MacKenzie's conclusions:

http://www.amazon.com/review/R3J863C5ZP53BA/ref=cm_cr_dp_tit...

Re:MacKenzie Bezos Writes Amazon Review for Jeff Bezos Biogr... by judk on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @10:41PM (#6680484)
Interestingly, he agrees with Mackenzie's allegations about inaccuracy, but he is far more forgiving about them.
Re:MacKenzie Bezos Writes Amazon Review for Jeff Bezos Biogr... by dmix on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @01:01PM (#6676703)
Interesting, I hadn't heard of Hayden White before:

> He has argued that historical writing mirrors literary writing in many ways, sharing the strong reliance on narrative for meaning, therefore ruling out the possibility for objective or truly scientific history. White has also argued, however, that history is most successful when it embraces this "narrativity", since it is what allows history to be meaningful.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hayden_White

This is relevant considering most non-fiction writing today is influence by "new journalism" and adopts a fiction/literary form. Often using a narrative structure similar to screenwriting (beginning/middle/end) which is antithetical to scientific history.

Re:MacKenzie Bezos Writes Amazon Review for Jeff Bezos Biogr... by thwest on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @01:29PM (#6676982)
If a screenwriterly narrative is moving away from scientific history, how could we move closer? Simply publish historical data in table form? It seems like as soon as you employ verbs that imply causality you are subject to White's analysis here.
Re:MacKenzie Bezos Writes Amazon Review for Jeff Bezos Biogr... by rmk2 on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @05:52PM (#6679069)
Self-reflexion. White's point is that these narratives and meta-narratives exist and are simply something we do. The way to go forward from there is to incorporate that into one's own writing by reflecting the implicit (or implied) biases, narratives and meta-structures. I think this is the case with many of thinkers like him, from Derrida over Foucault to White, that their theories are nothing that can be in any way "applied" to make something better. Instead, what they introduce is a moment of self-reflexion, where we do not just criticise somebody else for their (implicit or explicit) reliance on hierarchies or "external" truths, but instead also question our own influences, connotations and motivations.
Re:MacKenzie Bezos Writes Amazon Review for Jeff Bezos Biogr... by thwest on Wednesday November 06, 2013 @10:55PM (#6687404)
I really like this post, and I feel like the only incorrect response is to respond. (although 2nd thought is that Derrida's project is to show us that none of the recursive attempts to account for this phenomenon ("employing narrative") prevent it)
Re:MacKenzie Bezos Writes Amazon Review for Jeff Bezos Biogr... by Nimi on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @05:46PM (#6679028)
One can include the narratives of the key figures depicted. One recent Israeli movie, The Gatekeepers, did so (for leaders of Israel's security service), and the differences in opinions remained unsettled at the end of the film.
Re:MacKenzie Bezos Writes Amazon Review for Jeff Bezos Biogr... by Megatronic on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @11:04PM (#6680610)
Hayden White would distinguish between a hollywood narrative in which a false(r) history is deliberately created for entertainment or sensatinalism, and an attempt at an accurate account, regardless of how biased it is. There's a difference between intentionally crafting a narrative and expressing one you have formed through your experiences. Bezos is suggesting the former, which is quite different than what White was talking about. Not that that proves anything, but you're dismissing what she's saying completely by misapplying a theory.
Re:MacKenzie Bezos Writes Amazon Review for Jeff Bezos Biogr... by rmk2 on Wednesday November 06, 2013 @08:18AM (#6682504)
The differentiation between a "hollywood narrative" and the "attempt at an accurate account", however, brings us a new set of problems: Who gets to decide which is which? Do we have to rely on authorial intention? Do we rely on reception?

Either way doesn't allow us to qualify what kind of effort we have at hand without grounding said qualification on our own biases. If we believe that the account is fundamentally flawed, we are free to assume that a hollywood narrative has been deliberately crafted to misrepresent "historical truth" (which would be the Bezos side). If we believe that the account is fundamentally correct, regardless of bias and some factual flaws, then we have to assume that the intent behind it was to give an accurate account of history.

My whole point is that neither authorial intention nor pure reception can offer us a definitive assessment of a given accounts "truthfulness" or overall expressed content. Consequently, this lets me regard both sides as biased. Both have an agenda, and both represent things a certain way, thus necessarily misrepresenting others in the process. Who I think is more believable in their account is then a question of my own choice, depending on my own inclinations, biases and presuppositions.

P.S.: I do not regard any of the quoted bits as a theory that is to be applied. Instead, they introduce two distinct elements: reflexion and self-reflexion. Theory thus introduces a mode of thought, not a structural base for analysis. White's own categories are certainly structural (and structuralist) and to be applied, but they are crafted for his own analysis of the history of historiography (and therefore notably absentin my quotations. They, however, are not the transferable meaning that is valid in for more contexts than just his intended analyses.

Re:MacKenzie Bezos Writes Amazon Review for Jeff Bezos Biogr... by barretts on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @12:35PM (#6676467)
Well (if verbosely) said.
Re:MacKenzie Bezos Writes Amazon Review for Jeff Bezos Biogr... by bksenior on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @09:29PM (#6680156)
"There are three sides to every story: Your side, my side, and the truth. And no one is lying. Memories shared serve each differently."

- Robert Evans