Re:South Korea is stuck with Internet Explorer for online sh...
by uiri on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @12:20PM
(#6676343)
If you actually look at the history of Standard Oil (including the exposé by Ida Tarbell which arguably depicts the strongest case for the existence of a monopoly), you will notice that Standard Oil's market share was already on the decline by the time that the US Supreme Court ruled that Standard Oil had to be broken up. The break up wasn't even very effective in Standard Oil's case; the modern ExxonMobil is the result of mergers of some of the largest of the daughter companies.
(All of these are well known, well documented examples a little over a century old. For a more modern alternative, consider the many people who have a single provider for internet access – they can either pay or give up on significant participation in the modern economy.)
> Also, a private-sector monopoly, no matter how seemingly entrenched, is always vulnerable to disruption (when was the last time you used a PC manufactured by IBM? Or were forced to use IE against your will, for that matter?
Amusingly, both of your examples are cases where the monopoly was disrupted under the treat of government action. The reason those other browsers had a chance is that Microsoft couldn't lock down the PC market as much as they wanted to while the DOJ was investigating. Similarly, look at IBM's history – do you think the PC market would be as open if they hadn't had to worry about a replay of the 1969 antitrust settlement?