(All of these are well known, well documented examples a little over a century old. For a more modern alternative, consider the many people who have a single provider for internet access – they can either pay or give up on significant participation in the modern economy.)
> Also, a private-sector monopoly, no matter how seemingly entrenched, is always vulnerable to disruption (when was the last time you used a PC manufactured by IBM? Or were forced to use IE against your will, for that matter?
Amusingly, both of your examples are cases where the monopoly was disrupted under the treat of government action. The reason those other browsers had a chance is that Microsoft couldn't lock down the PC market as much as they wanted to while the DOJ was investigating. Similarly, look at IBM's history – do you think the PC market would be as open if they hadn't had to worry about a replay of the 1969 antitrust settlement?
That can be pretty bad if the "good" you are going without is food, shelter, a necessary medical procedure, or some other fundamental requirement.
I suspect we need a new term for what we want. "Capitalism" is too sullied by use.
No nation is pure, of course. But we can look at examples of crony policies within otherwise capitalist-ish nations and compare to less crony-ish policies within those same nations.
It all gets a bit muddy real quick, but I guess we have to do the best with what we've got.
First, there is a great deal of overlap among the leadership of government, the military, education, and business. As in, the same dude is CEO of a large company and a Colonel in the army and last year he was minister for something-or-another. When he gets tired of this company he'll teach at NUS for a bit. If you're on track to slide into that top echelon when you're still in your twenties, you're golden, otherwise your prospects are more limited.
To a seemingly greater extent than is true even in USA, the government is involved in everything. Fortunately, the bureaucrats seem to make generally good decisions, but they're still making decisions. The genuinely competitive industries are export-focused, which I guess is OK for a small nation for which exports are so important.
Everyone has heard about the fairly severe punishments Singapore has for various crimes, but perhaps not how much enforcement varies based on the identity of the criminal. Even before you get to the punishment stage, law enforcement and related surveillance pervades society, and affects different classes of people in wildly different ways. This isn't an economic effect per se, but the choices people make as a reaction to this have economic consequences. Also, I can't get over the fact that for 34 of its 48 years, Singapore's PM has been LKY or his son.
You don't know Singapore or HK very well. They are very good at being a transparent government, but guanxi is still needed to get things done.
Also, a private-sector monopoly, no matter how seemingly entrenched, is always vulnerable to disruption (when was the last time you used a PC manufactured by IBM? Or were forced to use IE against your will, for that matter? And yet those were both at one time monopolies that came very close to being broken up by the justice department because people claimed the free market could never topple them). That's why that "distopian future scenario" the OP referenced didn't come about in most of the world. Other browsers came about that users liked better and despite the big advantage IE gets from being bundled with most PCs others have had success in the market. Contrast that with the difficulty in breaking a government-enforced monopoly like the one referenced in the article.