News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Avoiding Heart Disease by tansey on Monday November 04, 2013 @06:41PM (#6672002)
I tend to think of doctors as mechanics. Often when something breaks on my car, the explanation is "it's an old car, that happens eventually." And when they talk about it after fixing it, it's usually "Toyota's a good brand. Take care of it and you'll get another 100k miles from that engine." If I took my car to my mechanic with nothing wrong and asked what I should be doing to make sure the transmission lasts as long as possible, they will give me some generic intuitive advice, but they have no real insight because they are not in the business of maximizing the lifetime of healthy cars.

Doctors are kind of the same way. They see patients who have problems and need them fixed. If you walk into a doctor's office and say your family has a history of heart disease and you're concerned, they'll run a standard diagnostic to see if there is a problem. If there isn't, they'll give you generic advice. Outside of that, they are not really likely to have much insight into how to prevent heart disease in your specific case. Maybe you'll get lucky and the doctor will have recently read a relevant paper.

This seems to me like a problem that you're better off having answered by a medical researcher rather than a physician in the trenches. Researchers are the ones who are taking the long view on outcomes in patients. Keeping with the same analogy, you're probably better off talking to a mechanical engineer at a car company about maximizing the life of your currently healthy transmission.

Also, I generally see this as a problem that will be best addressed by machine learning researchers collaborating with medical researchers. Then again, I'm an ML PhD student working on health applications, so I'm biased. :)

Re:Avoiding Heart Disease by crusso on Monday November 04, 2013 @07:35PM (#6672257)
Even the front side of your analogy is broken. Mechanics are great sources of information on how to drive so you can maximize the life of your engine. It's like you haven't had a conversation with a mechanic before.

Likewise with doctors. I have had 4 doctors in my family (3 still alive), and I've spent many the family meal talking with them about health, longevity, and the mechanical/biology/chemistry behind how your body works and when it works best.

Re:Avoiding Heart Disease by reedlaw on Monday November 04, 2013 @09:04PM (#6672724)
Your interactions with mechanics and doctors imply a closer relationship than perhaps that of the OP. My typical experience with is closer to the OP's--that is they have a lot of vehicles/patients to see and don't go in to too much detail on each visit.
Re:Avoiding Heart Disease by sliverstorm on Monday November 04, 2013 @09:26PM (#6672809)
Many of them don't go into detail because 99% of customers don't give the slightest fuck. Show genuine interest, strike up conversation, and you can sometimes get a lot out of them.

In any case, service life in cars is usually determined by a couple key things: The design of the system, driving conditions, and service. You may feel like you're being blown off when the mechanic says "obey the service intervals and avoid short trips", but that's 99.9% of what you can do to make the car last.

(Special corner cases are widely-understood and well-documented, such as the impact of very high operating temperatures in automatic transmissions during towing)

Re:Avoiding Heart Disease by jimgardener on Monday November 04, 2013 @10:26PM (#6673039)
my mom(who was a primary school teacher) had been a diabetic for about 10 years.The doctors who treated her told her to eat more wheat based meals instead of rice based ones and told her to increase the dosage of tablets when sugar level crossed 200 .No doctor ever told her about carb counting which IMO, was the first thing she should have been told.I came upon carb counting from some articles on the internet.She is trying this for the last couple of years and now her ppbs is 107.
Re:Avoiding Heart Disease by montecarl on Monday November 04, 2013 @11:24PM (#6673218)
It seems that reducing dietary carbohydrates should be the primary treatment of most diabetics. Eating too many carbohydrates seems to be the cause for most people.

The conversation with the doctor/nurse should go something like:

You have diabetes. Your body has become insulin resistant because you ate too much sugary/starchy stuff. Eat less of it and you will get better.

Re:Avoiding Heart Disease by danpat on Monday November 04, 2013 @06:52PM (#6672050)
Small backstory and a question for you.

My fiancée is a psychiatric nurse practitioner. Recently, we were having dinner with a few of her colleagues, and they were complaining about the overwhelming number of new medications coming to market, and how they could never remember all the interactions, what to use for what, which ones were new, which had been retired, etc, etc.

As a CS person, I piped up and suggested, tongue in cheek, that the computers were going to take their jobs. This led to a healthy discussion about the human practitioners role in a time when the amount of information they're expected to know is rapidly expanding.

What's your take in the future role of the human in diagnosing and prescribing in a situation like this?

Re:Avoiding Heart Disease by tzm on Monday November 04, 2013 @07:29PM (#6672220)
Technically, it's inevitable. Information will be more actionable. http://www-03.ibm.com/innovation/us/watson/watson_in_healthc...

Practically, I think the role of humans will be to create a more human experience and to provide specialized knowledge centers.

Re:Avoiding Heart Disease by mhurron on Monday November 04, 2013 @07:24PM (#6672201)
Doctors offices already have something similar, at least for interactions.
Re:Avoiding Heart Disease by girvo on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @08:51PM (#6680011)
So does my pharmacy, interestingly enough.
Re:Avoiding Heart Disease by claudiusd on Monday November 04, 2013 @07:09PM (#6672124)
I love your analogy, but I think you drew the wrong conclusion. Doctors don't have an incentive to prevent you from getting sicker any more than your mechanic has an incentive for keeping your car out of the shop. Why would your doctor read the latest research on preventing disease when he can make a tidy profit from treating your disease?

Now this isn't to say that doctors are bad people who want to make you sick... on the contrary, most of the doctors I know are more passionate about helping people than making money. They are, however, subject to whims of the hospital they work for, which I can almost guarantee is more interested in making a buck than keeping you healthy. This is true of all large companies though, and as Clayton Christensen has taught us, this sort of marginal thinking usually leads to disruptive innovation by a start-up.

<shameless_plug> Want to disrupt health care? Omada Health is hiring! http://omadahealth.com/jobs </shameless_plug>

Re:Avoiding Heart Disease by noonespecial on Monday November 04, 2013 @07:34PM (#6672253)
I once mentioned that to a family friend who was a doctor. He said that if he wanted to make money off of people's suffering, he'd have become a lawyer. Its way easier.
Re:Avoiding Heart Disease by memset on Monday November 04, 2013 @08:03PM (#6672413)
Do realize that doctors are required to do continuing medical education (CME [1]) to maintain their license? Not to say that the system is perfect, but it is false that doctors do not do some sort of continued study in their field (mandated or not.)

Doctors most certainly have an incentive to keep their patients from getting sicker. One of the ways we evaluate quality of care is incidence of morbidity. How often does this patient continue to return to the hospital? This is a huge risk to physicians, in the form of a lawsuit.

It isn't like there is any shortage of patients who require care. There are so many ways that hospitals encourage doctors to do bad things to make a buck, but preventing preventative care would not be the first thing I'd target.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Continuing_medical_education

Re:Avoiding Heart Disease by patmcc on Monday November 04, 2013 @07:46PM (#6672315)
I think another big problem is the generic advice (eat better, exercise more, don't smoke, etc.) is incredibly effective, but doctors routinely see huge numbers of their patients not doing it at all, so why would they bother researching for more specialized advice?
Re:Avoiding Heart Disease by bdesimone on Monday November 04, 2013 @07:24PM (#6672199)
> Why would your doctor read the latest research on preventing disease when he can make a tidy profit from treating your disease?

Woah woah woah there. Are you really saying doctors don't read the latest research so that they can make a greater profit? Really?

You could have at least picked a more realistic example of misaligned incentives in medicine... e.g. using a more expensive drill bit during a surgery because you know that the surgical rep will take you out to a nice dinner every time he's in town.

There's a huge population of doctors. Some ethical. Some unethical. But I believe the profession does a pretty admirable job of stamping out immoral behavior when it finds it.

Re:Avoiding Heart Disease by graeme on Monday November 04, 2013 @07:33PM (#6672232)
The OP phrased it badly, but the point is sound. Suppose a doctor has a choice of two activities:

1. Read research, unpaid 2. Treat patient, paid

The doctor clearly has an incentive to focus on treating disease. They do read research, but they would surely read even more if they were paid directly to do so.

There's nothing nefarious in this, it happens in any industry. We do more of the things we're paid to do, and less of the things we're not.

Re:Avoiding Heart Disease by bdesimone on Monday November 04, 2013 @08:13PM (#6672475)
It's sound if you assume both aren't part of the job description. Change the occupation in the poorly constructed analogy and we have...

Suppose a pilot has a choice of two activities:

1. Read FAA safety report, unpaid 2. Fly plane, paid

Doctors, especially at academic institutions, are required not only to be up to date in the latest research, but contribute to it. If a doctor treats a patient in a way not up to par with current practices in research, he will be sued and lose his licensure.

Re:Avoiding Heart Disease by anactualmd on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @04:27PM (#6678457)
See mention of CME upthread. The choice is really:

1. Attend CME meeting, often at nice resort locale, usually unpaid, but deductible. Acquire at least 25 hours of such attendance per year.

2. Lose medical license. Pump gas, if you can find a full-service station.

Re:Avoiding Heart Disease by rosser on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @02:44AM (#6673759)
Holy false dilemma.
Re:Avoiding Heart Disease by caycep on Monday November 04, 2013 @08:05PM (#6672424)
The education tries to ingrain "do no harm" but then again, human nature is human nature.

The folks who go into primary care - i.e. GP's, pediatricians, etc, tend to be more altruistic, and think along the lines of preventative medicine. (They certainly aren't in it for the money...). It's really the subspecialties you hear about some random doc who is pushing tests or surgeries somewhere.

There is a push behind the new "Accountable Care Model" that tries to incentivize better performance on overall health metrics that tries to address this, but too soon to tell how well it works.

Re:Avoiding Heart Disease by pantalaimon on Monday November 04, 2013 @07:38PM (#6672277)
I don't think there will be a shortage of sick people anytime soon.

Also, the problem is that such papers don't exist, or at least not in the accuracy or certainty you'd like to have.

It's much easier to gather data from sick people and which treatments worked for them, than gathering decades worth of data from healthy people and correlate causes to which diseases they eventually may have developed.

Re:Avoiding Heart Disease by bambax on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @02:10AM (#6673649)
Agreed. In my experience doctors are fixated on symptoms and seem to be saying "if you have no symtoms you're wasting my time". I would say they're right. There are enough sick people to keep them busy, why would they spend time with healthy people?

If you're healthy (as in, no symptoms) then managing your lifestyle should be your business, not your doctor's, and most advice is obvious anyway (don't eat or drink too much, avoid processed food and all manners of sodas whenever possible, sleep well, exercise).

Regarding lifestyle choices, I also think doctors have seen many people getting sick that seemed to be doing everything right, they're not sure what's best. It's very possible stress is a main contributor to poor health, and just worrying too much about it is bad in itself.

Re:Avoiding Heart Disease by pcrh on Monday November 04, 2013 @08:47PM (#6672656)
The issue is that you're an individual, whereas the "standard of care" that your doctor is duty-bound to provide is based on population studies. Your doctor may be able to adapt this care to your specific case if you have obvious specific secondary conditions.

Ideally, your doctor would be able to tailor your care to your genetics, your lifestyle as well as to your medical history. That is the goal of "personalized medicine". This will likely become more and more common-place over the next decade or two, in particular with respect to the genetic aspect. But for now it remains too expensive and uncertain to be rolled-out by HMOs and national healthcare systems. So you end up with "generic" advice, which is in fact in most cases the best they can do.

Re:Avoiding Heart Disease by caycep on Monday November 04, 2013 @08:02PM (#6672405)
The big professional associates generally put out a set of consensus guidelines that are aimed at giving "physicians in the trenches" a (relatively) easy interface as to "best practices" in terms of preventative medicine and risk reduction.

That being said, this is a matter of separating the noise from the signal in the population which is quite hard. AFAIK, and I am probably missing a few, but the only real long term modifiers are aspirin, low blood pressure, and high fiber/low cholesterol/low glycemic index foods. Everything else - there isn't enough data to separate noise from signal except for a few specific cases (someone found a gene polymorphism or mutation to something specific, i.e. the risk of blue converse sneakers or something like that)

Re:Avoiding Heart Disease by JoshTriplett on Monday November 04, 2013 @08:16PM (#6672489)
To some extent that's unavoidable past a certain point. Your doctor can give you lots of advice on living past 40 or 60. If you want to live past 90-100, there are far too few examples to go by, and you start seeing the kind of "what worked for me" random advice that you see from the ones who managed it. And if you want to live past ~120, you'll hit some of the species-wide hard limits we don't know how to solve yet. At that point the answer for most doctors really is "that happens", unless you're one of the folks trying to solve the fundamental problems of longevity, which past that point have very little overlap with the problems doctors solve on a regular basis.