My chief concern is that progressives will ask us to explain how we contend with people who despite being given a stack of currency still manage to squander that, leaving themselves hungry, without shelter, or without savings. They may not say that now, but I think that challenge would eventually arrive. I personally favor family and charity as a last safety net, but progressives routinely dismiss those as impractical or insufficient.
My pessimistic side believes that a portion of the progressive inclination for central planning comes from a fear of allowing people to act stupidly and suffer the consequences. In other words, it's not necessarily that they want to manage the allocation of funds and/or delivery of services and products to the poor, but that they believe if they don't do this, bad decisions will be made, leading to suffering. Meanwhile libertarians such as myself routinely are naively optimistic, believing everyone will make decent or good choices in spending their basic income (knowing to put some into healthcare, some into savings, and so on).
It's complex.
See the UK, where we have complicated benefits and medical care and social housing.
If you drink your money, and cause yourself to become homeless, you'll have no money and have nowhere to live.
I think understanding how people get themselves into that kind of situation, and guiding them into better choices, is useful to society as a whole. That small investment avoids costs later.
Pay every weekday morning - it fixes the food part
Shelter is tough because we are not trying new things anymore. You rent an apartment or rent / buy a home. We don't have many cheaper shelters like capsule hotels[1] or maybe some modular-type apartments. Innovation in shelters is not a thing and seriously hampered by existing laws.
> I personally favor family and charity as a last safety net, but progressives routinely dismiss those as impractical or insufficient.
It was the way of things in the early days, but we really need to stop making it difficult for third-partys to actually provide these services.
1) yes, this is not long term or family friendly, but I've live in worse than what I saw in videos of these things.
We got it in our heads that you must buy a home and our definition of home is fixed. In my wilder moments, I wonder what would happen if a standard "module" size and connection (structural support, door location, water, electric, etc) for apartments happened and you could plug the modules into buildings. I'm sure there are 1,000s of other ideas.
1) small fact, those programs won't loan money to Native Americans on reservations since they cannot take the land anymore. Not sure that's actually a bad thing, but it is odd.
Historically, the inclination came from out of work low-level aristocrats looking for "jobs". Welfare for the poor has always been (disguised) welfare for the rich. This sociologic explanation was highlighted by Nietzche in the 19thC, referred to it as "Master ans Slave" morality.
A basic income should be a security net to catch all, who failed to earn enough for living, but not to much to avoid that everybody stops working and starts party.
One problem of a basic income is the iron law of wages and the private property on housing. Wages tend to balance to a point that they are barely enough to make ends needs. When wages climb, also housing costs and rental prices climb.
So a basic income must accompanied with a big social housing program to allow cheap housing for everybody. Else a basic income would only make the 0.1% who have large assets even richer, because they would earn most of this basic income by renting out housing.
I think that's much less true with this kind of a system than in the situations we more frequently see, because this is not localized. When wages climb in, say, SF then people move to SF and drive up the price. When wages climb whether they're in SF or Troy, MI you don't see the same dynamic. You might even see housing prices fall if people decide it's easier to make a better life for themselves elsewhere, when their presence is pulling resources to regions with a low cost of living.
As a side-effect, we will also guarantee that consumption levels won't easily fall below certain level.
That's a nice goal, but its probably not practical on basic income given current technology and means of production; the more automation advances, the more basic income can be (and, arguably, the more it needs to be) but if you aim to high you end up driving down production and driving up prices uncontrollably.
Namely, the permanently and severely disabled. These are the people who will have the highest cost of living because they will need additional care and special considerations made for housing etc.
They are also the people who will find it the most difficult to supplement their minimum income by working.
True as far as it goes. Collecting taxes and then turning around and giving the money back might be a good first step, but it should be obvious that it would be more efficient not to collect the taxes in the first place.
Some may object and say that giving money to the poor changes the social makeup of society by redistributing wealth from haves to have-nots. But that doesn't change anything, because the money given to the poor quickly finds its way to the same places it does now.
Once you get to the point that transfer payments are not going to go away, it seems like optimizing the cost and efficiency of said payments while reducing the cost (thus taxes) and size of government become priorities. This is basically one way to remove quite a lot of the government.
I'm still not sure about a fixed payment however. I guess I can see a minimum pro-rated[1] guaranteed income payed on a very tight schedule (weekly, but preferably every weekday morning). I can see it would take more paperwork, but I think the difference in payment versus admin costs probably would make it a better pick.
I get the feeling that a country with the constitution that says voting rights are dependent on not taking transfer payments might have a better chance of acceptance. It is a bit of a radical idea.
1) something like for every 2 dollars earned you subtract a dollar of payment
The latter, which is what is suggested here, involves giving everyone the same amount of money on top of whatever they earn or don't earn.
For the former, the government pays the difference between whatever you're actually making and the minimum amount (if positive).
With BI there is still incentive to work at low paying jobs - you always keep more as you earn more. With GMI you are basically volunteering until there's a job that pays more than the minimum - it's effectively a different way of implementing a minimum wage.
Yes, that why I said I was in favor of it (Guaranteed Minimum Income - well actually a pro-rated GMI) for much the same reason sologoub was in favor of the Basic Income from the article.
> With BI there is still incentive to work at low paying jobs - you always keep more as you earn more. With GMI you are basically volunteering until there's a job that pays more than the minimum - it's effectively a different way of implementing a minimum wage.
That is why I am in favor of a pro-rated version so that there is an incentive to work and people are softly leaving government payments.
Social security isn't means-tested, its contribution-based (the only way that it even approximates being means-tested is that SS income is subject to income tax if your total income is above a certain level.)
> no retirement programs
Retirement programs other than Social Security aren't safety net programs, so inasmuch as there is a need for them without basic income income, it doesn't go away with basic income.
Of course it does. What are the odds, however, that said swaths of government and the constituencies that support them would simply surrender and close up shop?
On the other hand, it is socialism, and socialism has a dismal record of success. Europe tried it, and is now bankrupt and having waves of social problems that did not exist 40 years ago. The USA has tried it and now is permanently divided, either 47/53 or 99/1, depending on who you ask.
I say go back to natural living. Let government handle defense, roads and environmental protection. Let local governments handle everything else flexibly. But stop trying to solve people's problems. It doesn't work, creates other problems, and discourages people from accepting responsibility for their own futures.
Here are a few facts to the contrary:
* Europe is not "bankrupt" from "socialism". In fact, even the most successful European countries (the Nordic states and Germany) are far more social-democratic than the "successfully capitalist" Anglo countries, most particularly the United States of America.
* Why is Europe "bankrupt"? Trade imbalances, and a monetary policy aimed at maintaining those trade imbalances for the benefit of the incumbent capitalist class rather than correcting them for the good of all citizens. It's not just net-importer nations like the "PIIGS" undergoing wage deflations and heavy debt, Germany has actually been leading Europe in wage deflation, not to mention that it does actually have a public debt issue. The cause of the Euro troubles, after the Great Recession itself of course, is the German use of mercantilism; the mercantilist system in Europe is not broken but working as (inadvertently, nobody outside Germany intended for Germany to become a mercantile empire) designed.
Citation: http://seekerblog.com/2012/01/17/euro-crisis-german-unit-lab...
* When have the successful Western nations been at their richest, in terms of total economic growth and socioeconomic equality? In their peak social-democratic years of the Postwar Consensus, precisely when what Americans decry as "big government" was used to shore up demand for labor and pump productivity into the economy through national infrastructure projects.
* Open question: does public and private debt growth have a causative relationship with the use of social-democratic fiscal policies, or with the use of certain trade and monetary policies instead? It's important to note that the late '60s and early '70s switched the entire Western world from the Bretton-Woods regime of trade and currency regulations (not to mention capital controls!) to today's neoliberal, neo-mercantilist regime of virtual debt-money. Today capitalist governments manipulate their currency whenever they want in order to suppress labor wages and increase exports, even despite normal market mechanisms acting against them (as in the cases of both China and Germany, who under "clean" markets would be effectively forced to consume and import more stuff, lest their money degrade into worthlessness from capital glut).
Sounds like a socialist idea right? But in fact the libertarian in me loves it - if implemented, it removes the need for vast swaths of government. If everyone is guaranteed a basic income, you no longer need vast systems to manage all the means-tested programs. No social security, no disability, no unemployment insurance, no retirement programs and tax shelters. No need for minimum wage. The list goes on and on.
And that's why it won't happen here...
[1]http://www.salon.com/2013/10/11/rather_than_savage_cuts_swit...