News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by blackhole on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @12:34PM (#6641363)
As a pianist and an electronic musician, I never have any qualms about making music I can't play.

This, however, is just ridiculous.

The thing is, it's not at all hard to write a piano piece that's unplayable. Simply add a third note group far enough above or below the existing two note groups and it will be physically impossible to play (unless someone else helps you). It doesn't need to be a grotesque fountain of millions of notes to be unplayable. This is better examined not as impossible music, but as an experiment that asks the question "how many notes can you use at the same time and still make a coherent song?"

The debate between music that's playable and music that's impossible would be better served by more realistic examples, instead of a small sub-culture.

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by acjohnson55 on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @02:13PM (#6642060)
I don't see why this is ridiculous. I don't think that physical playability/unplayability is the key feature here. What does it really mean to be "unplayable" anyway? When you play piano, is it your body that generates the sound, or are you manipulating a machine that generates it for you? There's a delay between notating a MIDI file and hearing the resulting sound, but the same goes for the time between your finger hitting the key and the hammers hitting the string. I'm not saying there isn't a distinction between live performance and pre-production, but I think we're better off looking at playability as a spectrum than a binary value.

We could critique the medium, but people have abused instruments and sound makers for generations. Look up prepared piano [1], glitch music [2], and the wide world of guitar effects. This is just another way exploring the possibilities of a given medium (MIDI, in this case).

Theoretically, we could generate all possible music just by adding together sine waves, but realistically, most music is only accessible by using far more limited mechanisms, like instruments, gadgets, and paradigmatic software, which in turn influence the creative process. A person is definitely free to critique the artistic merits of a given piece, but I think it's rather close-minded to critique an entire medium. Most of the styles of music we listen to were (or still are) considered cheating by adherents to some other style.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prepared_piano [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glitch_%28music%29

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by jerf on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @02:11PM (#6642043)
I found the result to be a rather monotonous sameyness. The sound of "all the piano keys being smashed" overwhelms everything else about the piece, and the end result is that for all the apparent energy, the end result is really quite boring.

Contrasted to its acoustic opposite, chip-tune minimalism, and I'll take chip-tune anyday, even in its "pure" form (limited polyphony, no postprocessing, etc, just as you would have found it back in the day).

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by aimhb on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @02:49PM (#6642360)
I appreciate Black MIDI not really as a "cool gimmick" but more as a genre of music. In my opinion, its main function and appeal is to embody music that is still pleasing to the ear, even if it would be impossible in practice.

The majority of the pieces linked to in this thread probably aren't the best example of this, but I think Dream Battle (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lzy_WrH8v7U) is quite good in this regard. The piece itself is just a normal piece -- it only happens to be unplayable, and since it is unplayable, there are a number of Black-MIDI-specific "extended techniques" that can be employed (as you'll see).

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by moultano on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @11:46PM (#6645108)
I'd be interested to hear what a practitioner of this would do starting from a renowned piece with some actual complexity. It seems like there's a lot of potential for cool effects, but it's held back a bit by compositions that don't use it for much.

There's stuff out there that has a frenetic line paired with a sparse melody that might work well: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RK5wWD1k7T0

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by jerf on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @04:24PM (#6643102)
It's better, yes. Still not my taste, but less monotonous.

Still, I'm not sure this "genre" has a lot of depths to explore. Their time and their choice, of course.

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by tesseractive on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @05:11PM (#6643438)
Rock started as music most people thought was too simple to be interesting, and so did jazz and a lot of early electronic music. I think it's really premature to write off a music style most people haven't even heard of yet.

Given how much interesting music (IMO) has come from things like serialist classical, I suspect it's only a matter of time before someone finds ways of producing interesting sorts of tone color that are more difficult to achieve via other methods.

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by jerf on Thursday October 31, 2013 @11:36AM (#6647404)
Well, the natural next step for the "genre" is to use something other than just pianos, then use multiple instruments simultaneously, and before you know it you're "just" writing very polyphonic music.

It depends on how pedantic you want to be about the word "genre", and I tend to avoid the word entirely when possible because of the really weird (IMHO) ideations that surround it. But in this case, if we're going to keep it to "piano"-type sounds, which we pretty much have to if we're going to have a "problem" that needs solving anyhow, I think they've pretty much explored the space that's available to them.

And the primary reason for this is that they are not charging into a new, unexplored space... quite the contrary. The piano has been explored for hundreds of years. Rather than opening bold new fields of exploration, this is exploring the last few remnant bits that people couldn't cover earlier due to not having hundreds of fingers.

I understand being open to music ideas, but I also don't believe in entirely turning off my brain. I really don't think there's much "there" there.

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by nitrogen on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @10:42PM (#6644905)
It's only a matter of time before someone in this scene rediscovers spectral music and creates a black MIDI version of Partiels (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kX77MC5oXDY).

I also think the black MIDI examples that have been posted would sound significantly better with better instrumentation (that is, more expensive softsynths -- I am a fan of TruePianos, personally).

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by k-mcgrady on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @06:46PM (#6644018)
>> "In my opinion, its main function and appeal is to embody music that is still pleasing to the ear, even if it would be impossible in practice."

It doesn't take many notes to make something impossible in practice. On piano 11 notes simultaneously makes it impossible for one person to play and it would probably sound a lot more coherent. The black midi I've listened to doesn't sound bad, but it all sounds quite similar - there isn't much range.

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by nitrogen on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @10:43PM (#6644912)
You can probably get to 12 to 14 and still sound good by using some of the fingers to play multiple neighboring notes.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by romaniv on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @04:46PM (#6643259)
Honestly, I think you can take most of the notes out of there and it will sound better. I'm not saying that it sounds bad, but the influx of keystrokes doesn't do much there sonically and adds some annoying artifacts.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by bryanlarsen on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @12:53PM (#6641486)
Ever played Rachmaninoff's Prelude in C# minor? 4 well separated simultaneous note groups in a couple of places. That makes it theoretically impossible to play...
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by CodeMage on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @01:20PM (#6641703)
Igudesman & Joo have their own way of playing stuff like that: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ifKKlhYF53w
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by leephillips on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @02:12PM (#6642053)
This had me in tears of laughter. What a genius.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by lstamour on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @01:57PM (#6641951)
I love these guys. Saw them live once. :)
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by ajtaylor on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @07:05PM (#6644110)
Pure genius, and funny too! I couldn't resist posting that link on facebook.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by npsimons on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @01:53PM (#6641918)
I'm assuming that since you bring up Rachmaninoff, you know that he reportedly had freakishly large hands, and was in the habit of writing things he could play, but others considered "impossible". To me, that's significantly different than black MIDI, which just seems silly, albeit vaguely amusing.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by bryanlarsen on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @02:24PM (#6642155)
I'm actually only referring to a couple of places in Prelude in C# minor. Most of the song is "almost impossible" for one reason or another, but there are a couple of places near the end where the lower octaves and the upper freakish chords are played simultaneously. The 9th and 11th measure from the end, to be precise. Even Rachmaninoff with his freak hands had to roll that.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by avdd_ on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @10:38PM (#6644892)
It's not a song, it's a prelude. And actually not very technically difficult, one reason for its immediate and enduring popularity. The simultaneous chords are just played very quickly one after the other and not "rolled".
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by bryanlarsen on Thursday October 31, 2013 @10:42PM (#6651509)
"not very technically difficult" is a matter of perspective. It's about as difficult a piece as any student or amateur is ever going to play or be exposed to and few students or amateurs are skilled enough to play it.

But it is accessible to amateurs, and sounds very impressive. Which is, as you noted, a good reason why it's so popular. It's a good piece to pull out when you want to show off.

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by ars on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @09:49PM (#6644765)
> large hands

Can't they make the piano keys a little smaller (narrower)?

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by gtani on Thursday October 31, 2013 @04:44AM (#6645771)
Yup, there's a company that does this, can't google it tho

http://books.google.com/books?id=IbZOJIpgnNwC&printsec=front...

Thing is, players with broad fingers have trouble negotiating between black keys as it is now.

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by nitrogen on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @10:44PM (#6644917)
Sure, but it could take considerable time to adapt one's muscle memory to the different key spacing.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by ars on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @10:55PM (#6644960)
The keyspacing is identical on all pianos?
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by nitrogen on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @11:09PM (#6644995)
For the most part, with the exception of toys and some compact synthesizers and MIDI input devices.

Edit: see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Musical_keyboard#Size_and_hist...

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by juletide on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @01:25PM (#6641739)
You could make the gap between those note groups wider and it would become impossible. Even then, it is impossible to play for some—my piano teacher had rather small hands and had to "cheat" by dropping out notes if she was going to try Rachmaninoff.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by normloman on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @12:59PM (#6641525)
A piano piece requiring 3 hands isn't impossible to play. You just need a second person to help you play it. ;)
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by blackhole on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @01:12PM (#6641629)
Yes, but by that same logic, no music is impossible to play. Just keep adding people to help you. Eventually, you'll be able to play it. This is why the entire "impossible" argument rapidly stops making sense, because you simply have to draw an arbitrary line somewhere, and it becomes a question of impracticality, not impossibility.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by romaniv on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @01:13PM (#6641639)
Or you can help yourself with your foot, like Jason D. Williams occasionally does.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by raverbashing on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @01:38PM (#6641818)
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by bjz_ on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @02:07PM (#6642017)
Original video here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=16oaGSltUPE

(thought she deserved the credit!)

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by joezydeco on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @06:26PM (#6643897)
I'm curious to know what you think about dubstep, then.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by nobodysfool on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @07:18PM (#6644196)
It's not really 'unplayable' it's simply not playable by a single pianist at a single keyboard. It would entirely be possible to have 30 pianists at 30 keyboards playing these songs. The question then becomes, "Why?"
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by Cthulhu_ on Thursday October 31, 2013 @07:39AM (#6646213)
> The question then becomes, "Why?"

Why not? [/argument]

Not everything needs to be done for a practical reason; that's most art.

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by the_cat_kittles on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @07:10PM (#6644142)
i think its really about the video more than the music