News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mozilla will add H.264 to Firefox as Cisco makes push for... by bbx on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @09:52AM (#6640503)
No matter what codec will eventually be widely adopted, I hope native video support for browsers will lead to better video players. Right now, I have issues with YouTube (loading speed, quality switching back and forth between 480p, 720p and 240p), Vimeo (still can't jump to a desired position, loads incredibly slowly), various Flash embedded players (won't load, or will reset to 0:00 when trying to change the current position), auto-playing videos, lack of controls, usability issues...

I usually end up downloading the video with a Firefox add-on to watch it later. Or just stop bothering and close the tab.

Re:Mozilla will add H.264 to Firefox as Cisco makes push for... by wyck on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @01:03PM (#6641557)
This has nothing to do with the codec, the quality issues are bandwidth related, most providers no not want to fork out cash to buffer your video's anymore.
Re:Mozilla will add H.264 to Firefox as Cisco makes push for... by GhotiFish on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @04:47PM (#6643262)
they most certainly are player related. I can easily avoid every problem the parent has described on a low quality DSL connection by downloading the video directly and watching the partial download in a native video player.

The state of video players on the internet is just flat out terrible. Given how restrictive the policies and philosophies are around downloading the videos and watching them directly, browser players arn't actually competing with native players. I don't think normal people realize just how terrible they are. I can't imagine this situation ever getting better.

Re:Mozilla will add H.264 to Firefox as Cisco makes push for... by michaelmior on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @07:47PM (#6644340)
Not that I disagree, but the argument that it's not bandwidth-related isn't refuted by saying you don't have issues by downloading the video and then playing it with another player.
Re:Mozilla will add H.264 to Firefox as Cisco makes push for... by GhotiFish on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @11:23PM (#6645039)
I said I don't have issues downloading video and playing with another player in low bandwith scenarios.
Re:Mozilla will add H.264 to Firefox as Cisco makes push for... by michaelmior on Thursday October 31, 2013 @11:03AM (#6647179)
But you said you partially downloaded the video, and then played it? Perhaps I'm missing something, but it sounds like the equivalent of pausing the Flash player and waiting for it to buffer.
Re:Mozilla will add H.264 to Firefox as Cisco makes push for... by GhotiFish on Thursday October 31, 2013 @11:40AM (#6647429)
Something's gone wrong with communication here:

It is the exact equivalent.

Except it never discards the buffer (they do this all the time), I can seek with impunity (I do this all the time), it doesn't consume huge amounts of CPU (they do this all the time), it goes full screen reliably and quickly (on linux they fail frequently), If there are problems with the connection then I won't lose everything I've downloaded (online video players are so terrible about this), I can run it at any speed I want (I do this all the time), I can supplement it with third party subtitles (I do this all the time) ect. ect. ect.

further, no bizarre bandwidth saving gets involved. If the connection is very bad, I can just let it download. It won't stop after 10 seconds and wait for me to play, and I get to decide when it starts playing. I can resume failed downloads, I can respond to bad connections, I can use web technologies that have existed for decades that are specifically there to deal with bad connections to route around poor network conditions.

Video players on the web are just death by a thousand cuts. They're all different unique little snowflakes, and all worse then windows media player from 2001. We are literally swimming in methodologies to deal with poor network connections, and the inter

but other than that they are equivalent.

Re:Mozilla will add H.264 to Firefox as Cisco makes push for... by Amadou on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @07:37PM (#6644296)
It is yet another hidden price of DRM. The W3C's embrace of DRM won't help either.
Re:Mozilla will add H.264 to Firefox as Cisco makes push for... by cbhl on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @10:03AM (#6640564)
I've never seen any of those issues -- are you sure your Internet provider isn't throttling video packets with DPI or something?
Re:Mozilla will add H.264 to Firefox as Cisco makes push for... by redthrowaway on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @11:38AM (#6641059)
I get the same, and it's not dependent on ISP. Many (most?) flash players are buggy resource hogs, and the html5 implementations I've seen don't feel ready for primetime yet.
Re:Mozilla will add H.264 to Firefox as Cisco makes push for... by actionscripted on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @01:06PM (#6641583)
(Former) Flash nerd here. The problems with plackback and scrubbing are absolutely the fault of the Flash player and there's really nothing you can do about it short of hacking your own video handling into the SWF format. There are a lot of low-level network-related problems in Flash.

I have zero real proof, but I know for a long time Adobe (Macromedia) was pushing their streaming server and didn't really put a lot of effort into handling streaming/buffering without it and I suspect this just never got fixed as things were "good enough".

Re:Mozilla will add H.264 to Firefox as Cisco makes push for... by krilnon on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @07:02PM (#6644096)
To be fair, there weren't many (any?) standardized alternatives back then. There was no particular incentive for Adobe to support, say, Red5 when there was no standard to gather around. Apple's HLS is a pretty recent attempt at moving toward a documented standard.

If you're talking about streaming .flvs off of a regular Apache setup, then it shouldn't be surprising that scrubbing and seeking are troublesome: static file servers weren't build for that use case.

What would you have preferred Adobe to have done?

Re:Mozilla will add H.264 to Firefox as Cisco makes push for... by cataflam on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @04:04PM (#6642951)
As others have said in answer, it's absolutely the fault of the various Flash embedded players.

It's somewhat easy to prove if you write your own player (not in Flash) to bypass the Flash player of sites like YouTube, Twitch, etc. The experience becomes perfectly smooth (as long as you have the average bandwidth), the video starts quickly, jumping to another point in the video is almost instant.

Re:Mozilla will add H.264 to Firefox as Cisco makes push for... by JohnTHaller on Thursday October 31, 2013 @12:11AM (#6645187)
If you're using a provider like Time Warner that has well-known and longstanding issues between it and Google's caching servers, that could be your issue. Myself and fellow Time Warnians in much of NYC spent about 2 years nearly unable to play anything above 480p. Google was sending everyone from certain blocks of Time Warner to the same caching server and it would get overloaded. There were a couple tricks you could implement at the OS level that would block the overloaded Google servers and get better video, but if you weren't using a router that supported those blocks, you were out of luck on your Xbox, Playstation, etc.

Note that things seem to be working better this year, though.

Re:Mozilla will add H.264 to Firefox as Cisco makes push for... by unicornporn on Thursday October 31, 2013 @06:20PM (#6650414)
Re:Mozilla will add H.264 to Firefox as Cisco makes push for... by Synaesthesia on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @01:04PM (#6641565)
The best experience is from a Safari extension called Youtube-5. It uses so much less CPU power and is so much smoother, it really puts Flash based players to shame, and shows how good the experience could, and should be.
Re:Mozilla will add H.264 to Firefox as Cisco makes push for... by WalterSear on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @01:17PM (#6641674)
I had all those problems until I dropped my ATT DSL for a local provider.
Re:Mozilla will add H.264 to Firefox as Cisco makes push for... by ChrisNorstrom on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @06:44PM (#6644010)
Use Chrome, install a YouTube buffering plugin that buffers all the way.