News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chromium: "MathML is not something that we want at this t... by general_failure on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @01:54AM (#6639778)
Before all the chrome and Google bashing starts...

The point is why do we need something specific for math. Would people be OK with a musicml? Or say chemicalml? And that's a good question. Why is math so special? Let's try to solve the problem more generically instead of adding specialized domains in the browser.

Re:Chromium: "MathML is not something that we want at this t... by dak1 on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @02:18AM (#6639858)
There's a long thread on mozilla.dev.platform[1] that lays out the arguments for MathML quite well.

I'd also add that there is a W3C Math WG, and has been for over a decade. I would have thought the question of whether or not MathML is desirable would have been answered at some point in that time frame before it became a W3C Recommendation.

[1] https://groups.google.com/forum/#!msg/mozilla.dev.platform/9...

Re:Chromium: "MathML is not something that we want at this t... by zurn on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @03:10AM (#6639973)
That thread starts with a pretty well reasoned argument for dropping MathML ("Summary: MathML is a vestigial remnant of the XML-everything era, and we should drop it."), and a later message provides more background for WebKit/Blink MathML problems: "The Blink implementation was never good enough to render MathML pages well in the real world, whether there were any or not. It also had some pretty major brokenness in the way it was integrated into Blink, which made it difficult to enable safely. "
Re:Chromium: "MathML is not something that we want at this t... by ibotty on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @04:21AM (#6640164)
and there are very many arguments pro MathML in it as well, which makes the reasoning seem not so well founded.

to quote one rebuttal of every point the thread op made:

1.1. you make a point against adding unnecessary typography. Mathematics is text, but adding new requirements. It's comparable to the introduction of RTL or tables much more than musical notation. It's also something that all school children will encounter for 9-12 years. IMHO, this makes it necessary to implement mathematical typesetting functionality.

1.2 you claimed MathML is inferior to TeX. I've tried to point out that that's not the case as most scientific and educational publishers use it extensively.

1.2.1 you claimed TeX is the universal standard. I've tried to point out only research mathematicians use it as a standard. Almost most mathematics happens outside that group.

1.2.2 You pointed out that MathML isn't friendly to manual input. That's true but HTML isn't very friendly either, nor is SVG.

1.2.3 You argued TeX is superior for accessibility. I've pointed out that that's not the case given the current technology landscape.

2 You wrote now is the time to drop MathML. I've tried to point out that now -- as web and ebook standard -- is the time to support it, especially when your implementation is almost complete and you're looking to carve a niche out of the mobile and mobile OS market, ebooks etc.

2.1 you claim MathML never saw traction outside of Firefox. I tried to point out that MathML has huge traction in publishing and the educational sector, even if it wasn't visible on the web until MathJax came along. Google wants MathML support (they just don't trust the current code) while Apple has happily advertised with the MathML they got for free. Microsoft indeed remains a mystery.

2.2 you claim MathJax does a great job -- ok, I'm not going to argue ;) -- while browsers don't. But we've used native output on Firefox before MathJax 2.0 and plan to do it again soon -- it is well implemented and can provide the same quality of typesetting.

3. Well, I'm not sure what to say to those. If math is a basic typographical need, then the syntax doesn't matter -- we need to see it implemented and its bottom up layout process clashes with CSS's top down process. No change in syntax will resolve that.

Re:Chromium: "MathML is not something that we want at this t... by weland on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @03:53AM (#6640088)
> The point is why do we need something specific for math.

You seem not to have been around when we had to do it over plain text. It sucked. MathML is a huge gain for sharing thoughts over scientific matters. Of course, they aren't as important to today's "open web" compared to, say, ads and making text rumble with JS, but they shouldn't be relegated to an entirely unimportant position, especially considered they're part of the famous HTML5 standard that should supposedly deliver us from the dreaded fractures between platforms.

Re:Chromium: "MathML is not something that we want at this t... by deSouza on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @02:04AM (#6639819)
"Why is math so special?". Try counting up the fields that use mathematical notation versus musical and chemical notation.
Re:Chromium: "MathML is not something that we want at this t... by farnsworth on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @02:21AM (#6639863)
Is "counting the fields" how we should consider all Chrome feature requests? A browser's user is not a field.
Re:Chromium: "MathML is not something that we want at this t... by deSouza on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @02:37AM (#6639893)
I love the semantics heroes here on HN.
Re:Chromium: "MathML is not something that we want at this t... by eof on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @02:46AM (#6639921)
That would be a pretty good argument if MathML weren't in the HTML5 spec
Re:Chromium: "MathML is not something that we want at this t... by bayesianhorse on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @02:01AM (#6639802)
Why is math so special?

Asked at Hackernews?

Really?

Re:Chromium: "MathML is not something that we want at this t... by codezero on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @02:10AM (#6639837)
Is asking that off limits? If it's so obvious and easy to understand, explain it. Also, Chrome caters to a very wide audience so dev time has to consider a much broader audience than hackers.
Re:Chromium: "MathML is not something that we want at this t... by ovangle on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @02:23AM (#6639866)
The problem is that the Chrome team shouldn't be selectively implementing parts of the html5 standard [1]. It shouldn't matter how many users desire the functionality after it's accepted by the w3c.

Of course, Chrome could implement whatever it likes if it drops any claim to be standards compliant, but until that happens...

[1] http://www.w3.org/Math/draft-spec/mathml.html

[deleted]
Re:Chromium: "MathML is not something that we want at this t... by ovangle on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @02:37AM (#6639894)
Ummm, no. It is part of the html5 spec, under embedded content.

http://www.w3.org/html/wg/drafts/html/master/embedded-conten...

Re:Chromium: "MathML is not something that we want at this t... by anon1385 on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @02:41AM (#6639910)
Is that a meaningful distinction? <img>, <video>, <audio> and <math> are all on this page: http://www.w3.org/html/wg/drafts/html/CR/embedded-content-0....
Re:Chromium: "MathML is not something that we want at this t... by mddw on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @04:20AM (#6640161)
What ? Of course they should. It's all about choice. There are a shitload of standards and a limited amount of man-hour.
Re:Chromium: "MathML is not something that we want at this t... by threeseed on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @02:38AM (#6639898)
So why not just say we would like to do this but don't have time ?

The impression I got was that they would never implement it.

Re:Chromium: "MathML is not something that we want at this t... by bayesianhorse on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @02:49AM (#6639926)
Just to explain the joke: Math is special to us nerds.
Re:Chromium: "MathML is not something that we want at this t... by codezero on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @02:52AM (#6639933)
So the Chrome team should implement this because...
Re:Chromium: "MathML is not something that we want at this t... by saraid216 on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @03:14AM (#6639984)
Do MusicML or ChemicalML exist yet? I'd be interested even in the specifications if you've got some links. A quick Google didn't net much.
Re:Chromium: "MathML is not something that we want at this t... by haberman on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @03:26AM (#6640015)
Re:Chromium: "MathML is not something that we want at this t... by btown on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @01:33PM (#6641777)
The closest thing to an open-source in-browser JS renderer would be something based on https://github.com/0xfe/vexflow, but a reliable converter for MusicXML hasn't been written yet.
Re:Chromium: "MathML is not something that we want at this t... by mindcrime on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @12:22PM (#6641299)
Re:Chromium: "MathML is not something that we want at this t... by mindcrime on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @12:21PM (#6641295)
The point is why do we need something specific for math.

Considering that the roots of the WWW are in a scientific research organization (CERN)[1], and considering how much scientific users use maths, then yeah, I'd say it makes sense that maths should be a native part of the WWW platform.

[1]: http://www.w3.org/History.html