News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why I Stick with the Linux Desktop by VeejayRampay on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @05:53PM (#6637763)
It's way too nice to Apple to call their piss-poor Spaces "Virtual Desktops". Call me when I can finally arrange them how I want (i.e. 2 rows, 2 columns) and not have them in line, which is stupid and inefficient. I'd also like a call when Apple finally implements maximize for windows.

And don't get me wrong, I am a Mac user, just a highly frustrated one when I see people praising them as the second coming of the prophet even though a lot of extremely useful features are just missing because some dude at Cupertino decided that Mac users didn't need them.

PS: Negative post, I know, but it feels good.

Re:Why I Stick with the Linux Desktop by kozikow on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @06:25PM (#6637939)
Did you try Amethyst: https://github.com/ianyh/Amethyst ? It's Tiling WM modeled after xmonad for OSX. Among other things it brings better keyboard support to spaces. I have keyboard shortcut for "move to n-th space", "move focused window to n-th/left/right space". And since you mentioned maximizing - since it's modeled after xmonad (tiling WM) every window is maximized when opened (or splitted with current focused windows, depening on your layout).
Re:Why I Stick with the Linux Desktop by alayne on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @06:01PM (#6637807)
It's best to just have keyboard shortcuts for each space (Control 1-4) rather than move left to right. Even if you are moving in a 2x2 virtual screen you usually still have the inefficient diagonal case.
Re:Why I Stick with the Linux Desktop by VeejayRampay on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @06:19PM (#6637909)
You're absolutel right about that. I should have mentioned that I mostly use 3 virtual desktops (browser in the first one, vim in the second and some messaging app on the third) so I do arrows for 99% of my moving anyway.
Re:Why I Stick with the Linux Desktop by selectodude on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @06:00PM (#6637797)
Agreed. Spaces circa 10.6 was so much better than the crap we have now. But it seems like Apple is at least fixing their regressions for the first time since 10.7.
Re:Why I Stick with the Linux Desktop by caiob on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @06:09PM (#6637852)
It was indeed, but the usage was much lower. At least people use that feature now.
Re:Why I Stick with the Linux Desktop by 0x09 on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @06:03PM (#6637817)
You should try TotalSpaces. I can't speak for it, but it appears to replace the functionality lost from 10.6.

For me Spaces in 10.5 and 10.6 is as good as any *nix WM and better than several due to the linear wrapping behavior (on a 2x2 grid any workspace is accessible via directional key from any other.)

Re:Why I Stick with the Linux Desktop by wting on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @06:33PM (#6637973)
You might want to look into BetterTouchTool (http://www.boastr.de/). It gives you the ability to map keys to full screen maximize, left and right split, and a plethora of other options.
Re:Why I Stick with the Linux Desktop by bluthru on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @06:23PM (#6637926)
They're not "stupid" and "piss-poor". Linear desktops are a huge usability win for a multitude of reasons:

* It's spatially an easier mental model.

* This mental model is consistent with iOS multitasking and iOS home screen.

* It allows for simple gestures to switch between desktops.

* In western society, we read from left to right. New is to the right. Fullscreen a new desktops are added to the right.

* This also sets up a linear "Forward/back" model similar to web pages.

* You can easily add ONE desktop on the fly. No need to make it a grid for no reason.

* The biggest reason: Spaces and expose are unified into Mission Control. One action to see EVERYTHING. This is a huge plus, as people don't have to check two different locations for a window. A grid of desktops wouldn't fit up above in mission control.

* There's nothing below the dock and there's nothing above the menubar. Simple mental model.

Regarding "maximize for windows":

* It's a "fit window to content" button. A window shouldn't take up more space than is necessary in a multi-tasking environment. Regardless, there is a fullscreen mode and windows also remember their position and dimensions if you drag them.

Re:Why I Stick with the Linux Desktop by baddox on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @06:35PM (#6637981)
> * It's spatially an easier mental model.

This is the only point that really matters, and I think it's false. A square grid is a far easier mental model for me. Remembering if something else is above|below|to the left|to the right of where I am is way easier to remember and visualize than how many slots to the right or left something is.

Re:Why I Stick with the Linux Desktop by buo on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @06:44PM (#6638046)
I have four virtual desktops mapped to WinKey+{a,s,z,x}. I've used this scheme for so long that the keys are hardwired in my brain and I can switch desktops without even thinking about it. In particular, I don't care if the window manager organizes the desktops in a matrix or linearly, since I don't need a visual representation.

As an aside, my biggest gripe with Ubuntu is that they hard code the Win key to something else, which breaks my desktop switching habits.

Re:Why I Stick with the Linux Desktop by baddox on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @09:14PM (#6638792)
Fair enough. It sounds like you use a more specific named mental model, rather than a visual one. When I used a 2x2 virtual desktop grid (I don't use virtual desktops at all anymore), I has loosely defined roles for each desktop, but it was fairly dynamic. I used the visual model, as in "Where did I throw that terminal window? I think it's right below me."
Re:Why I Stick with the Linux Desktop by VeejayRampay on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @07:09PM (#6638174)
That's actually pretty cool. I'll use some variation of that using hjkl :)
Re:Why I Stick with the Linux Desktop by kazoolist on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @08:30PM (#6638600)
+1 for Virtual Desktops and key mappings for each.

I do 3x3, mapped to <ctr>+<alt>+[1-9] on the keypad.

Re:Why I Stick with the Linux Desktop by VeejayRampay on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @07:08PM (#6638163)
About all those nice bullet points: That's cool, but I'd like to be able to use a grid layout. I'm not looking for an argument or a lesson about the awesomeness of the Apple Way™. I just see people trying to accomodate their 9 Spaces and moving tediously from 9 to 1 and back, while pondering the "huge usability win" that is the linear desktop layout and that's when it hits me: "It'd be nice to have the option of using a grid layout, Linux has that, it's pretty nice".

Then I mention maximize and you tell me "it's not maximize, it's fit to content". Then again, that's all nice and dandy but if I wanted "fit to content" I guess I'd be already be satisfied and I wouldn't be complaining about it now, would I? Same for fullscreen, I'm sure you actually do understand the difference between maximize and fullscreen. I don't want fullscreen, I want maximize, a feature Mac OS X does not offer (except for a few apps like Terminal.app, which makes it not only an idiotic choice, but also inconsistent across the OS).

Re:Why I Stick with the Linux Desktop by JasonFruit on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @08:57PM (#6638707)
That's exactly why I haven't been able to bring myself to buy nice Apple hardware: there are too many things where I say, "I want it," and the answer is "You shouldn't." With my LXDE desktop, I can make it act however I want, and I'm pleased and productive, even though I shouldn't be.
Re:Why I Stick with the Linux Desktop by bluthru on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @08:11PM (#6638506)
If you're evaluating an Apple product based on how many options it gives you, or how it might bend to your individual desire, you're gonna have a bad time. Apple is opinionated, and there are usability benefits to be gained from that. Mission control would not work with a grid.