News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Profit affects doctors' treatment decisions by jellicle on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @04:28PM (#6637207)
That's a fine bit of conservative nonsense you just regurgitated, coming to the conclusion that the problem the U.S. is suffering from is "too much health care", and therefore the solution is to reduce access to healthcare and insurance. It rests on the assumption that patients get frivolous medical procedures (open heart surgery for you! and open heart surgery for you! and open heart surgery for you!) because they may not pay full price for them, a claim which, like the teapot orbiting the sun directly opposite the Earth, has never been observed in real life.

In actuality, healthcare is a well known example of a market failure - there cannot be a normal market in healthcare ever, because definitionally, your health is worth an infinite amount of money to you (how much would you pay not to be a slave? how much would you pay not to have your hands and feet chopped off?).

Further, healthcare prices are unpredictable. How much does a gall bladder surgery cost? Did I mention that the patient got a flesh-eating bacterial infection as a result of the surgery? That's true and will always be true even if prices were posted at the door, which they are not.

The solution - which has been discovered by every advanced nation on Earth except the U.S. - is having the government strongly involved in paying for healthcare, insuring across the entire population to even out costs and making sure that, e.g., medical device manufacturers can't gouge the unknowing public. Monopsony powers nicely counteract the inherent power imbalance that healthcare providers normally have over the sick, and everything works just fine, costing each of those nations less to cover their entire nation than the U.S. currently spends to cover a small segment of its population.

Re:Profit affects doctors' treatment decisions by bhauer on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @07:07PM (#6638159)
> That's a fine bit of conservative nonsense you just regurgitated

Conservative, libertarian, I guess they are more or less the same for this subject. Fine.

> coming to the conclusion that the problem the U.S. is suffering from is "too much health care"

I suppose you're saying that because higher prices suggest a glut of supply? Wait, no.

I'm not sure why you say that is the conclusion of my argument. I certainly never said the US has too much healthcare, nor imply it.

In fact, if anything the US is supply-constrained in healthcare thanks to the AMA, FDA, etc. There is plenty of demand for healthcare, but the supply is pretty well controlled through regulation.

I certainly can't start selling healthcare. Even with a lot of studying, I still couldn't just sell healthcare. Making additional healthcare supply isn't like making more supply of furniture, food, or even cars (which is closer on the regulation spectrum to healthcare, meaning it requires a herculean effort to enter this industry—witness Tesla).

> therefore the solution is to reduce access to healthcare and insurance

What?

No, I'd rather make these services more readily available to everyone by making them available in the same way nearly every other product is available to anyone. Is the iPad unavailable to me because my employer doesn't provide tablet insurance? Just sell me healthcare and health insurance on regular markets, please. Nothing could be more available in my opinion.

As it is, the "availability" of healthcare in my life is extremely narrow (again thanks to what evolved from 1940s price controls). I have a small set of options from one vendor selected by my employer. With the ACA, I will now have that option (maybe, though it's an HSA and I've been told to kiss HSAs goodbye) and a few other ratified options that have been selected by a central planning committee.

If I can't afford routine health care on a regular market, I'd rather work harder to get a better job. In a worst-case scenario, I'll plead with friends and family or charities. I genuinely would prefer this to the current model. I'd pick up insurance to handle catastrophic events. I'd donate more to charity to boot.

> your health is worth an infinite amount of money to you

Actually, not really. If I have a quality of life issue and I can improve my quality of life for $500, I will weigh the pros and cons and probably go for it. If it costs $500,000, I'll suck it up until someone innovates the cost down to something I can afford.

Even if I have a catastrophic issue and I have no insurance, and the only resolution is something that costs $1M, this is something my family (friends, charities) should decide. Sell/refinance property or pull the plug? Bottom line, it's a local decision to pull the plug, not something for a central planning board.

> Further, healthcare prices are unpredictable

This is not a counter-argument to using regular price signals. Services that are unpredictable are usually billed at hourly rates or time and materials with an estimate. If I have the termite guy out to check my house, he's not going to be able to give me a quote until he assesses the situation. Even then, it may be worse than he thought. But he has a price sheet of hours and services and I can look at that and select a different termite guy if the price sheet seems out of line. Better yet, other people will have paid termite guys and give me a basic feel for what a termite guy charges. When he says his hourly rate is $5,000, I'll know he's a nutcase.

Today, if I heard it cost $5,000/hr for some medical procedure, I wouldn't even know how to react. Is that a lot? Is it low? I don't even know who I could ask for a guess.

> which has been discovered by every advanced nation on Earth except the U.S.

I don't enjoy the argument that everyone else does something a given way, so why don't you get in line already. The way I see it, this country has been doing healthcare more similar to other countries (no true market, no price signals) than similar to what I want for decades.

A free market can support a central-planning model inside of itself, but vice-versa is never possible. This is why those of us who support free markets are so sensitive to those who would shut them off. Central planners don't have to kill the free market to do their central planning exercise, but they always choose to.

We don't ask them to kill central planning so we can have a free market. In fact, we don't even care how central planners want to arrange their centrally-planned plan inside the free market, as long as it's voluntary. Have fun!

If I had my way, the ACA would make centrally-planned healthcare an entirely in or entirely out proposition. Voluntary. Don't want in? Fine, you're on your own. Entirely.

I'd opt out. And soon enough, I'd find people ready to sell me health care. Then I'd give more to charity. I'd be so much happier.

Re:Profit affects doctors' treatment decisions by pyoung on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @08:21PM (#6638560)
One major oversight that you fail to address in you hypothetical free market scenario is that supply is still constrained. In a truly free market, anyone can set up shop and try to market and sell their services. If I buy a TV that craps out in two days, I either get it fixed by warranty or I go online and write a bad review which hopefully contributes to the demise of the company. If I get a bad surgery from a poorly trained doctor I die. That is why we have the FDA etc, and that is why doctors are rigorously vetted and trained through the med school/residency process, and I think most people would agree that that is a good thing.

Another issue I have is your mention of 'charity'. Almost anytime this gets used in a political/economic discussion, it is used to dismiss a whole class of problems that the author does not want to deal with in their argument. In this particular case you mention that if you cannot afford a 'free market' doctor/treatment, then you can turn to charity to provide the funds. Of course we all know that charity will never come close to providing for the entirety of society, so you are left with a situation where almost everyone except those who can afford treatment are forced to go without it. And of course the typical libertarian response is "tough luck" or "work harder". But here is the thing, health, similar to environmental issues has strong public effects. There are a number of diseases and illnesses that, if left untreated in a large portion of the population, can have devastating impacts on society. A healthy population is a necessity of a first world economy and relying on charity to ensure positive, society level outcomes is absurd and ignores reality.

Look, I lean libertarian on many issues, but there are certain aspects of society that are just not suited to a free market. I want to be able to go to a restaurant without being terrified of catching TB from the waiter or getting salmonella poisoning from the food. I don't want industrial companies polluting the ocean and rivers that I surf and fish in. The free market can be very powerful, but it is also fairly dumb, it cannot recognize when it is doing more collective harm than good. I don't see why so many libertarians think in terms of all or nothing. Compromise shouldn't be such a dirty word in today's political discussions, it's a sad state of affairs.

Re:Profit affects doctors' treatment decisions by bhauer on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @09:09PM (#6638768)
> That is why we have the FDA etc, and that is why doctors are rigorously vetted and trained through the med school/residency process, and I think most people would agree that that is a good thing.

With the amount of error we have (see malpractice suits) as it is, I'm not convinced that what we have right now is actually yielding better overall results than a free market would with actual price signals.

Reason being that medical care quality is usually not a binary matter—with outcomes of either total success or total failure. Usually it's a broad continuum, and yet mediocre doctors are presently extremely difficult to differentiate from superb doctors because of the lack of price signals.

Malpractice suits would still exist in a free market, of course. And if care lead to death, there would be lawsuits. But in a majority of cases, bad care would lead to non-death but non-ideal resolution. That's where price signals will flourish.

Ironically, I see the current situation as an all-or-nothing where I want more nuance. We currently treat all doctors as essentially similar because they have all completed the same rigorous training and certification process, and we few other measures to use. (Some above-market review systems notwithstanding.)

Finally, don't be certain that doing away with regulation would lead to certifications evaporating. It more likely would mean variation in certification. A less politically-entrenched alternative to the AMA perhaps. (Of course, I'm also not necessarily bowled over by certification. I put no stock in computer programming certifications.)

> And of course the typical libertarian response is "tough luck" or "work harder".

While true, this shouldn't be dismissed cavalierly. We tend to speak without as much political thought as the right and left—saying apparently heartless things like "work harder." But what we mean in practice is that there would be more emphatic pressure on individuals to work to solve their own life situations first and only in extreme cases leverage safety nets.

We have a situation today where half of the country uses some form of government assistance. That's not what safety nets should be for. But outside of "character" or other intangibles, there's no incentive to avoid the safety nets—in fact there's every incentive to use them, lest you be a sucker. Only suckers pay for things.

When I had an electric car, I momentarily reeled at the $5,000 federal government incentive because it goes against my every belief. But, come on. Who is going to pass on such a sweet kick-back? I took the money. We all do.

Yes, it's utterly impossible for a libertarian paradise to provide a 50% safety net. But we feel we have such a large safety net because it's a venus fly trap, not because it is necessary to have a 50% safety net as a first principle.

Furthermore, many libertarians are amenable to a basic income, and with a basic income and a free market for health care and health insurance, it's almost a foregone conclusion that a great deal of competition would angle for that demand.

> Compromise shouldn't be such a dirty word in today's political discussions, it's a sad state of affairs

The trouble with compromise is what I said earlier. We're willing to allow central planners to build within a free market, to create a voluntary consortium of participants supporting one another through centrally-planned distribution of resources. But reverse the tables and we're absolutely never permitted the same freedom. Central-planning is not voluntary; it a piece of totalitarianism.

So compromising with central planners means totally conceding. Either they plan for you or you plan for you. I prefer planning for me, difficulties and all.

Re:Profit affects doctors' treatment decisions by hharrison on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @02:25AM (#6639868)
I'm surprised that this point hasn't come up yet in this conversation: the whole point of insurance is to pool risk. The basic principle is that of everyone who pays in, the lucky ones subsidize the unlucky ones.

Obviously, this works best the more people who pay in. When people don't get insurance until they need it, it raises the cost for everyone. When people don't get insurance and still end up burdening those who did (by going bankrupt when faced with monstrous E.R. bills, for a common example), costs go up for everyone. In these situations, there's only way to make the system work: enforce that everyone buys in. That's why I support single-payer.

Here's another car analogy: car insurance is mandatory for drivers in the U.S., and most countries. Because the system only works when everyone buys in.

Of course it offends the libertarian sensibility to force people to buy something. How barbaric! Personally, I'm a libertarian-to-leftist convert. I think society needs a monopoly on force, and that monopoly goes to the government. The use of that force should be minimized, but one of reasons we need it is to force people to chip in for the common good. When it comes to pooled risk for catastrophic events, it's worth it. I have no moral qualms. It's not a matter of who's doing the planning, it's a matter of societal choices that just plain don't work if not everyone's on board. You're right that central planning is not voluntary. That's the whole point.

> But outside of "character" or other intangibles, there's no incentive to avoid the safety nets—in fact there's every incentive to use them, lest you be a sucker. Only suckers pay for things.

"Yeah, look at all those suckers, paying for things, how stupid. Why bother trying to make more money? It's not like I value character-building." - single mom making $12,000/year, and (gasp) receiving government assistance

Do you really think government assistance makes poverty appealing?

Re:Profit affects doctors' treatment decisions by warfangle on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @11:55PM (#6639390)
>But in a majority of cases, bad care would lead to non-death but non-ideal resolution. That's where price signals will flourish.

Conjecture. Got proof? (let's say, a statistical analysis between the recent spate of doctors who no longer accept insurance -- only cold hard cash or credit -- and their Swedish counterparts in both patient care and malpractice suite rate)

That's the thing about this entire argument. We're point at those other folks that seem to be a doing a lot better job at this whole keeping people healthy thing than we are. And you're pointing at this conjecture that maybe people make rational decisions in a market.

And we know that's not true.

Just look at homeopathic medicine to see how well the free market does, without FDA intervention, at keeping people healthy - and getting them healthy if they aren't.

Re:Profit affects doctors' treatment decisions by pyoung on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @11:06PM (#6639203)
I am strongly in favor of basic income, primarily because I think technology is going to make it increasingly difficult for many individuals to find meaningful, high paying work. But even with sufficient basic income, people are going to forgo insurance and health care until it's too late, and as I mentioned in the previous post, this will have societal level effects.

I would agree that in a more ideal world, we could have free market health care. With enough technological progress, it might be possible to get accurate diagnoses of illnesses just by using an iphone app and then go to a pharmacy (or get drone delivery) to get a prescription for a cheap nano surgery pillbot. But we are way too far away from that, and there are way too many human lives on the line. I think it's okay to be militantly idealistic, but when human lives are at stake, I think it is necessary to cede to practicality.

Re:Profit affects doctors' treatment decisions by vasilipupkin on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @12:27AM (#6639510)
Libretarians tend to conveniently forget that the reason we have FDA, EPA and all that good stuff is that when it was all pure market, it wasn't working very well - that's why we set FDA up in the first place. That is not to say that the current system is perfect.
Re:Profit affects doctors' treatment decisions by steamer25 on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @02:07PM (#6642012)
In spite of the FDA, people are still [potentially] swindled by e.g., colloidal silver, ionized air and water, various supplements, energy drinks, etc. Moreover, it's much harder to tout the benefits of eating e.g., oranges or kale without funding a zillion dollar study.

I do think various products and services should be reviewed but there are better ways to do it than with a federal agency. E.g., https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_ioniser#Consumer_Reports_c...

Re:Profit affects doctors' treatment decisions by projct on Friday November 01, 2013 @03:52PM (#6655906)
Re:Profit affects doctors' treatment decisions by steamer25 on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @01:41PM (#6641839)
> That is why we have the FDA etc, and that is why doctors are rigorously vetted and trained through the med school/residency process, and I think most people would agree that that is a good thing.

I can imagine a world where it's sufficient to see that physician X is certified by Harvard and works for a clinic that's recommended by Consumer Reports without any involvement from the state. In this scenario the FDA would still exist as a competing organization but no one would be compelled to buy their product via taxation.

> Of course we all know that charity will never come close to providing for the entirety of society

Ostensibly, we've all voted for compulsory charity. If we can be trusted to vote so nobly, why not put down the guns and self-elect to be charitable?

> I want to be able to go to a restaurant without being terrified of catching TB from the waiter or getting salmonella poisoning from the food

I agree and I don't think I'd lose any libertarian cred to say that the government does have a role here because the restaurant has defrauded you and breached the implicit contract to provide you with safe food.

> I don't want industrial companies polluting the ocean and rivers that I surf and fish in.

I think property rights solve a lot of these things--"Oh, they polluted some river..." vs. "They polluted MY river?!" . I can concede that things like oceans and larger rivers should not be privately held but in these cases I'd prefer local government jurisdiction to federal/global governments. Essentially, the more aggregate the government, the more deliberate/unintrusive/restrained/super-majoritized I think it should be. In my mind, health-care is not one such federal issue.

Re:Profit affects doctors' treatment decisions by amalag on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @09:02PM (#6638735)
What do you think of the Singapore model? It includes price subsidies, health savings accounts and catastrophic coverage. I think the US will not move towards single payer medicaid for all, I think it will adopt something along these lines.

I think if people are forced to pay for routine care, we will get a much better system. Then insurance will be what it is meant for, catastrophic insurance. The simple analogy that noone uses car insurance to pay for oil changes is relevant I think.

Re:Profit affects doctors' treatment decisions by bhauer on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @09:26PM (#6638833)
Admittedly, I'm not all that familiar with Singapore's model. But based on your description, it sounds better than where we're headed.

I fully agree that if we paid out of pocket for routine maintenance and minor "repairs," we'd have the makings of a superior system. Give healthcare a genuine price signal and stop asking, "why is healthcare so expensive?"

It's expensive for the same reason university education is expensive. Most of the time, someone else is paying.

Re:Profit affects doctors' treatment decisions by amalag on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @10:55AM (#6640851)
Unfortunately conservatives who hardly pronounce a sentence other than "Repeal Obamacare". I think everyone would welcome some debate on alternatives. As much as we like the market influence on routine care, I think the real cost is the elder and catastrophic care. We have sophisticated and expensive systems for health care. I don't know the answer, maybe it means eliminating insurance companies for a single payer model, and maybe it means higher deductible catastrphic care insurance. I do think the combination of insurance company lobbying and american disdain of "socialism" make things different here.
Re:Profit affects doctors' treatment decisions by sgift on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @03:06AM (#6639961)
> Actually, not really. If I have a quality of life issue and I can improve my quality of life for $500, I will weigh the pros and cons and probably go for it. If it costs $500,000, I'll suck it up until someone innovates the cost down to something I can afford.

Good luck sucking up "take the procedure or die." Somehow, the "free market is best! Free market is king! Free market loves you!"-crowd always seems to ignore this not so small part of healthcare. It is always just "I don't need this procedure, so I just wait until it gets cheaper and suck it up until then!" .. yeah, sure.

Re:Profit affects doctors' treatment decisions by novalis78 on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @05:00PM (#6637383)
One thought: there are other industries which sell services and tools that fluctute in price or are so complex that it is amazing how they can price their products at all - but they do. Just the fact that I cannot get any reliable pricing information for most procedures from health care providers seems strange and might point to the fact that their processes and methods are under no self-regulating forces/pressure. The situation reminds of Florida, 10 years ago, when the parties could not agree on a way to fix schools and the only bipartisan solution possible was to issue grades for the schools. That little "market transparency" started a whole avalanche of changes most of which came as a surprise and all of which have moved Florida ahead ever since. It performs dramatically better now, than it did 10 years ago in almost all assessments (minorities, drop-out rate, avg. Math/Science). I think giving people a choice by posting transparent pricing information is crucial to improving the American health care situation.
Re:Profit affects doctors' treatment decisions by jellicle on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @10:32PM (#6639074)
A few years ago, I had an agonizing emergent medical condition, for which I headed to the emergency room, and ended up having surgery later that evening.

Of course, the cost to me was $0, since I live in Canada and we do it right here. But supposing I lived in your "transparent pricing information" ideal society. How exactly do you suppose I would flip through the ten-thousand page pricing book to determine what brand of surgical gauze I'd like to have used in my surgery, when I'm in 11/10 pain and going to die within a few hours if left untreated?

And do you think the other local hospitals would send over their ten-thousand pricing books as well, so I can price-shop? Do you think Dr. Smithers is really worth a 12% price premium over Dr. Johnson, or not?

Can you really have a meeting of minds when one of the minds is unconscious from an automobile accident? Please advise.

Re:Profit affects doctors' treatment decisions by novalis78 on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @12:45AM (#6639554)
Fair point, but I am not saying a transparently priced system could be established over night nor would its benefits be felt right away by everyone in every situation. However under the assumption that you succeed setting up such a system, price competition and public reviews would continuously lower prices to attract more business whose success function would have to be truly happy patients expressing their health benefits publicly. This would force rapid medical progress and medical innovation such that a future you in this scenario could easily cover said surgery with your catastrophic insurance at the fraction of today's cost and probably with better quality care - because it will be in the clinics/doctors self serving interest to offer you the best possible care for the lowest price ... And in many cases this could just be a side product of a fast paced procedural and technical progress driven by transparency in price/quality which might lead to X-rays actually becoming cheaper or free and not more expansive then when they were invented which seems to be the current models trajectory - amu ing if it was not so sad.
Re:Profit affects doctors' treatment decisions by novalis78 on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @06:20PM (#6637917)
...and btw, to anyone here who is a ruby or php developer and feels very strongly about this topic and likes to help with our project that is trying to change this (pricepain.com/why) shoot me an email, we can need some help.
Re:Profit affects doctors' treatment decisions by derefr on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @04:46PM (#6637303)
> definitionally, your health is worth an infinite amount of money to you (how much would you pay not to be a slave? how much would you pay not to have your hands and feet chopped off?).

That is not how you measure preferences, at all. Try "what likelihood of having your hands and feet chopped off would you trade for not being a slave?" Probabilities are fungible in a way dollars aren't.

Re:Profit affects doctors' treatment decisions by michaelt on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @09:20PM (#6638815)
It depends on what part of healthcare you're thinking of, and what stage of the process you're at.

If you're wheeled into ER with a knife in your chest, you don't have a fungible probability of needing healthcare. You're going to be buying the knife-removal service whether it costs $100 or $100,000. You may be unconscious.

Obviously at the other extreme of choice is purely elective surgery, like breast enhancement. Lots of choice there - if you don't like one doctor's prices you can shop around or skip the surgery all together.

In between are situations where treatment is required but isn't urgent, or where the problem is minor and you can live with it/use off the shelf treatments, or where there are various types of surgery available. A lot of the time when there are multiple options with complicated trade-offs, that's exactly where it would be nice to have a friendly, trustworthy doctor who can give you some unbiased guidance.

How exactly to bring all the incentives into alignment and make them fair, over the entire continuum of choice and accepting that the people who need the healthcare aren't themselves experts - that's the hard part.

Re:Profit affects doctors' treatment decisions by Zak on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @07:17PM (#6638232)
your health is worth an infinite amount of money to you

No, it isn't. Avoiding certain very undesirable outcomes is worth an infinite amount of money to me, but suffering from strep throat symptoms for 3 days instead of 5 days is worth a finite amount of money. My upper bound on that is hundreds of dollars, but if I can pay less to get the result I want (if I'm certain I have strep, I want a course of amoxicillin, and I don't care if that involves seeing a doctor), I will pay less. Competition can drive the price down even if the buyer isn't price-sensitive.

Re:Profit affects doctors' treatment decisions by WalterBright on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @11:08PM (#6639210)
> has never been observed in real life

Frontline did a whole show on that, "Dollars and Dentists".

http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/dollars-and-dentists...

Frontline isn't known for having a conservative bias.

Re:Profit affects doctors' treatment decisions by thaumasiotes on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @02:45AM (#6639919)
Your opinion predicts the following:

- No person would ever sell themselves into slavery (OK, this is only implied).

- No person would ever kill themselves for the life insurance.

Do you see any problems with that?

Allow me to suggest that if your health is worth an infinite amount of money to you, you must have terrible relationships with your family.