Obviously, this works best the more people who pay in. When people don't get insurance until they need it, it raises the cost for everyone. When people don't get insurance and still end up burdening those who did (by going bankrupt when faced with monstrous E.R. bills, for a common example), costs go up for everyone. In these situations, there's only way to make the system work: enforce that everyone buys in. That's why I support single-payer.
Here's another car analogy: car insurance is mandatory for drivers in the U.S., and most countries. Because the system only works when everyone buys in.
Of course it offends the libertarian sensibility to force people to buy something. How barbaric! Personally, I'm a libertarian-to-leftist convert. I think society needs a monopoly on force, and that monopoly goes to the government. The use of that force should be minimized, but one of reasons we need it is to force people to chip in for the common good. When it comes to pooled risk for catastrophic events, it's worth it. I have no moral qualms. It's not a matter of who's doing the planning, it's a matter of societal choices that just plain don't work if not everyone's on board. You're right that central planning is not voluntary. That's the whole point.
> But outside of "character" or other intangibles, there's no incentive to avoid the safety nets—in fact there's every incentive to use them, lest you be a sucker. Only suckers pay for things.
"Yeah, look at all those suckers, paying for things, how stupid. Why bother trying to make more money? It's not like I value character-building." - single mom making $12,000/year, and (gasp) receiving government assistance
Do you really think government assistance makes poverty appealing?
Conjecture. Got proof? (let's say, a statistical analysis between the recent spate of doctors who no longer accept insurance -- only cold hard cash or credit -- and their Swedish counterparts in both patient care and malpractice suite rate)
That's the thing about this entire argument. We're point at those other folks that seem to be a doing a lot better job at this whole keeping people healthy thing than we are. And you're pointing at this conjecture that maybe people make rational decisions in a market.
And we know that's not true.
Just look at homeopathic medicine to see how well the free market does, without FDA intervention, at keeping people healthy - and getting them healthy if they aren't.
I would agree that in a more ideal world, we could have free market health care. With enough technological progress, it might be possible to get accurate diagnoses of illnesses just by using an iphone app and then go to a pharmacy (or get drone delivery) to get a prescription for a cheap nano surgery pillbot. But we are way too far away from that, and there are way too many human lives on the line. I think it's okay to be militantly idealistic, but when human lives are at stake, I think it is necessary to cede to practicality.
I do think various products and services should be reviewed but there are better ways to do it than with a federal agency. E.g., https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_ioniser#Consumer_Reports_c...
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dietary_Supplement_Health_And_E... [2] http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/dshea-a-travesty-of-a-mo...
With the amount of error we have (see malpractice suits) as it is, I'm not convinced that what we have right now is actually yielding better overall results than a free market would with actual price signals.
Reason being that medical care quality is usually not a binary matter—with outcomes of either total success or total failure. Usually it's a broad continuum, and yet mediocre doctors are presently extremely difficult to differentiate from superb doctors because of the lack of price signals.
Malpractice suits would still exist in a free market, of course. And if care lead to death, there would be lawsuits. But in a majority of cases, bad care would lead to non-death but non-ideal resolution. That's where price signals will flourish.
Ironically, I see the current situation as an all-or-nothing where I want more nuance. We currently treat all doctors as essentially similar because they have all completed the same rigorous training and certification process, and we few other measures to use. (Some above-market review systems notwithstanding.)
Finally, don't be certain that doing away with regulation would lead to certifications evaporating. It more likely would mean variation in certification. A less politically-entrenched alternative to the AMA perhaps. (Of course, I'm also not necessarily bowled over by certification. I put no stock in computer programming certifications.)
> And of course the typical libertarian response is "tough luck" or "work harder".
While true, this shouldn't be dismissed cavalierly. We tend to speak without as much political thought as the right and left—saying apparently heartless things like "work harder." But what we mean in practice is that there would be more emphatic pressure on individuals to work to solve their own life situations first and only in extreme cases leverage safety nets.
We have a situation today where half of the country uses some form of government assistance. That's not what safety nets should be for. But outside of "character" or other intangibles, there's no incentive to avoid the safety nets—in fact there's every incentive to use them, lest you be a sucker. Only suckers pay for things.
When I had an electric car, I momentarily reeled at the $5,000 federal government incentive because it goes against my every belief. But, come on. Who is going to pass on such a sweet kick-back? I took the money. We all do.
Yes, it's utterly impossible for a libertarian paradise to provide a 50% safety net. But we feel we have such a large safety net because it's a venus fly trap, not because it is necessary to have a 50% safety net as a first principle.
Furthermore, many libertarians are amenable to a basic income, and with a basic income and a free market for health care and health insurance, it's almost a foregone conclusion that a great deal of competition would angle for that demand.
> Compromise shouldn't be such a dirty word in today's political discussions, it's a sad state of affairs
The trouble with compromise is what I said earlier. We're willing to allow central planners to build within a free market, to create a voluntary consortium of participants supporting one another through centrally-planned distribution of resources. But reverse the tables and we're absolutely never permitted the same freedom. Central-planning is not voluntary; it a piece of totalitarianism.
So compromising with central planners means totally conceding. Either they plan for you or you plan for you. I prefer planning for me, difficulties and all.