In fact, I think that was the biggest flaw in the business. "Goths" in general had no problem spending $200 on a new black dress from the vendor next to us, but balked at a $45 gift arrangement with etched goblets and candle holders. Expensive gifts are their own niche, and really need to be more general-purpose. $10-15 really was the sweet spot for a gift, but the quality would have suffered.
Another issue was payment processing. Our margins were thinner than we were comfortable with, so we didn't want the added expense of a proper merchant account & something like authorize.net. There wasn't anything like Square yet, so we used Paypal Checkout. Our analytics showed something like a quarter of checkouts were abandoned at the point where we redirected to Paypal.
My goal was to grow this into the "CafePress of gifting" where people could build their own gift arrangements from a selection of general & niche items: balloons, teddy bears, whips & chains...a bunch of things to choose from. And then they could sell their creations in their own branded store for a percentage of the price. I should have accelerated that plan, but it might have required outside funding which I wasn't ready for.
We over-estimated the appeal of "goth" in the mid-2000s. There was still a good turnout at goth events in Chicago, but it was mostly adults who liked to dress up on the weekends for old-time's sake, but didn't identify as goths in everyday life anymore. We paid for tables at concerts, hearse shows, and fan conventions, and usually didn't make enough to cover the table. At least the music was good. At one point we pulled up the Seattle Goth site hoping to do a sponsorship deal with them, and their home page was just a picture of Fonzie on waterskis.
There was still a decent-sized market of younger goths & "emos", but they didn't have the money for a $25 gift basket of jewelry, incense, candles, and such…and THEN shipping on top of that. We were told to offer something closer to $10 shipped, but that barely covered the cost of an empty basket, shipping materials, and postage with a tiny profit.
Twilight was pretty big, but our vampires didn't sparkle. We put together a Browncoat basket with a complete set of Firefly action figures and assorted other stuff…even had custom marketing materials made to distribute at fan conventions for it. Didn't sell a single one.
Magazine advertising was expensive, and resulted in zero orders. Emailing our customer list a 20% discount code every couple months resulted in 2 orders in three years. We were flooded with emails from events & meetups wanting us to donate baskets for raffle prizes, which we could at least write-off on our taxes & get some publicity for. No sales ever came of these sponsorship deals, but we did get some sweet thank-you letters.
The last year we were in business, we were hit with a $200 chargeback. We asked Paypal if they could validate the address or something on that big of an order, and they said there was nothing they could do. We took the risk, and lost the money, merchandise, and shipping. That one incident cancelled out our entire profit for the year.
We donated all the remaining merchandise to charity & took a write-off just so we could get our spare bedroom back (it became my "man cave"/computer museum). Our time is better spent volunteering if we're not going to make any money anyway.
Again, no huge crisis, no health problems. But, a lot of extra stress, a couple thousand bucks wasted on top of what we paid for the company, and an entire room our our house tied up for 3 years and nothing to show for it.
Edit: Oh yeah, let's not forget the month I got a bill from my hosting company for extra bandwidth because a picture of me from the site ranked high for "goth" in Google Images and people were hot-linking it in forum posts all over the place going "goths are so stupid. look at this guy he thinks he's spooky ooooh".