Re:Android isn't freedom, because Google is closed
by AndrewDucker on Sunday October 27, 2013 @01:17PM
(#6622586)
Google offer the Google Platform to people who agree to certain things. But anyone is free to fork Android at any point, if they choose - Amazon have done so, for instance, as well as many Chinese manufacturers.
Re:Android isn't freedom, because Google is closed
by ronnier on Sunday October 27, 2013 @03:00PM
(#6622999)
Seems like Android really gave Chinese and Korean companies a lifeline in the mobile phone market. Those phones either wouldn't exist or would be running the windows phone software I assume. Chinese and Korean companies benefit from Android. Blackberry and Microsoft are losing as a result.
Re:Android isn't freedom, because Google is closed
by kevinh on Sunday October 27, 2013 @02:24PM
(#6622844)
They're free to fork the segment of android that google hasn't locked into their own closed-source ecosystem.
Many AOSP applications have been abandoned by google in favor of their proprietary applications.
Re:Android isn't freedom, because Google is closed
by fidotron on Sunday October 27, 2013 @03:12PM
(#6623045)
And the reasoning is most of those apps (for better or worse) depend on Google's cloud services, so it makes no sense for them to be in AOSP.
There remains nothing stopping you replacing all the Google stuff on Android, including the very parts that make them money.
One of the sadder, non obvious, parts of the way mobile has developed is it is becoming synonymous with trivial front ends to cloud services, and not really smart client apps at all.
Re:Android isn't freedom, because Google is closed
by Ambrosia on Sunday October 27, 2013 @02:33PM
(#6622885)
Not anyone -- if someone like Samsung decides to fork Android, people using their devices will suddenly find that their Google apps won't work anymore.
Re:Android isn't freedom, because Google is closed
by the_mitsuhiko on Sunday October 27, 2013 @02:38PM
(#6622906)
That's an argument against Open Source :(
Re:Android isn't freedom, because Google is closed
by sp332 on Sunday October 27, 2013 @02:44PM
(#6622933)
I think you misunderstand. Google's individual apps (like GMail) are closed-source, and only licensed for use on "official" Android builds.
Re:Android isn't freedom, because Google is closed
by ddebernardy on Sunday October 27, 2013 @02:42PM
(#6622923)
Err... Which Google apps are open source? Or maybe I'm just not getting the objection.
Re:Android isn't freedom, because Google is closed
by aviraldg on Sunday October 27, 2013 @04:26PM
(#6623410)
Replace "full Android ecosystem" with "Google services" to see why your point doesn't make sense. (and that's what they are)
Re:Android isn't freedom, because Google is closed
by devx on Sunday October 27, 2013 @04:16PM
(#6623367)
What do you mean too much freedom? From the user's and even developer's perspective, it's better for Android to be more like Windows (pre-Windows 8), than more like Linux (tons of different distros/forks).
While Android remains free for anyone to use as they would like, only Android compatible devices benefit from the full Android ecosystem. By joining the Open Handset Alliance, each member contributes to and builds one Android platform—not a bunch of incompatible versions
source : http://officialandroid.blogspot.com/2012/09/the-benefits-imp...