Re:And then the machines came for the doctors
by jared314 on Saturday October 26, 2013 @08:26PM
(#6620105)
While I think IBM Watson will become a powerful tool for querying and hospital/insurance risk management, I'm not sure it will be replacing a doctor until MRI machines are a dime a dozen. What good is a medical query engine if the patient doesn't know how to describe what is wrong? If you are planning your child's career, take this into account; otherwise, it is just something new for the doctors to learn, like engineers learning CAD tools.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:And then the machines came for the doctors
by PeterisP on Saturday October 26, 2013 @08:38PM
(#6620154)
How big is a market for an expensive senior oncologist, if a doctor with twice shorter training (and half the school debt) can give the same results (by using the same Watson) while competing on price and friendliness?
Re:And then the machines came for the doctors
by cowsandmilk on Saturday October 26, 2013 @09:26PM
(#6620353)
the increased emphasis on bed side manner at many of the top med schools indicates they agree with you.
Re:And then the machines came for the doctors
by julespitt on Saturday October 26, 2013 @08:32PM
(#6620130)
I've seem papers before where machine learning was able to compensate for both inaccuracy of measurement and outright falsehoods being reported, and overall was far more reliable than humans.
Full Disclosure: I just read a paper saying that only 10% of doctors are capable of bayesian reasoning, so I'm in a mood to pick on doctors today. I'll stop now.
Re:And then the machines came for the doctors
by hershel on Saturday October 26, 2013 @09:37PM
(#6620400)
Mind linking the paper?
Re:And then the machines came for the doctors
by TinyBig on Saturday October 26, 2013 @08:48PM
(#6620200)
"What good is a medical query engine if the patient doesn't know how to describe what is wrong?"
This implementation of Watson is more than a query engine; it returns a confidence interval with its diagnoses and "knows" which questions to ask to improve the confidence level in those diagnoses.
Re:And then the machines came for the doctors
by hershel on Saturday October 26, 2013 @09:40PM
(#6620411)
Research on automated patient interview systems reveals two facts:
1. Doctors on average miss 50% of questions needed to be asked on a medical interview.
2. In general , people are less likely to lie to a machine, when they would lie to their doctors if dealing with some socially sensitive issues.