Justifying intellectual property through the analogy of physical property is flawed, as they are inherently different beasts.
That said, your core argument is entirely spot-on - our economic framework that is accepted in policy circles doesn't see the economic value of letting copyright expire. I'd also suggest that policymakers are rarely (if ever) dispassionate and unbiased; at the end of the day, their view of the world is closely aligned with the view of those who keep them in office through campaign contributions and whatnot. It doesn't even have to be as explicit as bribery - simply the fact that Congressmen (out of necessity) run in circles with wealthy people who have an interest in preventing the expiration of copyright is enough to color their opinions and views in favor of that particular position, even if they never knowingly accept a bribe.
The reason is a fundamental tradeoff -- we've accepted a bargain to deny ourselves some fundamental property rights temporarily under the theory that, in the long run, we'll get more innovation and content and further the "progress of science and useful arts", as the US constitution puts it.
If we're not making that progress, then it no longer becomes a tradeoff, and the laws are simply breaking property rights for no reason.
So, yes, if you care at all about property rights there's a very good reason to believe in limiting copyrights.
Like all property rights, copyright is a socially constructed privilege to exclude others from certain actions, and, like all property rights, every copyright interest limits everyone else's freedom, including the freedom to derive utility from their property.
This is a very real tradeoff with copyright, but it is exactly the same kind of tradeoff that exists with all property rights, not something special to copyright vs. other property rights.
I ask because the general statement of "use my ... however I wish" is obviously way too broad; I can't use my computer to commit fraud, or my printer to print dollars. More generally, I would say the distilled basic property right is to use my property in a way that does not violate anyone else's rights or break any laws.
The most basic property right is the right to exclude others from the use of your property, and in that sense, if we accept that "intellectual property" is property, then it seems to apply there too.
I don't think I'm the only one in this thread who saw rayiner's comment and felt instinctive disgust followed by grudging admiration -- the idea there is really messing with my while framework for thinking about copyrights.
Uhm, no. Like many of rayiners "arguments" it's authoritative rhetorical bullshit. He frames the question, makes some assertions that aren't backed up and leaves the burden of proof on the reader. If you look closely you'll find he's not even taking much of a position on the subject. So even if you manages to disapprove what he's claiming you'll end up in a discussion you can't win since he's the one making up the rules as you go along. Actually this is quite similar to how copyright keeps getting extended.
It's not just property rights that copyrights interfere with, of course, there are also other basic fundamental rights being diminished. Freedom of speech is an obvious example.
This isn't an argument against all copyright. It's merely pointing out that there's a tradeoff, and every now and again we should ask "is it worth it?"
Also, I'm confused why this is an "economic value" issue. I was under the impression copyright existed solely for the benefit of the public, "to promote the sciences and useful arts" as I read.
You've got more insight than I do, so further elaboration would be greatly appreciated.
The purpose of "intellectual property" protection is a valid point, though. I think that the greatest victory of the pro-"intellectual property" is simply calling it "intellectual property", thereby tainting it with thousands of years of philosophy of what "property" is.
The point of copyright is to encourage the creation of new works (called content these days). If Disney can just keep making money off Mickey Mouse forever and use that money to crowd newer ideas out of the market, I would argue that we're significantly poorer as a society than if new and original creations were being made.
DJs should be free to remix pop songs as they like and everything is gravy, but if a DJ dares remix another DJ's work then suddenly we are a poorer society? Absurd.
I have no idea how your second paragraph relates to my comment.
What? I have absolutely no idea what this is suppose to mean and/or refer to.
The second section of my comment is pointing out that Disney remixes, yet you seem to think remixing Disney would be a symptom of some sort of awful state of society. If remixing evidences that, then why do we need further evidence of it? Remixing Disney media would just be continuing in the same vein as Disney.
Disney can't even exist without remixing earlier works.
It's nice that children and hobbyists can read and perform Twelfth Night without paying gratuitous royalties to a company that is now completely unrelated to the long-dead William Shakespeare. It would be nice if, in 3013, children and hobbyists could read and perform The Lady's Not For Burning without paying royalties to a company that is by then completely unrelated to Christopher Fry.
Also, real/personal and intellectual property differ enough that I don't think the analogy from your second paragraph is particularly instructive. For example, with physical property I can't think of any obvious analogs to remixes and derived works.
But they probably wouldn't be less motivated by longer expirations.
Sure they would be: properties that are valuable more than a handful of years after they are first published are rare enough that the chance of achieving that is a minor factor in motivation, but the existence of such properties under extended protection both reduces the potential for and reduces the market value of new works, reducing the motivation for new creators more than the slight chance of producing such a work increases it.
If expirations were shorter, say 20 or 30 years after the publication of a work, wouldn't creators be motivated to keep creating so as to not suddenly lose a stream of income?
Disney would have had far less material to lift.
Adverse possession, right of conquest, property taxes, and estate taxes are a few of the ways in which physical property rights expire.
Expressing the value of allowing intellectual property rights to expire does not require arguing that physical property rights ought to expire.
Isn't the scope and intrusion worth considering?
(I ignored the part on economic theory because first of all 1) you're likely wrong on your assumptions 2) none of it is applicable to lawmakers as they exist today, they are not science-, but ideology-driven)
You seem to be confusing trademarks and copyright. Disney characters are in fact protected in perpetuity as long as Disney continues to use them commercially.
The copyright question is the question of whether Disney can keep control over specific works like Steamboat Willie, or whether they will start to enter the public domain.
> the economic framework that's well-accepted in policy circles has no way to express the value of letting copyright expire
Nonsense. The definition of copyright is a legal monopoly on the production of copies of a work. It has long been understood by economists that monopolies legal or not, incentives rent-seeking and disrupt a markets natural trend towards natural prices.
No, but real (dirt) property rights are usually taxed. How about an escalating tax on older copyrights?
All kinds of physical property rights do expire -- leasehold interests, life estates, etc., are, after all, property rights -- though most common subjects of physical property have some person somewhere holding a "root" set of property rights which are held in fee simple and thus do not expire in the most simplistic sense (though many items of physical property have ad valorem taxes assessed on their value, which is essentially a means of property rights gradually expiring; this is particularly common with real property.)
The reason fee simple ownership as the general norm is the case is largely that the capitalist class, as it was developing and feudalism was declining, amassed sufficient resources and influence to direct government to further enhance the capitalist class's ability to continue to amass resources and influence by reforming property to favor that situation.
This is what happens when you confuse objects in the physical world with those in the information world.
Physical rights don't expire because it entails deprivation of use. But copyright expiration doesn't eliminate your right to create, distribute, or sell -- it simply extends these capabilities to others.
but even assuming that it does, it only works when there's a huge empire providing thousands of jobs themed around a work, right? so how do you codify the difference between Mickey and $random_forgotten_book_from_1920, from which releasing copyright could only be a good thing for the economy?
This is wholly wrong. There are entire classes of good where marginal consumption does not dilute the value of average consumption. The purpose of copyrights is to subsidize (temporarily) the production of such goods. This under the theory that they would not otherwise be (or only inefficiently) be produced. Certainly mickey mouse needs no further encouragement...extending DIS an ongoing franchise is pure and simple pork-barrel-politics to the governing class that relies on the media (eg, ABC a DIS subsidiary) to get elected (and/or the electoral votes of Florida).
Plus, if you then again allow others to build on the more recently "invented" stuff, then you get even more ideas and creations, as a society, which is why there's this "agreement" that copyright works should go into public domain. But corporations, who don't invent anything themselves, want to be able to exploit those works forever.
This is why I support Sweden's Pirate Party's idea [1] to limit copyright to 5 years, and then allow creators to extend it every 5 years up to 20 years, for a fee each time, because then you wouldn't end up with problems like these, where the vast majority of works become abandonware that nobody can use for almost a century to at least remix them:
http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2013/07/the-ho...
Watch these videos, and then hopefully it will make it more clear:
Why give someone else a crack at it? There are a lot of excellent reasons, here's two: 1) Because competition is always a good thing in the private sector. It has been demonstrated constantly throughout free market economic history that competition generates greater innovation, as opposed to the lack of competition. 2) It's a massive net benefit to a nation's culture to have copyrights expire such that the public can own its history (and individuals can then do with it as they please), of which characters such as Mickey Mouse are a part.
On the other hand, I completely agree we should own our history. For example, the purported owners of "Happy Birthday" are pure rentiers. They have no brand to protect and add no economic value. The copyright on that song should have expired long ago.
I think a good compromise is "use it or lose it." A copyright expires after some period of disuse by the holder. At that point it can be said to have passed into history, and is owned by everyone.
Let me put it another way. Why don't physical property rights expire? The argument of: "well then other people could use them!" doesn't fly, because the same thing applies to physical property. So long as Disney keeps making use of Mickey Mouse, what economic reason is there to give someone else a crack at the character? Would it create more economic value? What economic theory tells us that?
You can talk about "bribery" all you want, but at base there is a theoretical problem. The accepted belief is that there are no downsides to protecting property rights, and there is no way to express the value of allowing property rights to expire without sounding like a crunchy hippie.