Re:Black Girls Code launching in Miami
by sp332 on Friday October 25, 2013 @04:09PM
(#6614208)
Condescending maybe but GP has a point. If racism is already a big deal, ignoring it isn't going to help. Explicitly addressing it and helping out the less-privileged group will.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Doesn't really address the point at all. Maybe racism is best solved by treating all as equals instead of creating further insular groups? It does seem logically absurd on its face.
The first step is to stop snarking at people who dare to ask.
> Maybe racism is best solved by treating all as equals instead of creating further insular groups?
Straw man argument, your 'creating further insular groups' representation of the original idea is not at all obviously equivalent, and you make no effort to support the representation.
> The first step is to stop snarking at people who dare to ask.
It's really not.
It's not "further insular". It's a group that already exists. Treating people as all equal is fine. Pretending that all people are treated as equal in society is not helpful.
I'd argue that perpetuating the problem of people being treated different in society is even worse.
But middle-class white men are disproportionately encouraged to be programmers. As the article points out: "There were very few women and nobody of color. I found that puzzling since the startup industry was obviously booming." So to be fair, we should either stop encouraging them, or start encouraging people who are outside that group.
Seems to be it would be more productive to try to encourage more than a minority of a minority, as it were. Female programmers are already rare, blacks more so just by statistics. What about other races? Hispanic women are out of luck? Asian? Native?