News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by jrockway on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @08:21AM (#6591295)
Why not just pick a VID and start using it? USB is so well understood at this point that there is no need for anyone to play ball with an "official" organization.

(Whoever gets "officially" issued that VID is going to whine when they notice it's already being used for hobbyist purposes anyway, which means that the technique of just picking one will guarantee uniqueness.)

Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by eksith on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @08:31AM (#6591363)
I like this idea. If there's some benefactor to the Open Source community (or even if they pass along a collection) for the VID, that could even work. They just need to properly implement the standard and the VID can effectively be the Hoover or Kleenex of VIDs.

Edit: On second thought (after I actually read it), this bit...

  Please immediately cease and desist raising funds to purchase a 
  unique USB VID for the purpose of transferring, reselling or 
  sublicensing PIDs and delete all references to the USB-IF, VIDs and 
  PIDs for transfer, resale or sublicense from your website and other 
  marketing materials.
...rubs me the wrong way on so many levels, I'm tempted to say, the hell with the forum.
Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by buro9 on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @08:51AM (#6591460)
That cease and desist request ticks the boxes for "You are committing a thought crime and are not permitted to have these ideas".

Which explains why we (especially) react so strongly to it.

Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by Someone on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @02:10PM (#6593774)
An argument I would make if I we t to court fighting that is that such squatting dilutes the 'USB' brand.

Imagine a world where this 'open' approach gains market share. For the consumer, the net result easily could be that USB, which now is highly plug and play, becomes more like the way ISA cards used to be plug and play: you can plug in any device, but to make it work, you need to do some voodoo (oops, there's more than one device with that PID/VID. Please tell me what you plugged in: X, Y, Z, or something I haven't heard of?")

Exaggeration? Yes, but not completely untrue, and that's the argument I would make.

Whatever you do, you need some entity that prevents multiple manufacturers from using clashing identifiers. That is one of the things the owners of the standard will fight for to maintain, because it is one of the things required to make USB work as well as it does.

Yes, it would be nice if they sold individual VID/PID pairs to hobbyists. But I do not see a legal reason why they would have to do so. Anti-competitive? Maybe, but they will argue that there are thousands of individual vendors in the market.

Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by mdwrigh2 on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @08:30PM (#6595973)
> Imagine a world where this 'open' approach gains market share. For the consumer, the net result easily could be that USB, which now is highly plug and play, becomes more like the way ISA cards used to be plug and play: you can plug in any device, but to make it work, you need to do some voodoo (oops, there's more than one device with that PID/VID. Please tell me what you plugged in: X, Y, Z, or something I haven't heard of?")

For the record, this already is pretty common. Lots of keyboards mimic Apple's VID/PID, and tons of controllers use absolutely nonsense VIDs/PIDs (GameStop's mobile controller line, for example).

Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by caf on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @06:52PM (#6595540)
The fact that it's so important to prevent multiple manufacturers from using clashing IDs is exactly why it's in their interest to make registering an "official" ID as open and accessible as possible.
Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by alcari on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @08:46AM (#6591429)
Read the article again. That's not the Forum, that's the VTM Group, which handles their marketing and legal concerns. The USB Implementers Forum itself didn't make a statement.
Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by eksith on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @09:01AM (#6591523)

  This idea did not sit well with VTM Group, the people serving as the 
  management, PR, legal, and membership and licensing department of the 
  USB Implementers Forum
The hands, the mouth and collector of thoughts cannot be separated from a thing and still be called a whole. Besides even the title says, "USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source"
Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by derefr on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @09:52PM (#6596253)
> The hands, the mouth and collector of thoughts cannot be separated from a thing and still be called a whole.

I don't know about that. Publishing houses are certainly separate from authors, and record labels from musicians.

Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by ryanthejuggler on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @10:31AM (#6592128)
The article is a second-hand source; the author could be trying to stir something up, or maybe just got a bit too excited. Who knows? The article also says the proposal, among others, "haven’t hit the desk of anyone at the USB Implementers Forum, the people who are actually in charge of designating USB VIDs and PIDs". Doesn't sound like the forum said no to me.
Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by PhasmaFelis on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @04:35PM (#6594776)
What is with this bizarre argument that paid legal representation doesn't legally represent their client? By definition, unless the USB Forum directs the VTM Group to retract the C&D, it represents the Forum's position.
Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by weland on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @01:40PM (#6593497)
As far as I can understand, as with every organization in the world, when the-entity-that-represents-the-marketing-and-legal-concerns of that organization writes a cease and desist, it kind of comes from that organization. The USB IF itself didn't make a statement because they don't make statements on these matters; that's why they hired VTM Group for.

Don't underestimate the USB Implementers Forum. Despite its name, it is not an organization of USB users (big and small). They have a direct interest in this matter because:

a) Like every organization, they need to have some source of income. Technically, they're a non-profit organization, but they're also the one who issue the VID, and a company giving out PIDs to whoever wants them is eating their "lack of profit".

b) Its members who have an interest in consumer devices/end products (i.e. companies that don't sell chips, but devices using chips) tend to be large and slow-moving. The Kickstarter crowd is pecking at their business options. (True story).

Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by nicksdjohnson on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @10:09AM (#6591955)
It's signed "Executive Director"; regardless of their internal organisation, it's a statement from USB-IF.
Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by PhasmaFelis on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @03:30PM (#6594276)
That's a ridiculous distinction. If you hire someone to represent you, you are responsible for their words and actions on your behalf.
Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by spiritplumber on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @10:53AM (#6592274)
"We will be willing to settle the matter with a trial by combat."
Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by samworm on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @08:36AM (#6591384)
The way these things normally work is that you're only allowed to use the name and marks if you're an official licensee.

So if you put the USB logo on your marketing and claim to have a "USB Mini" connector in your specifications then you could be in trouble on two fronts: (1) the usb folks can sue you for using their IP and (2) purchasers can claim the product is not "as described" which may given them certain rights dependent upon the location.

Not using the official logo shouldn't be a problem in hobby market. Everyone will recognise the connector. Not being allowed to identify it as USB2 or USB3 or whatever, that could be a problem. I'm sure there are creative ways around it though.

Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by kefka on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @08:41AM (#6591406)
One should be able to say "Compatible with USB2", in the similar way 3rd party companies made cartridges for the Nintendo.

And about squatting on a VID.. Well, they should have thought about pollution of their namespace on their anti-hobbiest policies. They frankly deserve it.

Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by usea on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @04:11PM (#6594593)
> One should be able to say "Compatible with USB2", in the similar way 3rd party companies made cartridges for the Nintendo.

The most prolific of those 3rd party companies was sued by Nintendo and lost.[1][2] Although that case is not directly applicable, and had different circumstances. I thought it was worth mentioning.

[1] http://digital-law-online.info/cases/24PQ2D1015.htm

[2] http://www.1up.com/do/feature?pager.offset=1&cId=3146206

Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by brudgers on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @09:40AM (#6591768)
At this point, I doubt that certification matters for many applications, particularly in the consumer sector.

"Connects to your computer at speeds up to five gigabits per second using industry standard USB cable," probably covers everything short of a the edge cases such as government procurement contracts.

Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by joshvm on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @07:36PM (#6595750)
It doesn't matter at all for the hobbyist sector. If you can afford to push a paid-for consumer product, you can probably afford the license.

V-USB for AVR gives you 2 VID/PID pairs for 500 Euro. http://www.obdev.at/products/vusb/license.html

There's also a 10EUR hobby package which gives you a pair for personal use only.

FUP applies, but if you're breaking it then really you should go legit and pay the USB feds their protection money.

How are these guys getting round it?

Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by Pxtl on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @10:16AM (#6592018)
Considering how many cheap Chinese knock-offs out there seem to go unpunished, I don't think the USB folks are really successful at enforcement.
Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by JonFish85 on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @11:59AM (#6592770)
Anecdote: apparently going after Chinese knock-off companies is a gigantic PITA. I've worked with those who have tried going after them. File a complaint about company ACBD. A week later, company ABCD never existed, but company XYZ is operating at the same factory. Amazing!
Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by weland on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @01:56PM (#6593644)
I can wholeheartedly confirm this. The cheap Chinese knock-off companies are basically beyond the reach of Western law.
Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by mildtrepidation on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @11:41AM (#6592616)
Which could be said about so many such knockoffs; however, the issue of Chinese and other non-US counterfeiting is harder precisely because they're non-US, and operating in manners and areas where the legal system is not prone to caring about US regulations (for better or worse).

So whether you can safely ignore this depends largely on how easy it is for this body to successfully throw the book at you, and others' success in this area doesn't really mean anything unless you're able to operate in the same circumstances, which I doubt most of us are.

Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by derefr on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @09:54PM (#6596263)
So... the FOSS hardware guys should operate Chinese manufacturing shell companies?
Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by Fuxy on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @09:02AM (#6591526)
Let's just call it ThatThing2 and ThatThing3 in the hobby community :P
Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by wheremiah on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @11:45AM (#6592643)
How about BSU? It could stand for a lot of things... but I like Bull Sh!t USB. Which I think is an appropriate eye-poke response to an annoying organization.
Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by Amadou on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @06:11PM (#6595349)
Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by kabouseng on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @09:04AM (#6591538)
As far as I remember, only the logo is trademarked, not the phrase USB. So you could still state your product has USB, you just can't display the logo anywhere.
Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @05:37PM (#6595167)
Then market it. SUSB - SuperUSB. Who wouldn't buy something that's the-same-but-Super?
Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by nl on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @07:14PM (#6595656)
"YouSB"
Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by CatMtKing on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @06:35PM (#6595450)
Aka Sue-Us-B :P
Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by crististm on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @03:26PM (#6594245)
It's like if you want your CD to have the "compact disc- digital audio" label you have to comply with whatever colored book. People stopped caring about that long ago and won't care much for USB either as long as it works.
Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by gsnedders on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @09:21AM (#6591619)
"[...] using a connector included on all modern computers".
Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by gpvos on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @11:45AM (#6592648)
Call it BSU2 and BSU3.
Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by ZeroGravitas on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @08:35AM (#6591381)
They have:

"There are a number of ideas to get around VTM Group that include squatting on USB VID 0xF055"

Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by missing_cipher on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @12:50PM (#6593164)
For those who missed it, 0xF055 can be read as "FOSS": http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_and_open-source_software
Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by qwerty_asdf on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @11:41AM (#6592617)
Does anybody own these?

  0xDEAD
  0xBEEF
  0x1337
  0xFACE
  0xF00D
  0xABCD
...and so on?

Maybe, if they're reserved as unassignable (due to being an inappropriate value for professional, business puposes), then perhaps it's open season on those.

Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by Amadou on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @06:07PM (#6595326)
An alternative would be to find one that has been assigned to a now defunct company. Then you'd only have to worry about historical devices and if you are lucky you could come up with a list of those PIDs and exclude them.
Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by nraynaud on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @12:48PM (#6593154)
I think 0xF055 has circulated too much now (slashdot, hack a day, maker: etc.) So if we there should be squatting it better be on 0xF055. Let's just destroy the strict minimum to achieve our goal (having a unique VID+PID for our proprietary drivers to find the corresponding gadget on the bus).
Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by rtkwe on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @04:13PM (#6594614)
Looks like no: http://www.linux-usb.org/usb.ids

Though I'm not sure how accurate and complete this list is.

Edit the official list is here but they list their VIDs in dec.

Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by StavrosK on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @11:38AM (#6592594)
Hah, nice VID, easy to remember.
Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by bborud on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @03:14PM (#6594145)
You wouldn't even have to make use of the VID. If a sizeable group would just agree that "we're going to view this range as set aside for open source and start using it", no company would want to accept being assigned a VID in this range.
Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by nraynaud on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @09:49AM (#6591838)
I think there's still a problem because that leaves still only 255 PID.

Maybe we should just squat the VID, and then do a PID+(another field in the descriptor) as the discriminator for people who need special protocols (I do).

For now I've stolen my MCU maker VID and used 255 as PID, because I couldn't even find an "experimental" PID/VID in the spec to use during development.

It's a bug and urgent problem, I'm perfectly ok to fudge the rules, but we have to agree on something that doesn't break people's drivers.

Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by nitrogen on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @11:15AM (#6592436)
I know I saw 0xffff or something like that being used for development in some source code, but it turns out searching for "VID" is impossible because it gets interpreted as "video".
Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by pyre on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @09:30PM (#6596153)
Try searching this:

  development usb "vid" -video
First hit is someone asking about VID/PID in a motherboard forum.
Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by dylz on Wednesday October 23, 2013 @03:07AM (#6597346)
Search Tools > Verbatim
Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by nicksdjohnson on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @10:09AM (#6591959)
VIDs and PIDs are 16 bits, not 8.
Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by nraynaud on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @10:12AM (#6591981)
oops, my bad! But I don't think it's enough to go random on that. We need either a registry or more bits to go random.
Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by dkersten on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @05:02PM (#6594956)
When I was doing some development for some USB devices, I remember there was a VID/PID designated for development-only use. I can't remember what it was, however, and the company I was doing work for registered their own before the devices shipped.
Re:USB Implementers Forum Says No to Open Source by noselasd on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @01:41PM (#6593513)
Or (as long as it's an opensource project), just go get a PID for your gadget under the openmoko vid, http://wiki.openmoko.org/wiki/USB_Product_IDs