News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:CryptoSeal (YC S11) Shutting Down Private VPN by Beltiras on Monday October 21, 2013 @09:11AM (#6585221)
Come to Iceland. Law is on your side here and the infrastructure is coming along.
Re:CryptoSeal (YC S11) Shutting Down Private VPN by rdl on Monday October 21, 2013 @10:29AM (#6585752)
Iceland, Switzerland, New Zealand, Hong Kong, and a few other places do look really interesting (and Switzerland and Hong Kong have pretty good infrastructure). Investigating a few more as well.

One consideration, though, is that we're all US citizens, and so even if we set up a Hong Kong company with Hong Kong servers, we'd be at risk to US court orders or any civil/criminal action. So for US citizens, the only real solution is technical controls, or legal/legislative reforms in the US.

Re:CryptoSeal (YC S11) Shutting Down Private VPN by bandushrew on Monday October 21, 2013 @03:37PM (#6587719)
Im from NZ. NZ is not a good place to trust your private data.

The NZ government has no hesitation in breaking whatever laws it needs to in order to satisfy US requests.

Re:CryptoSeal (YC S11) Shutting Down Private VPN by hrrsn on Monday October 21, 2013 @04:12PM (#6587869)
See also: Kim Dotcom raids, GCSB amendment bill.
Re:CryptoSeal (YC S11) Shutting Down Private VPN by malandrew on Monday October 21, 2013 @05:11PM (#6588237)
How about having one employee in each of those jurisdictions and setting up a way so that nothing can be done such as deploys and code changes, etc. without one employee from each jurisdiction using their key together. There is no way that a government is going to be able to compel like four citizens from four different countries from complying if it is possible. A US admin could give up their key to the US government and it would still be useless if they can't get the an admin from Iceland, Switzerland, New Zealand and Hong Kong to also participate in the change. It would allow people to comply with the letter of the law to avoid comtempt of court since they gave up their key as asked.
Re:CryptoSeal (YC S11) Shutting Down Private VPN by harshreality on Monday October 21, 2013 @07:42PM (#6588925)
Wouldn't that require N principals, one for each jurisdiction, which is an unusual organizational structure, and requires a lot of trust and shared vision even if it's an n-of-m authorization system?
Re:CryptoSeal (YC S11) Shutting Down Private VPN by mcherm on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @08:28AM (#6591335)
Sort of. Just because N people from different countries and time zones each need to enter their password in order to make a production change doesn't mean that the organizational structure needs to follow that. For all we care, only the subteam that does production deployments would need to be set up this way.

They would, however, need highly trusted agents in several legal jurisdictions. Agents who they trusted with the ability to bring the company down. Still... I think I might pay for a service like that, if some of the principle participants were people I trusted so I was sure it wasn't a honeypot.

Re:CryptoSeal (YC S11) Shutting Down Private VPN by rdouglas on Monday October 21, 2013 @03:51PM (#6587788)
Don't forget The Bahamas, Ryan! :-)

If you need advice from experts at setting up a legal foreign business, LMK, and I'll send you a few referrals.

Re:CryptoSeal (YC S11) Shutting Down Private VPN by tobiasu on Monday October 21, 2013 @01:07PM (#6586798)
Switzerland is far from being innocent saints when it comes to surveillance:

The Swiss SIGINT equivalent is called PTSS: https://www.li.admin.ch/en/ptss/index.html https://www.li.admin.ch/en/ptss/legal.html https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swiss_intelligence_agencies

And don't get me started in HK, NZ or Iceland. If you really want to protect Osamas IRC server and worse with your VPN service, you require specific political protection from the host country.

Re:CryptoSeal (YC S11) Shutting Down Private VPN by Beltiras on Monday October 21, 2013 @02:20PM (#6587267)
Why would Iceland be a vulnerability?
Re:CryptoSeal (YC S11) Shutting Down Private VPN by tobiasu on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @06:47AM (#6590887)
They just recently cooperated with the FBI to bust Silk Road...
Re:CryptoSeal (YC S11) Shutting Down Private VPN by easytiger on Monday October 21, 2013 @11:25AM (#6586098)
> New Zealand

Are you kidding!?

Re:CryptoSeal (YC S11) Shutting Down Private VPN by gonzo on Monday October 21, 2013 @10:37AM (#6585819)
Do US citizens have to install pen registers on their own service(s)?
Re:CryptoSeal (YC S11) Shutting Down Private VPN by rdl on Monday October 21, 2013 @10:41AM (#6585859)
If so ordered by a court of competent jurisdiction.

Essentially from lavabit it appears if you don't have technical capabilities inside the service already in place to provide pen trap level realtime reporting, they can compel you to install a pen trap device, and provide all keying/etc. required to make it work.

Re:CryptoSeal (YC S11) Shutting Down Private VPN by gonzo on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @12:19AM (#6589769)
You're likely wrong.

On June 10, the federal government served a court order on Lavabit issued under 18 USC 2703(d), a 1994 amendment of the Stored Communications Act.

The Stored Communications Act (SCA, codified at 18 U.S.C. Chapter 121 §§ 2701–2712) is a law that addresses voluntary and compelled disclosure of "stored wire and electronic communications and transactional records" held by third-party internet service providers (ISPs). It was enacted as Title II of the Electronic Communications Privacy Act (ECPA, Pub.L. 99–508, 100 Stat. 1848, enacted October 21, 1986).

(emphasis mine)

Users generally entrust the security of online information to a third party, an ISP. In many cases, Fourth Amendment doctrine has held that, in so doing, users relinquish any expectation of privacy. The Third-Party Doctrine holds "…that knowingly revealing information to a third party relinquishes Fourth Amendment protection in that information."

It doesn't follow that a private individual can be compelled to install a pen register on his/her own infrastructure.

Re:CryptoSeal (YC S11) Shutting Down Private VPN by rdl on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @01:35AM (#6589956)
I thought he meant "do us citizens operating services for third parties have to install pen registers". If it is your own service for yourself, they just go a layer down the stack and get your hosting provider or carrier to do so.
Re:CryptoSeal (YC S11) Shutting Down Private VPN by consonants on Monday October 21, 2013 @12:07PM (#6586414)
>New Zealand.

Hahahaha. NZ bent over backwards to let the US decimate mega. Let's be honest, we have/had basically each of those countries be complicit in extraordinary rendition, extradition, or compliance with US IP-law.

What do you honestly think will happen when we, in the name of international security and terrorism prevention, ask them to hand over a few computers instead of, well, people?

Advertised cryptography/anonymizing services really can't exist in a climate where all rules are thrown out the window because terrorists.

Re:CryptoSeal (YC S11) Shutting Down Private VPN by hannibal5 on Monday October 21, 2013 @11:42AM (#6586230)
Five Eyes countries (US, CA, UK, NZ, AU) have very deep intelligence cooperation and sharing agreements. I don't think NZ is particularly good choice for this reason.
Re:CryptoSeal (YC S11) Shutting Down Private VPN by jluster on Monday October 21, 2013 @11:28AM (#6586122)
I don't know about your Iceland, but my Iceland is currently debating putting edge filters up to block "pornogaphy and other questionable content". I understand that the Internet here is just following our outdated laws which levy fines and threaten prison terms to anyone who purchases porn, but any country (even one as enlightened as ours) that contemplates edge router censorship is suspect to me.
Re:CryptoSeal (YC S11) Shutting Down Private VPN by Beltiras on Monday October 21, 2013 @12:36PM (#6586615)
.. and is Ögmundur still in power to follow through?
Re:CryptoSeal (YC S11) Shutting Down Private VPN by jluster on Monday October 21, 2013 @12:48PM (#6586674)
But you know as well as I do that he didn't fall over his censorship dreams but Icesave. Another will come. That we even seriously, politically, considered this is scary in and by itself. Pirate Birgitta isn't enough to reassure me.
Re:CryptoSeal (YC S11) Shutting Down Private VPN by Beltiras on Monday October 21, 2013 @12:59PM (#6586754)
I would say that is a miscategorization of the election results. It's not so much that he was voted out as the electorate falling for the populism of Framsókn.

Of course a party of 3 out of 63 is not going to make big waves legislatively, but the center-right coalition wouldn't touch this issue. Hell, the previous administration didn't want to touch the issue either. Noise, that's all.

Re:CryptoSeal (YC S11) Shutting Down Private VPN by jluster on Monday October 21, 2013 @01:24PM (#6586901)
Fair enough. Maybe I am just a little too sensitive to the broad brush and heavy handed approach we seem to touch everything these days with. Frankly, I love my country, but I sometimes wonder if the Facebook "Iceland is so cool" movement isn't making us, internally, a little to complacent.
Re:CryptoSeal (YC S11) Shutting Down Private VPN by Beltiras on Monday October 21, 2013 @01:47PM (#6587072)
I would respond with saying: Pirates gained 3 seats in Parliament. There IS hope.
Re:CryptoSeal (YC S11) Shutting Down Private VPN by iand on Monday October 21, 2013 @10:50AM (#6585905)
Iceland isn't an online utopia, as the current proposal for online censorship demonstrates: http://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/feb/25/iceland-seeks-i...

Although, for the most part, it has good intentions.

Re:CryptoSeal (YC S11) Shutting Down Private VPN by Beltiras on Monday October 21, 2013 @12:33PM (#6586597)
That bill was DOA, posturing by a politician to appease his left flank. Nobody took it seriously and his party is no longer in power.
Re:CryptoSeal (YC S11) Shutting Down Private VPN by iand on Monday October 21, 2013 @08:13PM (#6589035)
But it's still illegal to publish pornograpy in Iceland isn't it? http://www.althingi.is/lagas/nuna/1940019.html#G210
Re:CryptoSeal (YC S11) Shutting Down Private VPN by Beltiras on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @03:17AM (#6590248)
Yes, it does impinge on freedom of speech locally. No politician is going to move to abolish it (for now), but enforcement is next to non-existent.
Re:CryptoSeal (YC S11) Shutting Down Private VPN by Torgo on Monday October 21, 2013 @07:00PM (#6588758)
It appears also (as best as I can tell without being able to understand Icelandic) that there is a law on the books that makes it prosecutable to 'publicly ridicule an individual or group on the grounds of their "nationality, skin color, race, religion, or sexual orientation."'

I wonder how broadly that could be interpreted. The UK doesn't give me hope.

Re:CryptoSeal (YC S11) Shutting Down Private VPN by chmars on Monday October 21, 2013 @09:42AM (#6585410)
What's the legal situation in Iceland?

Isn't it likely that Iceland has – as all functioning countries – a surveillance apparatus and is cooperating with the US? For the latter, the usual legal trick is not to spy on your own citizens but to ask a partner service for data about your own citizens …

Strict privacy laws can be great, however, they are no protection from surveillance. Surveillance is usually excluded from privacy laws as far as countries are snoopy and not 'just' private entities.

Re:CryptoSeal (YC S11) Shutting Down Private VPN by Beltiras on Monday October 21, 2013 @09:54AM (#6585505)
The dept. of the Interior has been talking about expanded investigatory powers for police but those are aimed at when they can open an investigation without prior cause.

There is no spy agency in Iceland. We are a nation of roughly 350k people. Last interior minister actually sent the FBI packing when they came to investigate something.

Re:CryptoSeal (YC S11) Shutting Down Private VPN by jluster on Monday October 21, 2013 @11:32AM (#6586147)
It is highly unlikely that our current government is colluding with the US. Transparency is too high and anti-American sentiment as well. Don't forget, we're in total about half the size of an average American suburb, everyone knows everyone, there's very little you can gain from spying as opposed to asking.

Spying electronically on Icelanders is a useless and expensive pursuit, if you want to know anything you go downtown and sit around while your average Joe or Jane talk about it.

Re:CryptoSeal (YC S11) Shutting Down Private VPN by typicalrunt on Monday October 21, 2013 @01:04PM (#6586781)
Talking to people? What a concept!

Seriously though, it is amazing how much information can be gleaned from someone (rightly or wrongly) if you just sit down and talk with them for a bit. And even more information about someone's true feeling can be determined from their non-verbal communication, something that electronic surveillance (like email snooping) can do nothing about.

Re:CryptoSeal (YC S11) Shutting Down Private VPN by Beltiras on Monday October 21, 2013 @01:50PM (#6587094)
There's a recurring joke in advertisement in Iceland. If you have a fringe product with a well defined demographical following (say, upper-middle-class females, 40-50), you'd reach them better by throwing a small party with drinks on the house and inviting them than with media advertisement.
Re:CryptoSeal (YC S11) Shutting Down Private VPN by Zigurd on Monday October 21, 2013 @10:30AM (#6585757)
To get a handle on how bad domestic spying is in practical terms, consider that the US outspends the rest of the planet in military spending. Surveillance spending is likely to be roughly proportional. A small nation with low military spending per-capita could fall below the threshold of operating an effective surveillance state, just as they could fall below the threshold of operating a blue-water navy.