News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Barbarians at the Gateways: High-frequency Trading and Ex... by beagle3 on Thursday October 17, 2013 @11:22AM (#6565944)
Just to be clear, HFT these days mean microsecond round trip times between trading algorithms and exchanges.

The situation you describe is thanks to electronic trading, and is also available in financial markets that are not dominated (not to say "infested") by HFT, such as currencies and CFDs.

Re:Barbarians at the Gateways: High-frequency Trading and Ex... by kasey_junk on Thursday October 17, 2013 @11:33AM (#6566025)
There is no industry standard clear definition of HFT. That is part of the problem surrounding any discussion of it. People use the term to mean some mix of the following: - Trading is primarily algorithmic, computers making buy/sell decisions with minimal human intervention. - Trading is high volume with many low quantity orders with short (millisecond, second, minute) hold times. - Trading decisions happen at low latency currently in the sub-microsecond time frame.

It is better to think of these as dials than as hard requirements. Some algorithmic decisions take a very long time to make decisions, other electronic trading systems hold positions for weeks or even months. I've seen very low latency systems that only trade a few times per day.

Finally, your currency trading example is perfect. The reason HFT's are less involved in those markets is that they are known to be dominated by insider deals and old boy network cronyism. It is not a "fair" place to trade. If HFT were to come in that may or may not change. I suspect it would get better.

Re:Barbarians at the Gateways: High-frequency Trading and Ex... by beagle3 on Thursday October 17, 2013 @11:43AM (#6566109)
I think HFT is now universally regarded as "faster than human reaction time", which means the slowest HFT has a <200ms "time constant".

HFT stands for "High Frequency". That has not meant minutes since 2008 at least.

> It is not a "fair" place to trade. If HFT were to come in that may or may not change. I suspect it would get better.

"HFT" and "fair" in the same sentence, with positive connotation. Now, that's funny: HFT in American exchanges these days is an all out, unregulated war of bits, and fairness is not an attribute you can associate with it - see e.g. http://www.nanex.net/aqck2/4329.html ; The reason HFT stays away from currency is not because of being "fair" or "unfair" (no markets are fair, every market has privileged players).

It's just that in currencies, the people you take money from own the system and will kick you out. They make their own rules. Whereas on ARCA and INET, the HFTs are the landlords and make their own rules (by quote stuffing and stuff).

Neither market is regulated against the privileged players.

Re:Barbarians at the Gateways: High-frequency Trading and Ex... by kasey_junk on Thursday October 17, 2013 @11:58AM (#6566201)
Even with your hard constant of <200ms you haven't really specified enough to really talk about HFT with out being more specific. Is your constant the amount of time an algorithm holds inventory? If so tons of low latency systems can and do hold inventory for much longer than that.

Is it the amount of time it takes a computer to make a trading decision? Nearly any modern computerized system in under that time constant, and many non-low latency trades happen in that time frame.

Any electronic trading system (which I think most people agree are good things) will allow for algorithmic trading (how could they not?). The question is should we try to prevent low latency trading? If so, why? And how can we? Will any system we put in place cause more problems than it is worth?

Finally, if you don't think currency markets are fair, why use them as an example where you are getting better prices than you would be otherwise? Currency markets do not provide better pricing to all of their participants than electronic markets with HFT do.

Re:Barbarians at the Gateways: High-frequency Trading and Ex... by beagle3 on Friday October 18, 2013 @09:46AM (#6571308)
> Is it the amount of time it takes a computer to make a trading decision?

It is time from when information becomes available until order goes out. This is a well defined measurement, unlike things about "decisions", which are not well defined.

> The question is should we try to prevent low latency trading? If so, why? And how can we? Will any system we put in place cause more problems than it is worth?

"Low Latency" and "High Frequency" are not equivalent, even though you seem to think so. "Low Latency" relates to one event. "High Frequency" indicates a rapid succession of events (Frequency is a measure repeating phenomena). High frequency does not theoretically imply low latency (or the other way around), but practically the correlation between low latency and high frequency is 100%.

If you follow the nanex links, you'll see the "low latency" players are bullying the "higher latency" players, and should be prevented from doing so.

In fact, many exchanges do that - e.g. Some european future exchanges will fine you if your order:execution ratio is >10. Meaning, you have, on average, to execute 10% of the orders you give. In the US, some players have an 10000:1 order:execution order. We should disallow that - as everyone else pays exchange fees for a faster system to suit these players, and then pays more to have a system that can keep up with the spurious orders these guys send.

Really, Eurex has this trivially solved. Since 2001.

> Finally, if you don't think currency markets are fair,

I do not think they are fair. But they are as good as the equity markets (liquidity and spread wise) without the HFT players - ergo, HFT does not provide the benefits HFT proponents claim it does.

Re:Barbarians at the Gateways: High-frequency Trading and Ex... by kasey_junk on Friday October 18, 2013 @10:17AM (#6571463)
CME, ICE & CBOE (the major US futures exchanges) all enforce fill ratios as well and have for some time.

Fill ratios are not designed to prevent either high frequency or low latency trading, it is there to prevent a particular form of exchange gaming (quote stuffing).

You are not being clear (and you are being condescending) on what you mean by HFT players & what you find objectionable. Is a market maker that trades 40K contracts a day but doesn't quote stuff objectionable? What about a cross exchange latency arbitrage trade that is not spamming exchanges? If so why?

Also, I've traded Eurex. They have very specific interfaces for low latency/high frequency traders. You can order different classes of connectivity from them that are specifically designed for these use cases. They also have predatory algorithms, so I'm not sure what they have solved.

Re:Barbarians at the Gateways: High-frequency Trading and Ex... by beagle3 on Friday October 18, 2013 @11:50AM (#6572023)
> Fill ratios are not designed to prevent either high frequency or low latency trading, it is there to prevent a particular form of exchange gaming (quote stuffing).

They are very effective against quote stuffing, but they also work well against player that leave their quote active in the market for 1ms with high frequency. That's false price signaling, and is independent of quote stuffing (as I'm familiar with it: the practice of throwing so many orders at the exchange that slower players got a lag in their data).

> You are not being clear (and you are being condescending) on what you mean by HFT players & what you find objectionable.

I am specifically talking about HFT players in the US Equity markets - these are the subject of all the HFT discussions on reddit and HN. These do a lot of false signaling, quote stuffing, frontrunning in between exchanges.

> Is a market maker that trades 40K contracts a day but doesn't quote stuff objectionable?

That's fine, as long he is not false signaling either (that is, putting in orders he has no intention of executing)

> What about a cross exchange latency arbitrage trade that is not spamming exchanges? If so why?

This subverts the NBBO system. I believe this should either be illegal, or it should be legal and the NBBO system be canceled. But traders are under the illusion that the NBBO system is protecting them from wasting money to these arbitrageurs, when is isn't.

> Also, I've traded Eurex. They have very specific interfaces for low latency/high frequency traders. You can order different classes of connectivity from them that are specifically designed for these use cases. They also have predatory algorithms, so I'm not sure what they have solved.

The same things: a) quote stuffing, b) false signaling. Being faster costs money, and should provide an advantage - but it should be "neutral".

Is there any way (e.g. quote stuffing) in which you are aware that the faster players on Eurex can causally disadvantage the slower players, like they can in the US Equity markets?

Re:Barbarians at the Gateways: High-frequency Trading and Ex... by kasey_junk on Friday October 18, 2013 @12:25PM (#6572212)
Sure, a very common game right now is quote spoofing (that is already illegal in the US) but still happens and exists on Eurex.

Very fast player X puts a few (<10) big orders on one side of the order book at a level that has some but not a lot of quantity in front of him (using random quantity to make it hard to recognize) making it look like there is more demand than there is.

This will cause other participants to quote at this same level. Once enough orders have been entered behind him, he will yank all of his orders and then cross through that level (or even through 2). He has flipped a level.

His speed allows for 2 properties that make this much easier: 1. He is taking much less risk with his spoofed orders turning into real orders because he can cancel them fast when the market conditions indicate they might get filled. 2. His targets can't catch his cancels/fill through order fast enough to get out of the way.

He can keep his fill ratios within the correct boundaries with no problem.

Re:Barbarians at the Gateways: High-frequency Trading and Ex... by kasey_junk on Friday October 18, 2013 @12:30PM (#6572239)
Also as a contrast to your latency arbitrage point, as a market participant myself, I have no problem paying the latency arbitrage fees. It means that I can shop for trading venues that offer features/fee structures that work best for me, without worrying much about price imbalances.

This is much better for me as a participant than the single exchange monopoly is or having to build up an exchange presence at every exchange.

The competition in that space is so fierce that the cut they are taking from me is much less than the alternatives. For me at least, it is a small price to pay.

Re:Barbarians at the Gateways: High-frequency Trading and Ex... by Mikeb85 on Thursday October 17, 2013 @11:43AM (#6566101)
HFT exploits arbitrage opportunities. This reduces spreads, leading to better execution for everyone.
Re:Barbarians at the Gateways: High-frequency Trading and Ex... by beagle3 on Thursday October 17, 2013 @11:46AM (#6566132)
Ask any HFT person, and they'll tell you less than 1% of their profit is from arbitrage. Unless, of course, you include the practice of quote stuffing (Which causally generates a latency arbitrage against slower players) as part of "arbitrage" - but that's not much different than saying a robber exploits the arbitrage between the fear for your life and willingness to part with the money on your person.
Re:Barbarians at the Gateways: High-frequency Trading and Ex... by anonymoushn on Thursday October 17, 2013 @12:47PM (#6566527)
I can confirm that more than 1% is from arbitrage, and that we do not engage in quote stuffing/flickering/etc.
Re:Barbarians at the Gateways: High-frequency Trading and Ex... by beagle3 on Friday October 18, 2013 @09:47AM (#6571318)
Well, that would be the first I've heard of, a lot of time. Except, I can't really add this to my statistics, because I don't know who you are or what your stats are.

(And no one should trust my assertion either - I'm just as anonymous as the rest of you, and lying for all you know).

Re:Barbarians at the Gateways: High-frequency Trading and Ex... by HockeyPlayer on Friday October 18, 2013 @12:06PM (#6572107)
A majority of our profits come from arbitrage. We don't do any quote stuffing or flickering. It is unethical and illegal.