News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jury says Cuban did not commit insider trading by rosser on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @06:24PM (#6562476)
The jury didn't say he "did not commit insider trading"; they said the government didn't prove that he committed insider trading. They didn't say he's innocent of the charges, but that he's not guilty of them.

There's an important difference between the two.

Re:Jury says Cuban did not commit insider trading by smalter on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @07:57PM (#6562833)
this comment is really off point.

there's no guilty/not guilty/innocence distinction here because this wasn't even a criminal case, it was a civil case.

in addition, the statement "the government didn't prove insider trading" is tantamount to the statement "mark cuban did not commit insider trading" because the case boiled down to a disputed question of fact, and what actually happened is unknowable.

Re:Jury says Cuban did not commit insider trading by joe_the_user on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @09:57PM (#6563248)
Yes gak,

"He wasn't proven innocent" is a rhetorical attack that can be made against virtually anyone who has been tried and not convicted in the US.

Indeed doubly off-topic as this is a civil matter.

But it still should be noted that, given prosecutors in the US have a high (up to 90%+) conviction rate, not being proven guilty is pretty good as far as exoneration goes.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conviction_rate

Re:Jury says Cuban did not commit insider trading by jtreminio on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @07:15PM (#6562685)
Except that in America people are innocent until proven guilty.

In the eyes of the law, he is innocent.

Re:Jury says Cuban did not commit insider trading by gamblor956 on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @07:28PM (#6562726)
No, in the eyes of the law, he is "not guilty." Innocence is a factual finding which has the same burden of proof as guilt because it is a definitive finding that the defendant did not commit the crime charged.

Judges admonish juries that people are "innocent until proven guilty" becaues most jurors aren't sophisticated enough to make the distinction.

Re:Jury says Cuban did not commit insider trading by SeanLuke on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @09:05PM (#6563077)
> Except that in America people are innocent until proven guilty.

This is a slogan, not a legal statement.

Re:Jury says Cuban did not commit insider trading by icebraining on Thursday October 17, 2013 @02:24AM (#6563935)
So when the SCOTUS in Coffin v. United States wrote "The law presumes that persons charged with crime are innocent until they are proven by competent evidence to be guilty," they were just writing a slogan?
Re:Jury says Cuban did not commit insider trading by SeanLuke on Thursday October 17, 2013 @08:05AM (#6564786)
Of course.

This whole debate, which is entirely moot since it's not a criminal trial, arises from the fact that "guilty" and "not guilty" (and "innocent" I guess) have both informal meanings and formal legal meanings, and those meanings are different. The OP used the formal meaning, in a formal context. People tossing about the informal meaning are not adding to the discussion.

Re:Jury says Cuban did not commit insider trading by beambot on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @07:09PM (#6562655)
Can a jury ever find a defendant "innocent"? I thought the only two options were "guilty" and "not guilty".
Re:Jury says Cuban did not commit insider trading by dragonwriter on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @07:16PM (#6562687)
> Can a jury ever find a defendant "innocent"? I thought the only two options were "guilty" and "not guilty".

"innocent" = "not guilty". Guilt is a binary state.

EDIT: Though, as this was a civil case, neither "guilty" nor "not guilty" were possible results.

Re:Jury says Cuban did not commit insider trading by gamblor956 on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @07:34PM (#6562745)
Guilt is a binary state, but a jury's finding of guilt is a trinary state.

Guilty = beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant committed the crime alleged.

Not guilty = the government did not prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant committed the crime alleged

Innocent = beyond a reasonable doubt (i.e., factual impossibility) that the defendant did not commit the crime alleged.

It is exceedingly rare for a jury to make a finding of innocence since (a) few prosecutors will agree to a jury instruction allowing this finding, and (b) if there is the necessary evidence to prove innocence, the judge will throw out the related charges before the decision gets to the jury. If the judge throws out the charge, whether the judge will further make a finding of innocence depends on the defendant--usually the defendant must move the court for such a finding and few do. However, in some jurisdictions judges have the leeway to make that finding without a motion by the defendant.

Re:Jury says Cuban did not commit insider trading by dragonwriter on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @07:47PM (#6562793)
> Guilt is a binary state, but a jury's finding of guilt is a trinary state.

Except in the case of things like the Scottish three-verdict system (which doesn't follow the conditions that you lay out), this is generally not true.

Particularly, in the US, generally "guilty" and "not guilty" are the only possible verdicts in most criminal cases (there are certain cases where "not guilty by reason of insanity" or "guilty but mentally ill" are also available), and there is no verdict that requires proof of innocence beyond a reasonable doubt.

Re:Jury says Cuban did not commit insider trading by SeanLuke on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @09:02PM (#6563070)
The point stands though: "not guilty" in the US is not the same as "innocent". Juries in criminal trials do not determine innocence. They determine whether the government was able to prove its claim of guilt. Just because the government couldn't prove its claim doesn't mean the claim was false.

It's moot anyway: this wasn't a criminal case.

Re:Jury says Cuban did not commit insider trading by dragonwriter on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @09:12PM (#6563103)
> "not guilty" in the US is not the same as "innocent"

Yeah, it is. That's exactly what "not guilty" means.

> They determine whether the government was able to prove its claim of guilt.

Right. Because people are presumed innocent. The failure to overcome the burden of proof to rebut a presumption means that the presumption is true. That's what a legal presumption means.

> It's moot anyway: this wasn't a criminal case.

Agreed. In fact, I said that upthread.

Re:Jury says Cuban did not commit insider trading by obstacle1 on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @11:18PM (#6563496)
>Yeah, it is. That's exactly what "not guilty" means.

No, it isn't. Stop attempting to slaughter language and logic. All "not guilty" means is the state of guilt could not be proven. That does NOT imply innocence.

It is completely possible for a defendant to be guilty of a crime but be found not guilty -- that is, neither innocent nor guilty -- by virtue of lack of evidence, or process error, or whatever.

Here is a professor proving you wrong [1]:

>This means that the jurors found [the defendant] not guilty; it does not mean that they found her innocent. It does not even mean that any or all of them believe she had nothing to do with the demise of her daughter. All it means is that the jury was not convinced beyond a reasonable doubt that Anthony committed the offenses of which she was accused (other than giving false information to the police, the minor charge she was convicted of). In other words, the prosecution failed to meet the high standard to which society holds the state in criminal cases.

And here is a criminal lawyer proving you wrong [2]:

>Juries never find defendants innocent. They cannot. Not only is it not their job, it is not within their power. They can only find them "not guilty." ... A verdict of "not guilty" can mean two entirely different things. It can, of course, mean that you believe the defendant (I would use my client's name) is innocent. However, it can mean something entirely different. A verdict of "not guilty" can mean a verdict of "not proven." Even if you are very sure the defendant is guilty, but the state has not proven it "beyond a reasonable doubt," then it is your sworn duty to return a verdict of "not guilty."

Now will you drop the unjustified arrogance?

[1] - http://articles.philly.com/2011-07-07/news/29747182_1_reason...

[2] - http://www.oregoncriminalattorney.com/Criminal-Defense-Overv...

Re:Jury says Cuban did not commit insider trading by SheepSlapper on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @09:19PM (#6563119)
No, "not guilty" is not the same as "innocent", for the same reasons as posted above. "Not guilty" means we can't prove you're guilty of something, "innocent" means we CAN prove you didn't do it.

"Not guilty" is not a claim to absolute knowledge, where as "innocent" is. And that's an important distinction.

Re:Jury says Cuban did not commit insider trading by rbritton on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @10:37PM (#6563384)
"Not guilty" can also mean that the jury exercised their right to jury nullification.
Re:Jury says Cuban did not commit insider trading by ksherlock on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @08:49PM (#6563028)
In California, there is a Petition for Factual Innocence/Declaration of Factual Innocence. The judge (not the jury) makes the determination.
Re:Jury says Cuban did not commit insider trading by dragonwriter on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @09:09PM (#6563094)
True; the main purpose of the Petition/Declaration of Factual Innocence seems to be to seal (and eventually expunge) arrest/prosecution records and legally allow a person to answer "No" to whether they have ever been arrested or charged with a crime, and it applies to arrests even where no charges were ever filed.
Re:Jury says Cuban did not commit insider trading by stevesearer on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @06:38PM (#6562531)
I was on a jury for a trial involving an alleged dui offense and what you mention is exactly the reason we found the defendant to be not guilty.
Re:Jury says Cuban did not commit insider trading by untog on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @06:52PM (#6562586)
How did that feel? I ask the question very genuinely. It sounds as if you suspected the accused was guilty, but that the evidence did not back it up. How did you feel about letting him go?
Re:Jury says Cuban did not commit insider trading by baddox on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @07:45PM (#6562779)
It's an invented difference that has no observable (as in, non-semantic) manifestations. As far as his legal treatment from here forward, he "did not commit insider trading" to the same extent that my grandmother (who has done no trading whatsoever and has never been accused of such) "did not commit insider trading."
Re:Jury says Cuban did not commit insider trading by lawnchair_larry on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @08:38PM (#6562991)
Most people don't discuss things in terms of their strict legal definition, but in terms of what actually happened. Your comment suggests that I could steal a car, but I am not any more of a car thief than your grandmother until I get caught and convicted. I may not be a Car Thief, but I'm a car thief, which is what really matters.
Re:Jury says Cuban did not commit insider trading by gibwell on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @06:52PM (#6562589)
Who are you to talk when the allegations made against you have never even been heard in court, let alone tried in front of a jury?