News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jury says Cuban did not commit insider trading by lawnchair_larry on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @06:21PM (#6562464)
How do you figure this was SEC bullying? Looks like a clear cut case of insider trading to me.
Re:Jury says Cuban did not commit insider trading by shreyansj on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @06:37PM (#6562523)
How do you figure this is clear cut case of insider trading. What's your evidence to reach that verdict, that the jury apparently failed to see?
Re:Jury says Cuban did not commit insider trading by lawnchair_larry on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @07:59PM (#6562843)
I can't speak for the jury.

Perhaps if you disagree that it's "clear cut", you at least agree that it was plausible. It wasn't simply bullying, that seems certain.

His defense was not that he didn't trade based on a tip, but that he never agreed to keep the tip confidential, and he challenged the definition of what an insider is.

This is a technicality. That's the problem with insider trading laws - "insider" isn't really defined. So, although it's often common sense and most people can make a judgment call on the spirit of the law, this often won't be sufficient for a trial. Still, this doesn't mean the SEC is wrong to pursue such cases.

Re:Jury says Cuban did not commit insider trading by tedunangst on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @07:43PM (#6562770)
It's possible for an action to look like clear cut insider trading, but not be. I don't it's SEC bullying for them to investigate things that look like clear cut insider trading. That's why we have the trial, after all, to determine if the action is what it looked like.
Re:Jury says Cuban did not commit insider trading by dmazin on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @07:02PM (#6562626)
The evidence is the testimony that Cuban was told by the CEO about the offering. The jury needed to believe it beyond reasonable doubt, but we don't need to because as individuals, our tolerance for coincidence is much lower than it is for juries.
Re:Jury says Cuban did not commit insider trading by staunch on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @07:11PM (#6562666)
Actually, since this is civil I think the bar is lower than in a criminal case. They probably only needed to prove that he's guilty based on the "preponderance of the evidence". Essentially that it's more likely he did it than he did not do it.

Just knowing the timing alone would suggest a greater than 50% chance of him being guilty to me. I'd convict him in 5 minutes.

Re:Jury says Cuban did not commit insider trading by mcherm on Thursday October 17, 2013 @12:53AM (#6563742)
How on earth does the timing affect this?

The government's claim: Mark Cuban was on a phone call where he was told information and promised not to trade based on it. He immediately went out and sold his stock.

Mark Cuban's claim: Mark Cuban was on a phone call where he was told information but didn't promise anything. He immediately went out and sold his stock.

Both of these claims would exhibit the same timing, so I don't see how timing can help decide the important question, which was whether he was technically an "insider" for the purpose of the law.

Re:Jury says Cuban did not commit insider trading by staunch on Thursday October 17, 2013 @03:05AM (#6564016)
Guilty I say. Off with his head!
Re:Jury says Cuban did not commit insider trading by dkl on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @06:40PM (#6562539)
I'm surprised to find not one defense of Mark like there was in the original thread a few weeks ago, when the trial started. At that time, there were a bunch of people with very specific arguments why it wasn't insider trading. I don't remember the specifics, but I remember reading and I found them interesting.
Re:Jury says Cuban did not commit insider trading by satori99 on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @07:54PM (#6562819)
IIRC it was to do with Cuban never having agreed to receive the information in confidence.
Re:Jury says Cuban did not commit insider trading by mcherm on Thursday October 17, 2013 @12:49AM (#6563735)
That's certainly how the article explained it.
Re:Jury says Cuban did not commit insider trading by rverghes on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @07:40PM (#6562764)
This is a pretty good overview of the case for Cuban:

http://www.professorbainbridge.com/professorbainbridgecom/20...

Apparently, simply owning stock is not enough to make you an "insider". You have to be a fiduciary (i.e. be an officer, or a controlling shareholder, or on the board, or similar), or owe a fiduciary duty to the company.

Re:Jury says Cuban did not commit insider trading by lawnchair_larry on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @08:34PM (#6562981)
This is a good overview, but a few things to note:

- Cuban was the largest shareholder

- Cuban was told that the company planned to offer a deal that allowed for more purchases at a 10% discount, diluting his stock. He was told this before the public announcement, and sold his stock the day before the public announcement.

None of this was really disputed. What was disputed was whether or not Cuban had a conversation that acknowledged he was an insider and that he couldn't sell, and whether or not there was an implied confidentiality agreement. This would suggest admission of guilt as well as satisfy the "misappropriation" definition of insider in the article you linked, since they couldn't satisfy the fiduciary definition.

So, he traded based on non-public, adverse information, and saved himself from a substantial loss. Despite this, the SEC failed to convince the jury that he fit any formal definition of "insider".

I think we can all agree that whoever bought all of his stock prior to the public announcement of the dilution did not have his advantage, and his advantage came solely from a position of privilege within the company.

Re:Jury says Cuban did not commit insider trading by Dylan16807 on Thursday October 17, 2013 @04:01AM (#6564144)
- Cuban was the largest shareholder

That really doesn't matter, since it was a puny 6%.