News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Square Cash by MBCook on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @09:19PM (#6557440)
Note that it takes 1-2 days for the deposit. They must be using ACH to do this. The 'free' part is great. Even with Square, I'd be hesitant to enter my debit card number.

Planet Money recently did a great episode all about the US's ACH system and why it works the way it does.

http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2013/10/04/229224964/episode-...

Re:Square Cash by avree on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @09:51PM (#6557562)
The deposit is instant and it does not use ACH.

Here's another comment that describes someone's actual experience with the product: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6557516

Re:Square Cash by kapilkale on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @09:57PM (#6557588)
Faster transfers are possible. Some companies (Kabbage maybe?) are able to do same day or instant transfers without wiring.

I believe it's done by opening bank accounts at major banks, and then using the interbank transfer system which is instantaneous and only requires an account number and a name. Other services offer pushes to credit cards or debit cards using bill pay systems or blind credits.

It isn't actually that hard to move money from person to person. The real issues with this sort of stuff are: a) payments fraud b) money transmission law and regulatory compliance

Re:Square Cash by MBCook on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @10:20PM (#6557661)
Based on the comment above that tried it, your theory of transferring between accounts in the same bank (and then reconciling later) would make sense.

The Planet Money podcast noted that some banks (Capital One, BoA) offer a similar service if both ends have accounts.

Re:Square Cash by pranavpiyush on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @01:39AM (#6558193)
Yep - Kapil is correct. Any serious payments company manages accounts in various banks and uses its internal systems to manage credits and debits at the individual account level.
Re:Square Cash by seanharper on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @10:12PM (#6557628)
They are not using ACH for this, but rather probably using the PIN-debit networks such as star, interlink, nyce and accel.
Re:Square Cash by seanharper on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @10:25PM (#6557676)
There is actually the capability to do an instant transfer over visa and mastercard networks as well, but it is somewhat expensive (>0.20) -- the pin debit networks are smaller and more willing to negotiate this sort of thing, and since most debit cards are able to process on more than one pin debit network you can get 100% coverage with just a couple of the pin debit networks playing ball.

That they are not allowing this for credit cards indicates that they are using the pin debit networks.

Re:Square Cash by dram on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @03:13AM (#6558425)
This says that debit cards are "online transactions" that could cost 10 cents vs 2% for an "offline" credit transaction - http://banking.about.com/od/checkingaccounts/a/debitvscredit...

I believe the transaction fee is higher and there's a percentage rate taken for non-pin debit card transactions.

Re:Square Cash by rafekett on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @12:22AM (#6558000)
> That they are not allowing this for credit cards indicates that they are using the pin debit networks.

not necessarily. you can't think of any other reasons why they'd do this?

Re:Square Cash by aioprisan on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @11:50PM (#6557910)
but they don't actually require a PIN number to complete the transaction, so that's probably now how it works, right?
Re:Square Cash by usaphp on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @09:51PM (#6557561)
> Even with Square, I'd be hesitant to enter my debit card number.

Are you afraid of entering your debit card number? How do you make purchases online?

Re:Square Cash by lbarrow on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @10:02PM (#6557597)
I'm going to guess with credit cards.

Credit card numbers are much safer to use online than debit cards, mostly because credit card dispute mechanisms give consumers a lot more power. If a merchant behaves in an unsavory way, with a credit card you can usually just call your bank, issue a chargeback and that's the end of it. You can't do that with a debit card.

Re:Square Cash by MichaelApproved on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @11:19PM (#6557823)
This is wrong.

You absolutely CAN dispute charges with debit cards. The problem OP might have with debit cards could be that a fraudulent charge temporarily locks cash funds (with debit card) instead of credit availability (with credit card).

Re:Square Cash by encoderer on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @02:01AM (#6558246)
You're oversimplifying.

There are wide differences in consumer protections between credit and debit cards.

The list of reasons for a valid chargeback on a debit card is much more narrow than a credit card. For example, suppose you purchase a tablet online and when you get the package, you sign for it, open it, and it's a paperweight. If you charged that on your debit card you're out of luck and will have to go to small claims court. On a credit card -- especially a good credit card -- the charge would be reversed. The issue there is that you signed for the package. If you don't believe that, give your bank's fraud dept a call, and then your credit card companies.

American Express obviously is great for consumer protections but truthfully any Visa Signature card offers a competent level of service.

Personally, I would never use a debit card online (or anywhere else for that matter) and would advise anybody against it. Not to mention, you can earn some fantastic cashback/mileage benefits. My wife and I are flying next spring to Europe, first class from San Francisco, over $20k in airfare, for only $2500 out of pocket for taxes and surcharges. To earn this we've spent $40k between 2 British Air cards in 15 months.

Re:Square Cash by bloopletech on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @02:29AM (#6558305)
I will only point out that you're paying for this kind of convenience in getting your money back - and the cheap flights - somewhere.
Re:Square Cash by tedunangst on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @02:46AM (#6558359)
Somebody is paying for it. Maybe not (only) the person getting cheap flights.
Re:Square Cash by encoderer on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @04:08AM (#6558543)
Ted has it right. Consumers with comprimised credit pay for the benefits given to consumers that the CC companies see as more desirable. I'm not one who believes in not taking a bite at the apple when everybody else is.
Re:Square Cash by lbarrow on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @01:08AM (#6558113)
Ah, thanks for the clarification.
Re:Square Cash by DannyBee on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @02:36AM (#6558326)
Actually, that is not the real reason credit cards are safer :)

You can dispute most debit card transactions now.

Besides the "one is availability of credit, the other, real money", there is a liability difference.

It used to be, at one point, that debit card liability was essentially unlimited but a consumer's liability for fraud on their credit card was limited to $50 by federal law (see 15 USC ยง 1643). Debit card liability now has a maximum as well, but your maximum liability actually depends on how quickly you notify.

If it's within two days, it's $50 liability on a debit card, but if you notify past that, they could legally make you liable for up to $500.

(There are other liability generating situations that exist for debit cards but not credit cards)

Re:Square Cash by MBCook on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @10:17PM (#6557648)
As lbarrow said, I use a credit card. It used to be that debit cards offered almost no protection. I think they're competitive with credit cards now, but that may only be when you're using it like a credit card. I don't know if this would count towards my fraud protection (which, honestly, I know nothing about).

Really, it's because I use my credit card as a firewall account. If my credit card gets compromised (which has happened twice before), I have to change maybe a dozen things that link to it. It's an inconvenience, but my bank can get me a new card the next day. Worst case scenario I lose my credit card for a week or so.

If my checking account is compromised, things are worse. If my checking account gets locked, not only can I not use it, I also can't pay my credit card. I'd have to setup my paycheck (pain), rent (pain), and some other things. Then I'd have to re-link a couple of other bank accounts. While I like my current bank, I don't want to take the risk of that account being locked for a week.

The idea of giving a random website (in that I don't have an account/relationship with them) a number that provides direct access to my paycheck gives me the shivers.

You could do basically the same thing with ACH. If a payment service asked you to enter your routing and account numbers, would you be OK with that? I see it as the same thing.

Re:Square Cash by foxylad on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @10:29PM (#6557682)
As a non-USAsian, I'm always puzzled by the American's paranoia about their bank account details.

In most countries, bank account numbers are effectively public knowledge, and appear at the bottom of invoices and such. The trick is that with this knowledge you can pay money in to an account, but you can't get it out - for that you need authorisation. This makes paying via echeck or direct credit very easy.

Am I right that in the US you can get money out of an account if you know the account number? If not, why the secrecy about your bank account numbers?

Re:Square Cash by thaumasiotes on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @10:53PM (#6557768)
Yes, in the US you can take money out of an account if you know the number. No, it's not a good system.
Re:Square Cash by aioprisan on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @11:53PM (#6557921)
Actually, you can't just take funds out. How would you do that, counterfeit a check and commit fraud by cashing it in? The bank ATMs/teller machines would reject that check and you'd find yourself in prison very quickly.
Re:Square Cash by wiredfool on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @01:43AM (#6558203)
Actually, you can.

1) ACH. Everyone has mentioned that already. I'd need routing and account number, and likely need to know if it's checking/savings or business/personal. Like they've said, everything that I can find on a check. You could contest it for ~ 60 days, but you'd have to sign something at the bank, and you're out the money till you do.

2) Drafts. They're like checks, but not. Some health clubs (Curves, iirc) do this as well as some other less reputable businesses. Basically, once you sign an authorization (that they keep on file, not like it gets passed to the bank or anything), they can print a check like thing and put some specific language in the signature block area, and deposit it. Typically, this is done in bulk. Often times, it's then immediately converted into an electronic equivalent check (Check21 law) and then deposited in one big file. Return rates on these are astronomical. Most banks won't touch them. They should die.

Re:Square Cash by thaumasiotes on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @12:07AM (#6557955)
You use the system backing check processing, ACH. Theoretically, this is similar to counterfeiting a check, except:

- these are electronic requests, so there's nothing to distinguish "genuine" from "fraudulent" ones

- you really do have all of the information that goes into an ACH payment

Really, it's much more similar to forging a check than to counterfeiting one.

Re:Square Cash by aioprisan on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @12:22AM (#6557999)
What service allows you to specify a debit from an account that's not authorized, in hte US? No bank that I've even used provides that, nor does an online service or API without first authorizing a debit via ACH with the deposit confirmation.
Re:Square Cash by tedunangst on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @02:40AM (#6558343)
deposit confirmation seems to have disappeared. I pay several of my bills (including rent, kind of a biggie) via direct withdrawal and never confirmed the account. Just went to a website one day, typed in some numbers, and clicked pay. (oh, I did have to mark the checkbox that says "I authorize this payment", but that doesn't seem like foolproof security to me.)
Re:Square Cash by bdegman on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @11:30PM (#6557861)
I'm no expert by any means but aren't the account number and routing number both printed on the bottom of every check? Are you saying that simply giving a check to someone compromises your checking account?
Re:Square Cash by thaumasiotes on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @11:37PM (#6557878)
Yes, they are printed on the bottom of checks because they are the information that allows conversion of the check into money. Yes, giving a check to someone compromises your account. You're trusting the other person to do nothing other than withdraw the amount on the check, but you're giving them enough information to withdraw whatever you have in your account.
Re:Square Cash by encoderer on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @02:07AM (#6558258)
And be charged with a crime for it. That's the other part. Not just trust.
Re:Square Cash by MichaelApproved on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @11:34PM (#6557869)
Remember that the person you're replying to said "which, honestly, I know nothing about".

To remove money from a US account, you also need authorization. The trick thieves use is to lie about having authorization. In that case, it's fraud.

I don't know of many fraudulent transactions that can't be reversed. Even fraudulent/unauthorized wire transfers can be reversed. The bigger problem is the hassle that comes with losing access to cash while the situation is resolved.

Can someone with actual banking knowledge correct me where I'm wrong and clear up this confusion?

Re:Square Cash by MBCook on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @10:41PM (#6557720)
It may be a historical thing. Whenever you get a receipt from an ATM or a store, your account number if blocked out (so you end up with "XXXXXXXX9585") for privacy reasons. I honestly don't know dangerous exposing my account numbers would be. Consumer protection laws can be hit-or-miss (or, in many cases, just plain missing). It's easier to just be careful.
Re:Square Cash by eli on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @09:46PM (#6557544)
I don't think they're using ACH, at least not exclusively. You can't do an ACH transfer with a debit card number.