1) ACH. Everyone has mentioned that already. I'd need routing and account number, and likely need to know if it's checking/savings or business/personal. Like they've said, everything that I can find on a check. You could contest it for ~ 60 days, but you'd have to sign something at the bank, and you're out the money till you do.
2) Drafts. They're like checks, but not. Some health clubs (Curves, iirc) do this as well as some other less reputable businesses. Basically, once you sign an authorization (that they keep on file, not like it gets passed to the bank or anything), they can print a check like thing and put some specific language in the signature block area, and deposit it. Typically, this is done in bulk. Often times, it's then immediately converted into an electronic equivalent check (Check21 law) and then deposited in one big file. Return rates on these are astronomical. Most banks won't touch them. They should die.
- these are electronic requests, so there's nothing to distinguish "genuine" from "fraudulent" ones
- you really do have all of the information that goes into an ACH payment
Really, it's much more similar to forging a check than to counterfeiting one.
To remove money from a US account, you also need authorization. The trick thieves use is to lie about having authorization. In that case, it's fraud.
I don't know of many fraudulent transactions that can't be reversed. Even fraudulent/unauthorized wire transfers can be reversed. The bigger problem is the hassle that comes with losing access to cash while the situation is resolved.
Can someone with actual banking knowledge correct me where I'm wrong and clear up this confusion?
In most countries, bank account numbers are effectively public knowledge, and appear at the bottom of invoices and such. The trick is that with this knowledge you can pay money in to an account, but you can't get it out - for that you need authorisation. This makes paying via echeck or direct credit very easy.
Am I right that in the US you can get money out of an account if you know the account number? If not, why the secrecy about your bank account numbers?